Every time it rains, Eric Chismar steps outside and checks the crumbling hillside next to his home.

For years, the edge of Andover Terrace in the Hill District has been collapsing inch by inch, turning a quiet residential street into a hazard zone. The street, which sits above Schenley Farms, is barricaded by fences and orange cones, forcing residents to take an up to half-mile detour around the hill to access their homes.

“It’s such a pain,” said Mr. Chismar, 55, who’s lived on the street for more than two decades. “I would have never imagined that just having the top of the street blocked would have impacted us in so many different ways.”

In 2022, a landslide forced city officials to block access to the street from Bryn Mawr Road. At least two homes were condemned — one on Andover Terrace and the other on Schenley Farms Terrace, below the hill.

Advertise with us

Scrapes and tire marks scar the low concrete wall lining the street from vehicles barreling down the narrow road before realizing there’s no way out. Residents complain about delivery trucks avoiding the street altogether.

Property owners of the two condemned homes have filed lawsuits against the city, with one of them claiming that officials had notice of the progressive failure of Andover Terrace for an extended period of time, therefore the “instability and eminent collapse … was a foreseeable and presentable event.”

The lawsuit filed by the owners of the Schenley Farms Terrace property also blamed Pittsburgh Water for the failure to monitor, maintain and control storm water and public water infrastructure at Andover Terrace. Spokeswoman Rebecca Zito said the authority was not directly involved in remediation for Andover Terrace and could not comment on its status.

The city didn’t respond to a request for comment on the lawsuit and has yet to publicly disclose the cause of the landslide. 

Despite promises to fix the issue, residents say progress has stalled.

Advertise with us

The city had originally listed an estimated completion date of mid-August 2023 for the Andover Terrace Landslide Remediation Project. It included removing the failed concrete retaining wall, excavating debris and soil from the hillside, and installing a retaining system using micropiles, lagging and soil nails, according to the city’s website. Temporary hillside stabilization was also a part of the plan, using erosion control matting and seeding.

Now city officials are estimating the project will be completed by the end of 2026, according to City Councilman Daniel Lavelle, whose district includes the Hill District.

He said part of the reason the process has stalled is because while the road itself is public, the land and homes below are privately owned. At least a year was spent working to get agreements in place to access parts of the property for remediation work, he said.

Mr. Lavelle estimates the project will cost at least $5 million.

“I know residents are frustrated, and as a resident, I'm frustrated, but I can tell you that this is a priority within the city to have the street rebuilt and reopened,” said Mr. Lavelle, who lives in the Hill District.

Advertise with us

His neighbors are not so sure.

“My main fear is this is the start of a longer term issue, and we’re not really seeing the city respond with the same urgency we feel here,” said Andover Terrace resident Josie Rush, 35.

Andover Terrace is on a steep hillside allowing for views of Oakland between the gaps of towering trees. More than a dozen early 20th-century homes line the street, most being passed down from generation to generation, according to neighbors. Tucked away from the city noise, residents said they felt a sense of peace and quiet — until they started noticing the warning signs.

“It didn’t happen all at once,” Mr. Chismar said. “For years we saw the road moving away from the sidewalk up there, and they would come and pave it, but then a few months later there would be a gap again – and this went on for years, until the gap got so wide you could fall into it.”

Mr. Chismar and others said they began reporting the issue to 311 as early as 2018. 

Advertise with us

“Between me and my wife, we used to call 311 every other week,” Ms. Rush said. “We used to joke that they would be worried if they didn’t hear from one of us within 48 hours.”

Cones block off a stretch of Andover Terrace which remains under construction in the Hill District on Wednesday, May 7, 2025. The section of road was the site of a landslide in 2022 and has yet to be completely repaired. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Residents said they didn’t see real action until a group of engineering students living at the end of the street raised the alarm to a professor at the University of Pittsburgh.

“All of a sudden there were jersey barriers up and it was a big emergency, the road was blocked and it stayed that way for weeks,” Mr. Chismar said. “Once they started bringing in heavier equipment, that’s when everything really collapsed and we saw things sliding down the hill.”

