Part two of a two-part series.

Speculation that Jason Lando would be Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor’s pick for police chief began almost as soon as the former City Council member clinched the Democratic primary in May.

That council would ultimately sign off on the nomination seemed all but certain. Mr. Lando was a popular figure among colleagues, community leaders and many in city government during his 21 years with Pittsburgh police, and some in those groups had been dismayed when he was passed over for chief in 2023.

His good reputation has largely preceded him.

Advertise with us

Days after he had worked his last day as chief in Frederick, Md., however, a report from the Frederick County Sheriff’s Office surfaced indicating the then-chief had been investigated over anonymous, disparaging text messages he allegedly sent to a retired police corporal.

Mr. Lando, 48, was already set to face myriad struggles within the Pittsburgh department: Ranks that have dwindled to their lowest in years, revolving-door leadership, and a citywide financial crisis sure to squeeze the bureau’s budget — all combining to demoralize remaining officers.

He will face an interview — likely under oath — with a City Council still feeling frayed by painful budget decisions and burned by the last chief who came before them. And now that interview likely will include pointed questions about Mr. Lando’s alleged behavior in Maryland.

The sheriff’s incident report, released to members of the Frederick police union by the recipient of the text messages, indicates the investigation concerned the misdemeanor crime of telephone misuse.

Six messages were sent intermittently over the course of about five weeks in July and early August. The texts were sent via the “Burner” app, which allows users to create and utilize temporary, disposable phone numbers. The investigation linked the burner numbers to Mr. Lando’s personal cell phone number.

Advertise with us

The investigation was forwarded to the state prosecutor’s office, which, according to a letter sent to Mr. Lando’s attorney Dec. 2 and shared with the Post-Gazette, found “no violations of criminal law.” The case has been closed.

Mr. Lando has alleged the retired corporal is the one who has waged a campaign of harassment against him: He told the Post-Gazette the corporal was dissatisfied with discipline the then-chief meted out. The corporal has denied allegations he’s harassed Mr. Lando.

Mr. O’Connor has indicated he stands by his pick, pointing to Mr. Lando’s record as an “advocate for police, justice, and community relations.”

“[He] is widely respected by both officers and the community,” Mr. O’Connor said in a statement to the Post-Gazette. “I think that his reputation and his accomplishments with the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police speaks for itself.”

It remains to be seen how big a part, if any, the Maryland investigation will play in Mr. Lando’s eventual interview with council. Most council members did not respond to requests for comment.

Advertise with us

One, Bob Charland — whose council district includes the South Side, the hilltop neighborhoods and part of Oakland — had little to say about the closed investigation.

“I think other people will ask questions about that. I want to know how officers feel about him, I want to know how the community feels about him,” he said. “I want to see what his plan is for policing in 2026.”

‘As long as he’s not on the basketball court ...’

Mr. Lando was already likely to face a higher level of scrutiny than chiefs past.

The last permanent chief hired by the city, Larry Scirotto, left after 16 months amid controversy around his part-time college basketball officiating gig — a job council members said he’d pledged to them not to pursue during his tenure in Pittsburgh.

The fallout led to changes in the way council conducts interviews with department-head nominees — they’ll now be placed under oath.

Advertise with us

Councilman Bobby Wilson said he believes there will naturally be more pressure during Mr. Lando’s interview because of the way Mr. Scirotto’s tenure ended.

Then-Pittsburgh Police Zone 5 commander Jason Lando jokes with kids after he made a long basketball shot during a pick-up game in Homewood. (Robin Rombach / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“I think that will be the No. 1 question,” said Mr. Wilson, whose district includes much of the North Side and Downtown. “I can see someone saying, ‘So let’s get this out of the way, will you have a second job? Will you have a second job next year? Will you have a second job in the third year? Has there ever been a deal between you and [the mayor]?’”

Perhaps what added insult to injury in Mr. Scirotto’s exit was his contention that he and Mayor Ed Gainey had a deal that if the first year of his tenure went well, he could return to refereeing part time — a claim backed up by some top members of the mayor’s administration.

Mr. Gainey has repeatedly denied any sort of backroom deal with Mr. Scirotto.

Mr. Wilson said he’s seen “nothing glaring” that he thinks would disqualify Mr. Lando from becoming police chief.

Advertise with us

“To be honest, at this point, as long as he’s not on the basketball court, I’m ready for it,” he said. “I’m ready for him to hit the ground running. As long as there’s nothing glaring in the questioning and in the interviews, I’m looking forward to a good partnership with [Mr. Lando].”

