Olabisi Olatunji, a server at Italian restaurant Bella Notte in the Strip District, encourages her customers, especially tourists staying at hotels, to take any extra food in boxes and give it to people in need on their way out of the neighborhood.

“Now, as times are getting tougher, and we’re very close to Downtown, I definitely see people migrating down here,” she said. “They know people come here on the weekends … it’s a place for them to see some type of help.”

A rise in homelessness, the city’s clearing of encampments Downtown, limited shelter capacity and a seeming absence of answers has business owners, employees and residents in the Strip keeping a wary eye out on what will happen in their neighborhood. City efforts to develop solutions, such as building transitional housing and permanent affordable homes, have foundered at the City Planning Commission. The recent fire at Second Avenue Commons further emphasized the lack of shelter space the city has to offer.

The Strip District, which borders Downtown, has been on a roll of late – seeing new development continue and more residents moving in. A 2023 report from Strip District Neighbors, the neighborhood’s community group, estimated that over 3,000 residents now live in the Strip, compared to fewer than 1,000 a decade ago.

Advertise with us

Christopher Beers, the owner of Grandpa Joe’s Candy Store, said business has always been good with the streets full of locals looking for a unique item not found at their local grocery store, or tourists directed to the area from the front desk at their hotel.

“The development on Smallman Street has added a new element to the Strip that we never really had before,” Mr. Beers said, referring to the renovation of the Terminal that has brought many new businesses to the street, part of more than $1.5 billion invested in the Strip District over the past decade or so.

Mr. Beers also highlighted an increase in the residential side of the neighborhood as a “huge win” for his business, remembering how the area used to wind down around 4 p.m. and now stays busy until late hours.

How that economic development push pairs with the need to care for the growing ranks of the unhoused isn’t always explicit.

Two encampments have been cleared from Downtown since a new set of guidelines were implemented last year that indicate where encampments can be located and how the city should go about removing them. The city is focused on revitalizing Downtown, hoping to create more of a neighborhood atmosphere to attract residents to fill apartments being created in former office spaces empty since the pandemic.

Advertise with us
People walk around the bustling Strip District on a sunny Saturday morning on Saturday, June 8, 2024. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Annie Cairns, the marketing manager at Light of Life Rescue Mission, said her team has not seen a rise of encampments in the Strip, but foot traffic from unhoused people has increased. Ms. Cairns said when the city shuts down an encampment, people typically combine with others or set up an entirely new camp elsewhere.

“If there is a new rule that takes place in one part of the city, homeless people will abide and relocate to another area, such as the Strip District,” she said. “No matter where they put their regulations, they’re just going to move.”

Mr. Beers said he has not noticed a significant rise of homelessness in the area, but said an increase might be discouraging to some business owners and residents.

“Business owners take great pride in how their businesses look and how comfortable people are in coming to the Strip because it’s a safe neighborhood,” he said. “I would hope that the city would uphold their responsibility in helping folks who are less fortunate, and that the result would not be that they feel … it necessary to come to the Strip District if there were facilities available for them elsewhere.”

Some who have noticed the uptick said it is centered along the Allegheny River Trail, further from the commercial streets of Smallman and Penn Avenue, and closer to the new condos that have gone up along Railroad Street.

Advertise with us

Pamela Austin, the president of Strip District Neighbors, said residents have raised this concern at meetings the neighborhood group has held.

“We have a lot of social service agencies here, so their concerns are helping people,” Ms. Austin said. “On the other hand, you have a neighborhood that’s an increasingly residential population. They feel like they’ve paid a lot of money for homes, so they would like to have a walkable, safe environment.”

The average rent for a one-bedroom apartment in the Strip is nearly $2,000, according to the 2023 Strip District Neighbors report – a one-bedroom on the riverside is typically above a $2,000 asking price.

At Bella Notte, Ms. Olatunji said if more unhoused people move to the Strip, tourism might be affected. The neighborhood was just named one of the country’s top alfresco dining experiences. But she is more concerned with the city response.

“I’ve seen them do a lot of drastic measures to kick the homeless out of different areas. I haven’t seen it down here in the Strip just yet, but I’ve seen it in other places, very violently,” she said. “I think they would probably do the same thing [here].”

Advertise with us

For many business owners, concern is a balancing act. Jacob Edwards, an owner at Parma Sausage Products, said being in business means “you’re pulled between both sides of the issue.” He said he has not seen a significant increase of unhoused people in the area.

“When you have a meat shop, you want to have a clean environment … but that still is a person, so I don’t know. It’s a weird thing,” he said.

This was true for Ray Mikesell, the former owner of Cafe Raymond. He sold his business in 2022 for myriad reasons – inflation, Covid-era economic troubles, and also homelessness.

“It’s not a good image for your business,” Mr. Mikesell said, explaining an instance when someone defecated on the floor of his business, and other times when people would set up to sleep outside of it.

Mr. Mikesell said his customers didn’t like it, and he paid a few people outside to leave.

Advertise with us

“I didn’t want them in front of my store, and there was not a whole lot I could do. So finally, I just gave up,” he said.

Mr. Mikesell, who donates to the Light of Life, said the city should provide better resources for unhoused people. He said he has seen other Pittsburgh businesses struggle with similar issues, such as Wiener World, which closed the doors on its Smithfield Street location Downtown and moved to the US Steel Tower, citing fatigue from street crime, drug use and public urination.

Alicia Romano, CEO of Community Human Services which is located in the Strip District, said she has heard business owners voice similar concerns at Strip District Neighbors meetings, describing a “good bit of stigma” in the room. She said as a result of closing encampments Downtown, her organization has seen a rise of homelessness in the Strip.

Ms. Romano said she does understand why business owners might not want someone who is unhoused sleeping outside of their shop and encouraged them to provide resources should they ask someone to leave.

Bill Foglia, founder of Penn Ave Pottery and whose family owned businesses in the Strip years prior, said it is a fine line for business owners.

“There could be a tipping point where a lot of business owners say, this is getting out of hand,” he said.