The Squirrel Hill community was bustling Friday morning. Everyday sounds of cars and buses taking people from classes and work echoed through the streets. Shoppers picked up last minute items for the weekend from locally owned businesses.

But every once in a while signs would pop up, a reminder of the anger and sadness residents who live in the hub of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community are feeling after the militant group Hamas launched a surprise assault on Israel last weekend, leaving more than 1,000 Israelis dead and others captured.

A small, locally owned grocery store hung the sign “Israel we stand with you” from their front doors. A group of teenage girls chalked the outline of Shiva candles on the sidewalk in support of Israel. Yellow “No place for hate” signs dotted the lawns of some Squirrel Hill homes.

The residents of the Squirrel Hill community are not strangers to loss and devastation. They banded together when a gunman in 2018 killed 11 worshipers from three congregations, Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. And on Friday that resilience rang loud as the community once again came together to show support for Israel.

Advertise with us
Rabbi Daniel Fellman leads Shabbat service on Friday, Oct. 13, 2023, at Temple Sinai in Pittsburgh. The congregation prayed for the safety of the state of Israel for peace and said a memorial prayer for those killed and missing after Hamas' attack. (Associated Press)

“I believe [in] showing support for Israel and not being afraid,” Aryeh Markovic, co-owner of Murray Avenue Kosher, said while working in the deli of the store that placed a sign of support on its doors. “That’s what terrorism is. You create terror and I refuse to back down to their intimidation.”

Last Sunday Israel declared war against Hamas, which governs the Gaza Strip, after the attacks killed 1,300 Israelis and led to deadly airstrikes, overwhelmed hospitals and shelters, caused mass evacuations and other chaos. Since that time almost 1,800 Palestinians have also died.

The war has intensified throughout the week and Israel’s military on Friday directed the evacuation of hundreds of thousands of civilians living in Gaza City ahead of a possible Israeli ground offensive. The order came within 24 hours of an evacuation notice issued to more than 1 million Palestinians from the northern Gaza Strip.

Anne Faigen, right, says a silent prayer for her friends in Israel while at a Shabbat service at Temple Sinai in Pittsburgh on Friday, Oct. 13, 2023. (Associated Press)

But the war has drawn mixed reactions around the world, with some politicians and organizations supporting Israel while others are advocating for Palestinians.

In Pittsburgh, Mayor Ed Gainey on Saturday said he had met with faith leaders from both the Jewish and Islamic communities and determined both sides need to be heard:  “... we must begin with recognizing the humanity of all people,” he said.

Advertise with us

“We must stand with our local Jewish community to recognize the right of Israel to exist, as well as condemn antisemitism and the horrific attacks by Hamas on innocent Israeli civilians. We must also stand against violence toward and displacement of innocent Palestinian civilians in the unfolding conflict in Gaza. We, as a nation, must continue to pray for a peaceful and just resolution to this conflict.”

The city’s Squirrel Hill neighborhood has quietly shown support for Israel with few signs posted throughout the neighborhood. Prayer services and unity events have taken place at synagogues and the Jewish Community Center on Forbes Avenue.

Pro-Palestinian rally draws hundreds

A pro-Palestinian rally drew hundreds of people to Oakland Friday afternoon, many waving the Palestine flag and chanting “Free, free Palestine.” Organizers said the event was one of the largest pro-Palestinian protests in the nation.

“We don’t condone any violence,” said Ahmed Avafa, who came from Gaza to America to study in his teens. “We don’t condone the killing of anybody. The loss of life on Saturday is shameful. And the loss of life on Sunday and Monday and Tuesday and Wednesday and Thursday and today is also shameful. This is not about politics. This is about the humanity.”

Advertise with us

Other speakers called on the United States to not allow their money to be used to “kill innocent people.”

“I am full of outrage at the atrocities that have been committed especially against the Palestinian people who are being really told to leave their homes and their country and have nowhere to go,” Michael Drohan, 85, said. “It breaks my heart. I cannot sleep, I cannot rest with this. And this is not to condone the attack of Hamas, which was a crime, but nevertheless the reaction of Israel is totally out of proportion and targeting civilians, targeting men, women and children is absolutely unacceptable.”

Pro-Palestine activists march down Forbes Ave. between Schenley Plaza and Carnegie Mellon University on Friday, Oct. 13, 2023. The rally, organized in part by Pitt students gathered for a free Palestine, started in Schenley Plaza with a few speakers, followed by a march from the University of Pittsburgh to Carnegie Mellon and back. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

But for many in the Jewish community, the rallies seen across the nation and world are based on misinformation and people not understanding what is taking place in Israel and Gaza.

Mr. Markovic said that anytime a child is hurt, whether they are Jewish or not, is “a sad, disgusting thing.” But he said Hamas needs to be rooted out of Gaza or things will remain the same.

“Same way we had to root ISIS out of Afghanistan, we’ve got to get them out of Gaza,” Mr. Markovic said.

Advertise with us

Shabbat services

The deadly Hamas attack is not just another geopolitical event for Jewish people, explained a Pittsburgh rabbi. It is dredging up generations of visceral trauma, especially in Pittsburgh — the city scarred by the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history.

