Former President Joe Biden famously said that being a big-city mayor is “the hardest job in American politics.” At other times, he went farther, quipping (in a classic Bidenism), “I never had an interest in being a mayor ‘cause that's a real job. You have to produce."
I would add that, in addition to producing results that improve the lives of everyday people, city executives must balance the needs, wants, incentives and petty rivalries of a truly enormous number and variety of stakeholders, from corporate and non-profit executives to union and party bosses to activists and community leaders. I have been rather deeply involved in the civic life of Pittsburgh for nearly half a decade now, and I feel like I comprehend roughly one-fiftieth of the complexity of this (unusually complicated for its size) civic ecosystem.
These days, except in extraordinary circumstances, a mayor does not impose his or her policy preferences by force of will. The bully pulpit no longer conveys that kind of authority. That means the job comes with enormous responsibilities and public expectations, but the power to fulfill those responsibilities and expectations is hemmed in on every side.
This is why I have come to believe that a mayor in today’s world can only succeed by cultivating a spirit of partnership: joining forces with private-sector institutions, or forging relationships among private actors, in ways that respect everyone’s incentives and limitations in order to achieve public goods.
Last week’s announcement by Mayor Corey O’Connor of $55 million in financial commitments from Highmark and UPMC is the clearest example yet that this mayor understands both the power and the limits of his office. And that’s the only way to get things done.
Priming the pump
Luke Ravenstahl sued UPMC over its nonprofit status. Bill Peduto pursued but later abandoned that suit, seeing it (rightly) as fruitless, and forged the complex and controversial OnePGH compact with the city’s big non-profits. Ed Gainey ditched that and tried to challenge primarily UPMC’s individual properties, in a gambit that cost the city more in legal fees than it generated in new annual income.
Read More
Yet six months into office, Corey O’Connor got the healthcare giants to pony up a total of $11 million a year for the next half-decade, earmarked for fire and EMS vehicles and equipment, seemingly without breaking a sweat.
What changed?
It’s partially that O’Connor’s predecessors (unwittingly) prepared the ground for him. By exhausting the city’s apparent legal recourse to extract actual taxes from the non-profits — even if the efforts were always quixotic — previous mayors liberated O’Connor to pursue a non-tax deal that might previously have been seen as capitulation.
Some still see it that way, wishing the city would force UPMC et al to cough up taxes. The mechanism by which Pittsburgh is to override state and federal law, however, is never explained. This is the kind of fantasy politics O’Connor has rightly rejected.
Aligning the incentives
In the real world, there has only ever been one plausible solution to Pittsburgh’s nonprofit free-riding situation: 1) book a conference room; 2) invite nonprofit leaders; 3) talk like adults.
While filling in at KDKA Radio last week, I spoke with O’Connor about how the deal came together. The most important thing he said — so simple but so refreshing to hear — was that he and his team had to respect the incentives and limitations of their negotiating partners. Just as he has to answer to voters, they have to answer to their boards. He couldn’t force them to do something they aren’t free to do.
The breakthrough was coming to the healthcare giants directly with healthcare-related uses for their gifts. This not only removed the main sticking point — distrust over the use of funds within the city’s messy budget — but gave UPMC and Highmark a positive incentive to strike a deal: They can tell their boards and the public that they are advancing their healthcare mission by partnering with Pittsburgh.
O’Connor also mentioned that Gov. Josh Shapiro played a role in brokering the deal, a natural role for the one-time attorney general who brokered peace between UPMC and Highmark in 2019. The mayor also let slip that the governor had been part of a previous deal, presumably during the Gainey administration, that fell through.
Mastering the job?
The essential point is that everybody feels like they won, or at least didn’t lose. Appearing to force institutions like UPMC to “capitulate” might bring a certain satisfaction, but it was always beyond the power of Pittsburgh to achieve.
Further, would it even be for the best for everyday residents? While we can argue about the broader structure of healthcare in America, within that structure the people of Pittsburgh are better off when city government, Highmark and UPMC are all stronger. And they’re stronger when they work together.
For the first six months, O’Connor has made this all look pretty easy. He might be tempted to think he’s mastered “the hardest job in American politics.”
That is, of course, exactly how it comes crashing down. Incentives and interests don’t always align so clearly. He and his team will be faced with much more demanding challenges. They already are: Just look at the problem of “teen takeovers.”
Yet O’Connor inherited a city where a spirit of antagonism has prevailed over a spirit of partnership for too long. There’s pent-up energy to making things happen — together. And he appears to be well-suited to the moment.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Saying goodbye to the wonder of the Arctic at the Carnegie.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.