Councilwoman Barbara Warwick, whose district includes the southeast corner of the city, said she doesn’t anticipate “anything out of the ordinary” in Mr. Lando’s interview. She said she is focused on continuing to reduce gun violence and working across departments to stem traffic deaths as part of the city’s Vision Zero initiative.

Mr. Charland, too, said he doesn’t think the scrutiny of Mr. Lando will be outsized or undue.

“I think the chief of police is always one of the most visible members of city government,” he said. “We should hold Chief Lando to the highest standard of running the police force — just like we held Chief [Christopher] Ragland, Chief Scirotto and Chief [Scott] Schubert.”

His interactions with Mr. Lando so far, he said, have been good.

Advertise with us

“Ultimately, the two things I care about the most are how he interacts with my communities … and how he interacts with the police force — his employees,” he said.

‘They do what they’re told or they’re looking for a new job’

The problems plaguing the bureau are neither new nor unique.

Departments nationwide faced an exodus of officers amid the first years of the COVID-19 pandemic and after the civil unrest wrought by the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis.

The Police Executive Research Forum, a nonpartisan organization, surveyed 182 departments about their pandemic-era staffing levels compared to 2019. Taken altogether, the departments saw an increase in officer resignations each year from 2020 to 2022, and retirements rose in 2020 and 2021. Hiring improved in 2023, according to a follow-up survey, and hiring in 2024 “rebounded to well above pre-2020 levels.”

That turnaround hasn’t been the case everywhere, including in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

At the start of 2021, the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police had nearly 1,000 sworn officers — 900 has historically been considered a full complement. At the start of 2025, the city had just over 750, a number that fell to 708 in December. So far in 2025, there have been 61 recruits brought on as 65 other officers have retired or resigned.

Part of that decline was fueled by a freeze in academy classes during the pandemic under former Mayor Bill Peduto. Mr. Gainey took office in 2021, though the administration did not get its first class into the academy until mid-2022.

Since then, officers have continued to leave the force faster than the city could hire and train new ones — to the point that Mr. Gainey has twice lowered the number of officers budgeted, reflecting the fact that 900 — and then 850 — weren’t realistic.

Staffing concerns are magnified for council members eager for expansion of some programs.

For Mr. Charland, that’s the South Side Entertainment Patrol — about a dozen officers dedicated on certain nights to the stretch of East Carson Street that has long been the city’s nightlife hub.

Advertise with us

The councilman said he’s been pleased with the results of the directed patrols, and he wants to see them continued and expanded.

That takes officers, however,  and the police union president, Bob Swartzwelder, said his members are already overcommitted in a city that prides itself on large-scale events: Fourth of July and Light Up Night celebrations, Picklesburgh each summer, and the Three Rivers Arts Festival and Pittsburgh Marathon.

“Until the mayoral administration realizes [police pay in Pittsburgh] is not competitive … they will never reach appropriate staffing to do all of the things they need police to do in the city of Pittsburgh,” he said. “It just will not happen.”

That’s not something the chief can fix: The contract is negotiated between the city and the union. The chief’s role is to adhere to it, which Mr. Swartzwelder said puts the next chief in an unwinnable position. He said the staffing situation all but forces the chief to violate the city’s contract with the union by canceling days off and forcing overtime.

And that affects morale, he said — another issue that has beleaguered the bureau amid a revolving door of chiefs and interim chiefs.

Advertise with us

There’s also the looming 2026 NFL Draft, to which the city will play host in late April.

“The chief is going to have to come in and have to do things — cancel days off, pass days, vacations — to staff this event,” he said. “Anybody that has half a brain knows you don’t have the resources to properly police it.”

Mr. Swartzwelder’s pessimism is rooted in the politicization of the police chief position — that is, he said, “They have to play along with the political side of the world.”

“I think no matter who the chief is, that’s the political schism you’re up against in the city of Pittsburgh,” he said. “They get told what’s going to happen and, regardless of who holds that position, they do what they’re told or they’re looking for a new job.”

‘When an organization is in pain ... they’re going to welcome change’

While Mr. Swartzwelder’s concerns are in how the next chief will balance city politics and the rights and needs of members of the bureau, there’s a third factor to consider as well: residents citywide.

Advertise with us

That, too, will be a delicate balance, said Cameron McLay, the former Pittsburgh police chief who promoted Mr. Lando from lieutenant to commander of Zone 5. He said that “one of the biggest favors” Mr. Lando can do for himself is to communicate clearly to everyone “that he is the chief of the entire city.”

“He’s responsible to everybody, to all of the communities, as well as the community of the members of the police bureau,” Mr. McLay said during an interview earlier this month.

He said there will be officers who think the potential new chief will have their backs regardless of the situation.