“More Jews were killed last Shabbat … than on any other day since the Holocaust,” said Rabbi Daniel Fellman of Temple Sinai on Friday night during the first service following the violence in Israel. “It isn’t that Hamas wants the destruction of Israel. It’s that Hamas wants the destruction of you and me.

“The world deserves better, the Palestinian people deserve better and we need to do better.”

Despite that anguish, Rabbi Fellman’s congregation heeded the words of an Israeli soldier who had urged worshippers “to go sing and dance, go make sure that every person in the world hears us singing this prayer this Shabbat.”

Advertise with us

Rabbi Fellman preached on the biblical story of the first murder — that of Abel by his brother Cain — and urged an understanding that all people are siblings, including Jews, Christians and Muslims.

Suzi Neft, center, and congregants of Temple Sinai sing during a Shabbat service Friday, Oct. 13, 2023, in Pittsburgh. The congregation later prayed for the safety of the state of Israel for peace and said a memorial prayer for those killed and missing after Hamas' attack. (Associated Press)

“They are all our brothers and sisters, and when one of us hurts, we all hurt. If we can’t see that we share this earth, that we share God’s love, ... then we are doomed to live the curse of Cain and Abel again and again.”

For Rabbi Seth Adelson of Congregation Beth Shalom in Pittsburgh, receiving the news about the attack last Saturday morning as he headed to worship brought back traumatic memories of Oct. 27, 2018. That Sabbath morning was shattered by news that a gunman attacked the nearby Tree of Life synagogue and killed 11 people from three congregations meeting there.

The difference, he said in an interview, was “we just we could not comprehend the idea of a shooting at a synagogue in Pittsburgh.” By comparison, last week’s Hamas attack was “tragic and horrifying and gut wrenching, but it was believable.”

Pittsburgh’s Jewish community is now grappling with the attacks on Israel while keeping tabs on family and friends who are still in the country.

Advertise with us

Adir Turgeman was out with friends last weekend at the University of Pittsburgh when he learned of the attacks. Mr. Turgeman, 27, who is studying computer science at California University of Pennsylvania, has family in Israel. Some of his friends were present at the Supernova trance music festival, around three miles from the border with the Gaza Strip, when it was hit hard by Hamas attacks last weekend. Many are now missing. Others are serving in the Israel Defense Forces, working as medics or in other roles.

“You feel so helpless, you feel so, not really selfish but those thoughts of like how is my best friend that I’ve known since daycare going to text me ‘Hey I’m going to go there trying to rescue people. If I’m not coming back, just so you know I love you,’” Mr. Turgeman said. “And I’m here doing nothing. It’s probably one of the hardest things.”

Mr. Turgeman is now leaning on Pittsburgh’s Jewish community to help him through. Many nights he has slept on the couch of different families and has attended events where he received community support.

“The Jewish community here is really helpful. … It’s an awful situation and I would prefer not meeting those families and not having to go through that but once you go through that you see the actual strength of the Jewish people and the Israelis,” Mr. Turgeman said. “They always unite together and you definitely feel it here.”

Mr. Markovic watched as his wife learned about the deaths of many people she knew from growing up in Ami’oz near the Gaza Strip. Her immediate family is safe, he said, but has been displaced. Mr. Markovic said he is “disgusted, horrified” by the attacks but noted that “it’s been very nice to see” the Squirrel Hill community gather around his wife to show her support while attending various prayer events to honor Israel. Community members and businesses are now working to arrange a streetwide day of support to raise money for Israel.

Advertise with us

And throughout the afternoon Friday, light purple chalk began appearing on Squirrel Hill sidewalks depicting three candles in support of Israel. The pictures were drawn by Basya Taub, Hadassah Rothman and Gabriella Balyasny, all 17, who were given outlines from their teachers at Yeshiva Schools of Pittsburgh Girls.

“When we light a candle or do a good deed it affects all the way in Israel,” Basya said.

Hadassah said she was “shocked” to learn about the attacks in Israel, but “I believe everything will get to a good resolution and Israel will come out stronger.”

For the girls, drawing candles on the sidewalk is a way for them to rally together and to bring more good deeds into the world.

Mordechai Telled, who works in the Murray Avenue Kosher deli, echoed the support of the Squirrel Hill community.

Advertise with us

Mr. Telled was home with his father last Sunday when his brother broke the news of the attacks. Mr. Telled was celebrating the Sabbath, meaning he was not using his phone.

“Horrifying, just worrying about the people that I know that are there,” Mr. Telled said of his reaction to the attacks. “It’s just horrifying, gruesome, morbid, horrendous, heinous.”

But over the past week there have been Jewish prayer services and nights of unity. Those events, Mr. Telled said, are “unfathomable. Really amazing and inspiring.”

For Mr. Turgeman, people need to now focus on spreading awareness.

“We know our reality,” Mr. Turgeman said. “People outside, people in the U.S., people in Europe, they don’t know our reality. You see a lot of things on the news and all the things on social media. You can see a lot of misinformation, you can see a lot of things that get out of context and in order for us to get support in the world … we need people to spread the word and show the truth.”

Associated Press and staff writer Laura Esposito contributed.