Pittsburgh police are reviewing how they evaluate potential recruits psychologically after about two dozen candidates were rejected from the bureau. 

The vast majority of candidates who received conditional offers were rejected on psychological grounds in early May, delaying plans for a recruit class during a time when more officers are retiring or leaving the bureau than joining. 

Police psychological exams are performed to assess applicants’ emotional stability and psychological suitability to be an officer, according to the International Association of Chiefs of Police. The exact content varies depending on each agency and applicant, but the major components of the exams are usually a questionnaire and an interview with a psychologist specializing in police and public safety personnel.

Days after the candidates were rejected, Mayor Ed Gainey said they would be invited back for a second evaluation with new psychologists and, upon passing, will join the ranks of the forthcoming recruitment class, Post-Gazette news partner KDKA reported.

Advertise with us

Officials did not respond to questions regarding the status of those candidates' employment or when the new class will start, but Public Safety spokeswoman Emily Bourne said officials are "holistically reviewing the police recruitment process and are evaluating that process — including the psychological — for potential changes.

"We will be publicly announcing and discussing any changes we make in the weeks to come, including how any updates will impact past/current recruits," she wrote in an email to the Post-Gazette.

For years, accusations of discrimination and racial undertones have raised concerns about the bureau's hiring practices. Now, there's concern that the bureau may be meeting its severe staffing shortage by lowering its officer standards, said Beth Pittinger, the executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board. 

"Is the standard to go get other psychologists, or is the answer to look at our expectations and the caliber of an individual we want as a police officer?" she said. 

"We need to know [officers] are psychologically intact and are there for the right reasons." 

Advertise with us

The final step

Mark Zelig, an expert in public safety psychology and a former lieutenant at the Salt Lake City Police Department, said it’s not impossible, but highly unusual that so many candidates failed their psychological evaluations after making it that far through the application process. Mr. Zelig has served as chair of the Police and Public Safety Psychology Section of the American Psychological Association, operates a national independent practice in forensic and police psychology and routinely conducts fitness-for-duty and pre-employment evaluations for police officers. 

In doing his evaluations, Mr. Zelig spends about six hours reviewing each applicant to determine if they’re psychologically sound enough to be a police officer. The test is more holistic than what most people think, he said. Much of it comes down to the candidate’s personal history rather than interviews he conducts with them.

“We don’t just hand them tests and ask them how they feel about their mother,” Mr. Zelig said. “We consider what the applicant tells us and we look at their background, and we sort of ask ourselves, is there anything unresolved or uncertain about this person?”

It’s only then that psychological testing is used —  to clear up those ambiguities, he said. 

For example, if a candidate has a mental health disorder,  Mr. Zelig said it can be a red flag but does not make them ineligible for the job. He looks to see how, or if, the disorder affected them through their life. Then, he might ask how they deal with their disorder on a daily basis or if they have adapted to their medication.

Advertise with us

He said psychologists aren’t looking to fail anyone in these evaluations. 

"We are put into a quality control position — our job is to say, 'everyone looks okay to us,’” he said.

And when an agency does its due diligence and screens the candidates, that’s usually what happens, he said. In his experience, police departments with the best reputations and benefits typically attract top-tier candidates who pass their psychological evaluations at higher rates.

But as agencies across the country face severe staffing shortages, Mr. Zelig said that diligence can sometimes be overlooked. And lowering the bar for officers, he said, can have "catastrophic results." 

In the years leading up to and in the early part of the pandemic, Pittsburgh was training and graduating an average of 70 to 90 recruits each year. The most recent class graduated in early March with 24 officers — the first full class since January 2021.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh has historically budgeted for a force of 900 officers, and the bureau hovered just below that — between about 850 and 890 — for much of the late 2000s and 2010s. As of March, there were about 740 officers in the bureau — a loss of some 250 from the most recent peak in 2020.

There have been a myriad of efforts through the years to combat the police staffing shortage: in 2022, the bureau scrapped its college credit requirement in an effort to eliminate barriers for potential recruits. Earlier this year, a lucrative new police contract was approved and major operational changes that touted overall officer wellness went into effect.

But the problem persists, and Mr. Zelig points to it as a potential reason why so many candidates in Pittsburgh failed their psychological evaluations and were then allowed a second chance.

"I would guess they're so desperate for applicants that everyone's under pressure to pass these people," he said. "The only [other] possible explanation is that [the psychologists] don't have enough experience to know how to interpret law enforcement norms."

While it’s rare, Mr. Zelig said he’s had experiences where he’s failed nearly every candidate he’s evaluated, too.

Advertise with us

And it’s always for the same reason — applicants that should have been screened out earlier, were allowed to continue the employment process.

“If the department isn't cracking enough applicants that they can send enough good ones forward — this is actually the outcome that should be happening,” he said. “And now, it seems like the second group of psychologists [in Pittsburgh] are under some pressure to improve the batting average.”

For some, like Vic Walczak of the American Civil Liberties Union, the high number of  rejections didn't come as a surprise because there was already concern about the city’s hiring process.

Twelve years ago, the ACLU sued the city over discriminatory hiring practices against Black applicants in the police bureau. The settlement brought numerous changes to the bureau's hiring processes and paid roughly $985,000 to Black applicants who were rejected between 2008 and 2014.

During the lawsuit, Mr. Walczak said his team learned several of their Black clients had been rejected from the bureau at the psychological evaluation phase despite previous employment at other bureaus where they passed their evaluations. At the time, the lawsuit addressed everything but the screening, and they didn’t have the resources to tackle it. 

Advertise with us

"[The evaluation], that is the final step," Mr. Walczak said.

Of the 23 candidates rejected earlier this month, five are Black, KDKA reported. 

"You're trending toward a department that is overwhelmingly white, engaged in over policing in a lot of predominantly Black neighborhoods," Mr. Walczak said. "That's potentially a volatile mix."

Problems in the past

There have been additional claims of discrimination in the psychological evaluation process in the past decade.

Christopher Gibbs, a candidate for Pittsburgh police, filed a discrimination complaint under the Americans with Disabilities Act in 2018, claiming the bureau did not hire him because of his attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gibbs "aced the written test," and received a conditional offer of employment from the bureau, according to court documents. It was revoked after the psychological screening process, where he alleged two out of three psychologists recommended he not be hired because of his ADHD.

According to court documents, five other police departments deemed Mr. Gibbs mentally fit and found him to have no history of misconduct as an officer or when he was a U.S. Marine.

Mr. Gibb's claim was initially dismissed but was reversed in the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2021.

"Governments have a right to ensure that their policemen are mentally fit," wrote U.S. Circuit Judge Stephanos Bibas. "But they may not use psychological testing as a cover to discriminate."

Ms. Pittinger, of the Citizen Police Review Board, said the city needs to establish a procedure that's fair for every candidate while also being mindful of who it's "giving the badge and the gun to."

"It's a whole mess of things that need to be addressed," she said.