On a dreary Tuesday morning in Lawrenceville, Party on Butler CEO Melinda Durham gazed past the glittering disco balls in her window with a cellphone to her ear, already taking calls from customers almost an hour before her store opened.
In the back, Creative and Production Manager Lauren Rhodes stood next to a trio of missile-sized helium canisters and concentrated on filling up two balloons for a woman’s online order — one shaped like a “9” and the other a “0.” Above the thrum of the store’s poppy playlist, she wondered out loud whether the numbers were for a 90-year-old, or for a 90th anniversary.
“I’m sure we’ll find out when she comes in,” she said with a smile.
At Party on Butler — a Pittsburgh Black-owned party supply store where customers can make any celebration idea a reality — decorations hardly ever stay the same for two weeks in a row.
The store offers more than 50 different themes, ranging from corporate events to a “divorce party.” The current centerpiece advertised “Galentine’s Day,” a friendship-focused alternative to Valentine’s Day.
People looking for a good time can pick up a copy of “What’s the Tea” — advertised as “Not Your Mom’s Card Game” — or indulge in a variety of fruit-flavored drink mixes encouraging them to “Just add vodka.”
Read More
“It doesn’t have to be all red roses and a serious thing with your boyfriend or husband — you can just have a bunch of girls,” said Ms. Durham.
Even from the outside, Party on Butler’s bright pink facade epitomizes Ms. Durham’s mission to make celebrations worth having.
Ms. Durham grew up in Columbus, Ohio, and attended Point Park University, where she met her future husband, Jordan, and graduated in 2019 with a bachelor’s degree in intelligence and national security. Her dream of working for the government was outweighed by the allure of New York City, though, so she became an installation operations analyst at Christie’s Auction House, where she was responsible for relocating million-dollar paintings.
But Ms. Durham’s life took an unexpected turn when her uncle, Shadrach Moon, passed away. Mr. Moon was an original resident of Belmar Gardens in Lincoln-Lemington, the first Black-owned cooperative with a federally insured mortgage in America.
Ms. Durham and her husband decided it was important to keep the townhouse in their family, so they moved back to Pittsburgh and renovated it.
“It gives me immense pride to be able to be in that same community, and just being around the history,” she said. “He was the last of the first people, so it’s really important for me to keep that energy alive in the community.”
‘People are coming to Butler Street’
Opening a party supply store was a “spur of the moment” decision for Ms. Durham.
She had enjoyed planning events and parties for her friends and family, so her husband encouraged her to turn her hobby into a full-time business.
She was initially apprehensive.

“I was like, ‘That’s super weird, I don’t know about that.’ And then our first big client was Amazon, and it got bigger from there,” she said.
Ms. Durham scouted potential locations for her new business and came across an unoccupied storefront that “felt right” on Butler Street. Soon thereafter, Party on Butler opened in August 2022.
In the post-pandemic business world, Ms. Durham considers her online store to be just as important as her physical location. Still, she said, Lawrenceville’s commercial drag provided Party on Butler with heavy foot traffic and reminded her of New York City’s vibrant atmosphere.
“I feel like people are coming to Butler Street, especially on the weekends. It’s new and trendy… kind of like a little mini New York,” she said.
Ms. Durham said that her first priority was to make people happy again in the wake of a pandemic lockdown that forbade social gatherings.
“Everything was so stressful and so serious, especially during COVID … and so we really focused on having fun, bright, colorful parties and just enjoying the memories and taking the stress off of it,” she said.
Staying in customers’ lives
Of course, Ms. Durham’s job as the main buyer for the store comes with plenty of stress, too.
Maintaining inventory for all of Party on Butler’s 50-plus themes takes “a lot of late nights of scanning products,” she said.

Graduation time around June is particularly busy since Ms. Durham offers a “one-stop shop” for party supplies and every balloon color you can think of, including “Purple Orchid,” “Champagne” and “Aloha.”
Ms. Durham estimated that Party on Butler sells over 1,000 balloons every Saturday — her busiest day — and 3,000 balloons per week.
But she has run into supply issues, since helium is a nonrenewable resource, and costs have been rising amid a national shortage. Party on Butler also finds itself in a line behind large helium users — such as the medical industry — when it comes to access.
“We’re kind of last on the totem pole,” she said.
Party on Butler has therefore pivoted to focusing on air-filled balloons, which are more durable and cheaper to produce.
“Helium only lasts a couple of hours, so we try to push people towards pieces that are going to last longer,” she said.
In an era when brick-and-mortar giants like Party City are closing, Party on Butler’s business has expanded. What started with Ms. Durham and her husband now has a total of eight employees.
The store has found its niche as a community-oriented party retailer, said Ms. Durham. Her client relations manager, Devon, sends frequent customers birthday cards and has coffee with them to build long-lasting connections.
“We like to stay in people’s lives … if we did your wedding shower, we want to do your baby shower,” said Ms. Durham.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.