In “Ready or not, here come the reassessments,” Brandon McGinley jokingly suggested that becoming an expert on property tax assessments requires “a pilgrimage to a mountaintop in Tibet.” As someone who has traveled through Tibet and, more importantly, works in Pittsburgh real estate, I can say his analysis is misguided.
The real solution is to grow the economic pie, not increase the tax burden on residents, many of whom already struggle with affordability.
McGinley’s central flaw is confusing market value with ability to pay. A homeowner’s property value may rise dramatically on paper while their income remains unchanged.
Higher property taxes risk accelerating the very trends already weakening Pittsburgh. Middle-class families who have flexibility will continue leaving for suburban communities with lower taxes and stronger schools, further hollowing out Pittsburgh Public Schools and shrinking the city’s long-term tax base.
The underlying issue is lack of growth. We are debating reassessments because Pittsburgh faces stagnant population growth, declining office values, and the resulting fiscal pressure — not because longtime homeowners are undertaxed freeloaders.
More residents mean more homeowners, more workers, more occupied office space and ultimately a broader and healthier tax base. New homebuyers already purchase at market values and are taxed accordingly. The city should focus on attracting residents and investment by making Pittsburgh more affordable, not less.
If Pittsburgh continues raising the cost of ownership instead of expanding opportunity, we risk pushing out exactly the people needed to sustain the city’s future.
JEREMY SMERD
Squirrel Hill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.