While the lore behind the framing of Allegheny County home rule is complex and the people who participated often fractious, everyone who was there at the beginning agrees on this: County Council was meant to be a weak body of citizen-legislators, not a clone of the full-time, high-responsibility Pittsburgh City Council.

It’s right there in the county’s charter, ratified by voters in 1999. Council’s 15 members “shall not receive a salary but may receive per-meeting stipends not to exceed in the aggregate $9,000 annually” and “shall not be entitled to receive any County funding for personal staff, local district offices or fringe benefits,” while the legislature’s overall budget “shall not exceed four-tenths of one percent of the County's annual locally levied tax revenues.”

In the years since, however, the county’s legislature has become busier and much more visible. During the last term of former county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, council picked fights with the executive branch on issues from reopening Shuman (now Highland) Detention Center to wages for county workers.

While these were typically seen as progressive challenges to centrist governance, they also were meant, as I wrote three years ago, to “reshape the balance of power in county government” and ultimately to “break the bounds set by the Home Rule Charter.”

Advertise with us

Now County Council is no longer just trying to press against or even break those bounds, but eliminate them altogether. Indeed, it’s hard to argue that the legislature, after 2½ decades of political evolution, should remain the one envisioned by its framers.

Breaking the chains

This week, council members voted to allow the county’s citizenry to strike two subsections of the Home Rule Charter: the prohibition on funding for staff, offices and benefits, as well as the limit on council expenditures of 0.4% of tax revenues.

The part-time per-meeting stipend was already amended in a close vote in 2023 to a part-time salary of around $11,000, regardless of the number of meetings attended. Further adjustments, such as seeking full-time pay, are not being targeted this go around, presumably because it would be a harder sell to get voters to approve huge raises for 15 council members — even if that would be in keeping with the legislature the members envision.

The measures will appear as two separate questions on the ballot this Nov. 3. It will take only a majority of the vote to amend the charter.

This is the culmination (for now) of years of frustration and directed efforts to unleash the apparently latent power of the county’s legislature. Councilman Paul Klein said as much in his remarks on Tuesday: “I think what we’re doing with this is looking to be liberated from the constraints of the Home Rule Charter so we can get closer to having a co-equal branch of government.”

Advertise with us

Yet a co-equal branch is not what anyone involved with framing home rule envisioned back in 1999. The idea was a strong, efficient executive to manage brass-tacks governance, with council as little more than a consultative and oversight body, representing the interests of the county’s 130 municipalities (and 90 city neighborhoods) to its government. How did we get here?

Power play

Mostly it was the natural process of the expansion of the power of a political institution, absent a countervailing force. While the idea of a “citizen legislature” might be “romantic,” as at-large Councilman Alex Rose rather contemptuously put it on Tuesday evening, once the citizens have taken their seats, they naturally want more.

The only countervailing force was the county executive, whose only weapon was the law — specifically, the Home Rule Charter. And, despite the best efforts of its framers, on a variety of issues the charter provided legitimate scope for more robust legislative responsibilities.

It didn’t hurt that, due to gerrymandering and shifts in political geography, County Council has become an overwhelmingly Democratic body, now 14-1. (The old county commissioners system, almost always with two Democrats and one Republican, was more representative of the partisan makeup of the electorate.) The party — and, more specifically, young progressive members of the party — has come to see County Council as an effective nursery for ambitious left-wing pols.

Yet the most important moment of all in this process was the 2019 election of one progressive in particular, Bethany Hallam, as council’s at-large Democrat. She brought the energy of a full-time political activist to the part-time role, spurring her colleagues to press against the charter and the executive while generating momentum for left-wing causes. And she discovered, whether by strategy or by accident, the cheat code within the “citizen legislature”: If your day job is as an activist, you can essentially become a full-time councilor and run rings around everyone else.

Advertise with us

Second thoughts?

So, should the voters remove more shackles from County Council? Reluctantly, I think the answer is yes.

I love the idea of the “citizen legislature,” but in practice it was naive about the nature of political ambition while the charter was too easy to interpret in favor of expanded legislative powers.

As it stands, County Council is an awkward institution. It has accrued many more responsibilities than its structure allows it to effectively fulfill. Among those responsibilities, like legislators at other levels of government in Pennsylvania, is providing constituent services, which requires staff to do well.

This expansion will stress the finances of a thinly resourced government, one that just raised property taxes 36% in 2025. But it’s hard to see how the County Council of 2026 can function without it, no matter what people in 1999 thought.

Which raises a deeper question: If this is the end result of home rule — an expensive, muscular, activist legislature — was home rule a good idea to begin with? Montgomery County, which grows closer to Allegheny’s size each year, seems to work just fine with three commissioners.

Advertise with us

There are, however, only two ways to trigger a rethink of home rule: a petition signed by over 45,000 voters — or an ordinance passed by County Council itself.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “What the resurgence of the Whiskey Rebellion says about Western Pa.”