An animal rights group is asserting that five elephants at the Pittsburgh Zoo have the “right to liberty” and should be released.

The Nonhuman Rights Project, self-described as the “only civil rights organization in the United States dedicated solely to securing rights for nonhuman animals,” filed a lawsuit against the Zoological Society of Pittsburgh, which includes the Pittsburgh Zoo & Aquarium and International Conservation Center, in  Allegheny County Common Pleas court, petitioning to free five female African elephants from captivity. Dr. Jeremy Goodman, president and CEO of the zoo, is also named in the suit.

“If [the court] chooses not to protect Angeline, Savanna, Tasha, Victoria, and Zuri … because they walk on four legs and have trunks, the common law, and by extension this Court, will forever be weaker,” NhRP wrote in its petition.

Ultimately, the NhRP said it wants the court to either release the elephants to a sanctuary or consider them as candidates for rewilding, arguing that elephants are deserving of the same bodily liberty as humans.

Advertise with us

“At its core, this lawsuit is about deepening our respect for the freedom of other beings and making sure we’re upholding the values and principles of justice that protect us all,” Courtney Fern, NhRP’s director of government relations and campaigns, said in a statement.

A spokesperson for the Pittsburgh Zoo declined to comment on the lawsuit, stating that the zoo would “follow up once the Pittsburgh Zoo & Aquarium has additional information to share on this matter.”

The NhRP has made similar pleas for the release of an elephant at the Bronx Zoo in New York and seven chimpanzees at the DeYoung Family Zoo in Michigan. Both were unsuccessful.

In 2015, the Pittsburgh Zoo lost its accreditation from the Association of Zoos & Aquariums due to a disagreement over a safety policy restricting zookeepers’ contact with elephants. The zoo won back the accreditation in 2024.

Just last month, police say a 19-year-old man jumped a fence at the zoo and entered the elephant enclosure, posting a video of the encounter on Instagram. Police said one of the elephants came “within inches” of striking the self-proclaimed social media influencer.

Advertise with us

The NhRP submitted its filing just after the zoo announced last week that two sister elephants, Victoria and Zuri, will be moved to its International Conservation Center in Fairhope, Somerset County. The herd there includes three females and bull elephant Jackson, and the hope is that growth of the herd will continue, per the news release.

“Every decision at the Zoo is centered around the well-being of our resident animals,” Dr. Goodman said in the release. “The plan for our elephants strengthens our ability to continue to provide world-class care while advancing our conservation mission.”

NhRP in a Tuesday news release said it intends to prevent the relocation of Victoria and Zuri while litigation is ongoing.

Moving the elephants, the zoo said, is to “ensure appropriate companionship for elephants at both facilities and also allow for growth of the herd.”

In the lawsuit, the NhRP provided documentation that it claims illustrates the stress that the elephants are enduring in captivity, supported by some expert declarations included in the petition. 

Advertise with us

William Keith Lindsay, a researcher for the Amboseli Trust for Elephants, wrote in his declaration cited in the lawsuit that the “continued keeping of elephants at Pittsburgh Zoo & Aquarium cannot be justified on any basis.”

“Their behavior has been completely controlled by their human handlers, and for this reason has been stressful to the point of psychological damage,” Mr. Lindsay, who said he studied photos, videos and documents about the elephants’ captivity at the zoo, wrote. “It is inhumane and cruel to subject these sentient animals to continuous control over their lives.”