Pittsburgh Public School officials on Monday reported an improved budgetary outlook for 2024 after significantly reducing the district’s expected deficit. But with looming tax assessment appeals, leaders are now looking for ways to continue to save money.

In all, the 2024 budgetary deficit is projected to total $2.1 million, a reduction from the $29.9 million deficit originally expected, Ronald Joseph, the district’s chief financial officer, said during a budget workshop. The change came after expenses for salaries and benefits were lower than expected due to staffing vacancies and the use of COVID-related funding and state grants.

But the deficit is expected to creep slowly back up in future years, reaching $16.7 million in 2025 and $17.8 million in 2026.

“Even though the financial situation and forecasting has improved over the next two or three years, we’re still forecasting spending more than we’re bringing in,” school Director Emma Yourd said. “We’ll need to think of ways to balance the budget moving forward.”

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Public officials have spent the past few months working to improve a grim budget outlook in the coming years, something that has been largely impacted by property tax assessment appeals that have reached levels not seen in decades, putting the district and Pittsburgh on the hook for potential massive tax refunds and revenue losses.

So far, PPS leaders are expecting to pay an estimated $6.9 million in tax refunds for 2022 and 2023 following a slew of tax assessment appeals stemming from a steep drop — from 87.5% to 63.5% — in the common level ratio, the number used in appeals hearings to calculate the taxable value of a property.

That number has fallen again, to 54.5%, this year and could go even lower in 2025.

And this year, almost 1,200 assessment appeals have been filed so far, representing $1.5 billion in total tax base and $15.6 million in annual tax revenue. That means tax revenue could be reduced by $2.9 million in 2024, Mr. Joseph said.

Appeals are expected to continue impacting the district’s budget, and could cause the projected 2025 budget deficit to increase to $19.5 million and the 2026 deficit to $20.8 million.

Advertise with us

Now, officials are considering several budgetary changes to help make up for those losses.

On Monday, Mr. Joseph presented a scenario with a 5.3% millage increase to help bolster real estate revenues impacted by the appeals.

“We are not recommending a tax increase at this time,” Mr. Joseph said. “We’re not advocating for one at this time. We are just looking at opportunities on the revenue side.”

With a tax increase, real estate revenues would increase from a projected 2025 total of $181 million to $187.5 million. In 2026 that number could jump from a projected $184.6 million to $191.1 million. And the budget’s overall projected deficit would drop to $13.1 million in 2025 and $14.2 million in 2026.

On the expenditure side, officials could look at several factors such as salaries and benefits, which account for 47% of the district’s budget. But included in that budget are salaries and benefits for positions that are currently vacant. For example, PPS currently budgets $5 million for vacant central administration positions.

Advertise with us

“One of the next steps we’re going to have during the budget process is looking at those positions and trying to see whether those are positions we need going forward and whether some of those positions can be reduced,” Mr. Joseph said.

Officials could also look at overtime costs, which accounted for $8.3 million in the 2023 general fund budget; contracted services, the cost of which has increased 34% since 2021; and software fees, which the district has been over-budgeting for. Mr. Joseph noted that during the next budget workshop officials will focus on transportation, special education and cyber charter school tuition fees, costs the district has little control over based on state laws and contracts.

The board has also been looking at whether to close some buildings that are operating below capacity.

Board President Gene Walker on Monday noted there are “so many factors that we don’t control in this process” and that the board needs to be willing to try different scenarios to “get ourselves in a financial position that we can sustain.”

“And that may take two, three, four years as we kind of go through this,” Mr. Walker said. “But this is the time to do it because if we wait to start kind of pulling on those levers that we do control we get ourselves in quite a bit more sticky position going forward.”