“’He’s got our back, so he’s not going to listen to those other guys’ — of course he’s absolutely going to be talking to those other communities who are critical of police,” Mr. McLay said. “He needs to introduce right up front, ‘I’m their chief, just like I’m your chief, guys.’”

It’s a balance that Mr. Lando has said he worked to strike in Frederick. He created two advisory groups there: the Chief’s Community Advisory Board, a quarterly meeting of about 50 police, community, activist and other leaders, and an Employee Advisory Committee, made up of one representative from every squad in the police department that met monthly with the chief.

Advertise with us

Establishing such stakeholder groups in Pittsburgh, Mr. Lando said, would be a priority. He acknowledged that pleasing everyone isn’t realistic, but “if people at least understand the ‘why’ and they’ve had a chance to have a voice … people will adapt pretty quickly.”

Mr. McLay said he believes Mr. Lando will have a window of opportunity when change will be embraced rather than resisted.

“When an organization is in pain — when they’ve had problems and it’s been embarrassing to them … they’re going to welcome change because the present isn’t all that satisfying,” he said. “I suspect that’s where the police bureau is going to be at for a little — where even [Mr. Swartzwelder] and the FOP will give him a broad swath, because they’ll want to see some changes, too.”

Of course the new chief will get a fair shake, Mr. Swartzwelder said, saying he’s always known the former commander to be a fair leader.

Mayor Bill Peduto swears in newly promoted Police Commander Jason Lando during a promotion ceremony at the City County Building on Grant Street in 2014. (Ralph Musthaler / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

There will be growing pains, he said, and the new chief will get pushback. But the chief’s job is to come in with a strategy and be consistent.

Advertise with us

Mr. Swartzwelder said the department that Mr. Lando comes back to is not the same one he left, pointing to the high turnover. The officers who know him, though, speak highly of him, Mr. Swartzwelder said.

“Anytime a new boss comes in, the officers are looking for effective leadership, and they need to learn what that leader’s style is,” he said, calling consistency the key to being perceived as legitimate. “As soon as you deviate, you lose your legitimacy.”

‘You’re gonna get 100% of my time and my attention’

Part of that consistency will hinge on steady leadership: There have been five chiefs and acting chiefs in the past four years. Mr. Lando, for his part, has said he is committed to Pittsburgh for the long term.

“There’s only one reason I’m [leaving Frederick], and that’s because Pittsburgh is my home,” he said Nov. 13, minutes after Mr. O’Connor announced the familiar face as his pick for chief. “I’m coming back and I’m in it for the long haul.”

Indeed, the Squirrel Hill native has told friends and colleagues in Frederick and in Pittsburgh that this was the only position that could have pulled him away from Maryland.

Advertise with us

He’d been close to it once before and, when that door closed, Mr. Lando had all but ruled out trying again. He was a finalist for the Pittsburgh job in 2023 — one of three pared down over a year-long, nationwide search that ultimately ended with a job offer to Mr. Scirotto.

Mr. Lando said he never got notice from the city that he’d been passed over, calling that part “the toughest pill for me to swallow.”

“Going back to Pittsburgh and going through the process and then finding out from TV that you weren’t selected — that was tough,” he said.

After Mr. Scirotto resigned amid the basketball officiating controversy, Mr. Gainey’s acting chief, Mr. Ragland, was poised to take over the job permanently. He retired before his nomination went before council, unsettled by what he claimed were unethical asks by council behind closed doors.

When Mr. Scirotto got the Pittsburgh job, Mr. Lando sold the house he still had in Pittsburgh and built one in Frederick. By the time the dust in Pittsburgh settled, he’d already decided that if the job ultimately went to another nationwide search, he was out.

Advertise with us

“I just felt that I didn’t want to risk going through that again,” he said.

When the mayor-elect called, though, he listened. He said he trusted Mr. O’Connor when he said saw what he was looking for in Mr. Lando and had no interest in a drawn-out search and interview process.

He’s keenly aware of the struggles that have plagued the department since he’s left, and he hopes some of the initiatives that were successful in Frederick — can help lessen the load.

He’s cognizant, though, that Pittsburgh is a different city and in a far different — and worse off — position than Frederick.

“You can’t just say, well, this works here, so I’m going to do it in Pittsburgh,” he said.

The reception from officers he’s kept in touch with, he said, has been positive. But he stresses to them that change won’t be instant.

“I tell them, ‘Listen, you’re gonna get 100% of my time and my attention — my heart’s in it 100% — but I don’t have a magic wand,’” he said. “’I don’t want you guys to think that I’m going to start on Monday and on Tuesday, everything’s gonna be cool.’”

Click here to read part one of this series.