On a clear day in August 1958, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. visited Pittsburgh’s Wylie Avenue.

Deacon Ernest Darby, now 88, was there, watching King driving up to Central Baptist Church in a single car; there was no entourage.

The church, overflowing with about 2,200 people, was buzzing, Mr. Darby recalled last week as he pointed to the back of the room where he sat during King’s sermon. The church seats only about 1,800, he said, forcing hundreds to stand.

“People were standing up and just waiting to hear what he had to say to this community, and also to this country,” he said.

Advertise with us
Central Baptist Church on Wiley Avenue in the Hill District will be 135 years old in July. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Central Baptist Church looks — and feels — almost the same today as it did when the civil rights leader spoke to the congregation decades ago, Mr. Darby said. It has new red upholstery on its long rows of wooden pews, but the stained glass windows, engraved cross and Biblical quotes on its walls are the same as when King visited.

Church leaders say the challenges facing the community haven’t changed much, either.

“If you blindfolded yourself, you would feel that you’re back in those times,” said the Rev. Courtney Meadows, seated on a pew next to Mr. Darby, as the two reflected on the church’s past and future a few days before Martin Luther King Jr. Day on Monday.

There is a resurgence of racism today, he said, and disparities still remain for many in the community.

“That’s why the exchange of history is so important,” he said.

Advertise with us
The Rev. Courtney Meadows said the history of Central Baptist Church in the Hill District as an “epicenter of Black life” is what brought him to Pittsburgh from Alabama. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Rev. Meadows, 32, has been preaching at Central Baptist for just under a year. He is originally from Montgomery, Ala., where King was a pastor at a Baptist church at around the same age and amid the Montgomery Bus Boycott — a mass movement against racial segregation on public transit.

Rev. Meadows, who became Central Baptist’s pastor last February, said the history of the church as an “epicenter of Black life” is what brought him to Pittsburgh.

“It is because of Dr. King’s visit,” he said, “And because of [the church’s] voice in the community, standing up for issues of racism and a more equitable society.”

‘Creative trouble’

King was not far from Central Baptist during his first visit to Pittsburgh two years before Mr. Darby saw him speak.

He was a young pastor when he addressed youth members of Ebenezer Baptist Church in the Hill District 70 years ago, and relatively unknown on the national stage, said Sam Black, director of the African American Program at the Sen. John Heinz History Center. 

Advertise with us

“This was really his start in civil rights organizing,” Mr. Black said.

At the time of that visit, King was already several months into leading the bus boycott. Coming to Pittsburgh gave him an opportunity to garner support for the boycott outside of Alabama, Mr. Black said.

The Rev. Cornell Talley, pastor of Central Baptist Church, greets The Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. during King's visit to the church in 1958. This picture is displayed at the church. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In May 1956, the destruction of the lower Hill was already under way — people were moved out and buildings were demolished, Mr. Black said, a "catastrophic shift” that displaced thousands of people. The urban redevelopment project cleared the way for building of the Civic Arena, which has since been replaced by PPG Paints Arena.

The leveling of the community still haunts the Hill District, as gentrification poses barriers to upward mobility, said Rev. Meadows.

“These challenges that we face today are not new, and the strategies even more must be reclaimed,” he said.

Advertise with us

King came to Central Baptist two years later. Cornell Talley, who died in 1989, was Central Baptist’s reverend at the time, and the two had a longstanding relationship. 

“These challenges that we face today are not new, and the strategies even more must be reclaimed.”

The Rev. Courtney Meadows

Talley was a leader, too. “He stretched his wings, and he got ahold of the problems in the community, and he had solutions for them,” Mr. Darby said. “He was a charmer.”

Talley helped to organize the Freedom Jubilee at Forbes Field, a fundraising event for the NAACP that attracted thousands of people, according to Mr. Black.

King was the main speaker. Numerous awards were presented, including honors to Pittsburgh Pirates great Roberto Clemente and to heavyweight boxing champion Floyd Patterson, according to a 1961 Post-Gazette article covering the event.

“I don’t mind being a troublemaker if it’s creative trouble I’m bringing about,” King told the Post-Gazette at the time. “I think it’s necessary to bring on tension, so long as there is non-violence.”

Advertise with us

King’s last visit to Pittsburgh took him to the University of Pittsburgh in 1966, where he addressed about 2,000 students. 

Martin Luther King Jr. speaks at the University of Pittsburgh, circa 1966. (Ross Catanza / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘A Knock at Midnight’

Rev. Meadows said he worries that Central Baptist Church is not the force it was during King’s time.

“What I hope is that we can … put boots back on the ground,” he said. “You hear a whole lot of people talking about his dream, but Dr. King woke up and he decided to take meaningful steps.”

The church, which will be 135 years old in July, had about 1,800 members when King spoke. Today, there’s about 800 in the congregation.

Still, Central Baptist, known as the “beacon on the hill,” has remained a constant for Hill District residents such as Mr. Darby, who has lived in the neighborhood all his life.

Advertise with us
Central Baptist has remained a constant for Hill District residents such as Ernest Darby, who has lived in the neighborhood all his life. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“[My parents] brought me in as a child in a cradle,” he said. “I’ve been here ever since.”

Rev. Meadows said he hopes to re-energize the community by partnering with other churches.

“I hope that Central can be a part of not just in the building of individual faith, but reclaiming collective community,” he said.

And he’s looking to King as a guide.

The sermon King delivered on that day in 1958 was called “A Knock at Midnight” — a speech he gave across the country — showcasing the need to answer calls for help during a dark time. 

Advertise with us

“Dr. King is saying America is at a ‘midnight,’ and there are individuals knocking at the door of the church asking for help,” Rev. Meadows said. 

“Central is still responding to the knocks at midnight, as we are once again in a ‘midnight season.’”

Now, years later, Rev. Meadows said King’s sermon is more relevant than ever.

“I wish I could deliver it again,” he said.