The city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure declined to comment.

“That was essentially a typical landslide scenario that we have here in Pittsburgh,” said Duquesne University geology professor Phillip Reeder. “We have steep slopes, housing often sitting right at the edge of these slopes, and neighborhoods, like where the Andover Terrace event took place, that are fairly typical of the infrastructure of a city the age of Pittsburgh.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Reeder explained that when houses, streets and sidewalks are built, they create hard surfaces that block water from soaking into the soil. This forces water to run off the land and only infiltrate certain parts of the ground. If water collects at the edge or on a slope, it can then weaken the ground and lead to a landslide.

“Landslides have been occurring in Pittsburgh for thousands of years, before there were any residents,” Mr. Reeder said. “There are thousands of scars all over the landscape surrounding Pittsburgh, from thousands of ancient landslide events. Now, put a city and suburbs on top of a landscape that already has the penchant to slide, and you end up with what Pittsburgh experiences – a lot of mass wasting events.”

The Allegheny County Department of Public Works currently lists more than 100 landslides that have impacted county-owned roads.

In Polish Hill, residents are also waiting for a fix on Brereton Street, where a burst water pipe created a landslide that crashed onto the Martin Luther King Jr. East Busway below in October. Residents in one home were forced to evacuate and the property was eventually condemned. 

A condemned home in front of the landslide that occurred in October, 2024 on Brereton Street in Polish Hill shown on May 6, 2025. (Sarah Qu / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

While the busway was completely reopened two months later, Brereton Road above remains blocked off by fences. 

Advertise with us

“I would love to see it get fixed, but people don’t even realize it’s back there,” said Josh McClure, 34, who’s lived in Polish Hill for more 25 years. “It’s out of sight, out of mind.”

Pittsburgh Water is currently initiating the design work to stabilize the site and remediate geotechnical conditions along Brereton Street and the hillside, Ms. Zito said.

“Since the landslide occurred in October, we have continued to monitor the site for movement and are moving forward with a water main relocation project,” she said. “This project would abandon the water main located on Brereton Street and relocate it to Kenney Way where we would establish water service behind the homes.”

Meanwhile, in Mount Washington, three major landslide remediation projects have been completed, city officials announced last week.

The projects, located at Greenleaf, Reese and William streets, were funded by a $13.3 million Pre-Disaster Mitigation Grant from the Federal Emergency Management Agency and administered by Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency. The city provided a 25% matching grant.

Advertise with us

Those projects are part of a broader effort to address hillside instability and climate-related vulnerabilities, city officials said.

Along Andover Terrace, gravel covers the slope, guarded by a fence and some traffic cones. A stretch of orange plastic safety fencing lines the edge, loosely fastened to stakes and sagging or completely fallen off in some sections.

In front of Mr. Chismar’s home, he constantly replaces a piece of rotting plywood that covers a hole in the ground – he estimates it’s nearly six feet deep. 

Residents said they’re worried it’s only a matter of time before someone gets hurt, but they have nowhere else to turn.

“I love my neighborhood and I love living here,” he said. “Even if I did decide to move, how do you sell a house that’s on the edge of a landslide? I feel like I’m sort of trapped here.”

Advertise with us

Residents are also learning the hard way that their homeowners insurance offers little protection. Most standard policies exclude damages caused by earth movement or excess water – even when that water runoff stems from aging city infrastructure or worsening weather conditions.

“It’s a typical exclusion,” said Todd Elliot, an attorney with Pittsburgh-based law firm, Elliot & Davis. “Not only damage from landslides, but also damage related to water, which is another big exclusion, since water often causes or contributes to landslides.”

For hillside neighborhoods like Andover Terrace or Polish Hill, Mr. Elliot said the risks aren’t going away.

“Gravity only moves in one direction,” he said. “For landslide-prone areas in Western Pennsylvania, the only question is when the damage will occur, not if.”

A stretch of Andover Terrace remains a construction site in the Hill District on Wednesday, May 7, 2025. The section of road was the site of a landslide in 2022 and has yet to be completely repaired. (Sarah Qu / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)