Megan Pellechio normally looks forward to distributing hot meals outside the overnight shelter at the Smithfield United Church of Christ. She’s able to feed people in need and says the frequent visitors have become a kind of community.

Now, she doesn’t know what’s going to happen to the people she fed every week, and many of them don’t know either.

“Two people have come up to me already,” she said. “They were like, ‘Where are we supposed to go tomorrow?’ ”

After weeks of outcry, the Smithfield Street shelter opened its doors one final night on Tuesday. It officially ceased operation around 7 a.m. Wednesday, and people were asked to disperse from the area.

Advertise with us

The temporary shelter extended past its winter operations to continue meeting the needs of Pittsburgh’s unhoused, providing 145 available beds that fill up every night.

Meanwhile, Allegheny County Council unanimously approved a resolution Tuesday evening recommending County Executive Rich Fitzgerald work with Pittsburgh and state officials to look at using part, if not all, of the shuttered Veterans Hospital site on Highland Drive for a low-barrier shelter.

Ms. Pellechio said the need is more desperate than ever. And she feels the solutions are everywhere, including in all the abandoned buildings she sees around Pittsburgh.

“They need to build more shelters,” she said. “Right by my apartment, there's an abandoned middle school that’s been sitting there. There are places.”

She said the decision to close the shelter is “inhumane” and “cruel,” as people scramble to figure out what to do next. She said some have secured other shelter beds, but places like Second Avenue Commons remain full. But even with those other alternatives, she said people are going to be displaced to other parts of the cities unfamiliar to them where they won’t know how to access other resources.

Advertise with us

“I think it would be different if they were closing it and giving an alternative,” she said. “They're saying that they have beds for everyone, but they don't. And they're saying that they're not going to be allowed to congregate on the steps here anymore.”

As the shelter provided a reliable place to sleep, Ms. Pellechio, activist Lorenzo Rulli and others garnered community donations to cater meals and bring other necessities for those in need.

Tuesday’s menu included pizza and soda — it took two deliveries to feed everyone.

Next to the food distribution table, piles of clothes were laid across the sidewalk for people to pick up. She said women’s hygiene products and men’s clothing are the biggest need.

She says she heard the arguments of those against the shelter during a public hearing last week, including concerns from local business owners. She said the misconceptions about unhoused people ran rampant.

Advertise with us

“The representation of homeless people — you know that they're all drug addicts, you know, violent,” she said. “That's what we keep hearing like they're all violent. They're all drug addicts, or they're messing up Smithfield street and they're not. They're taking away their safe place and that's frustrating.”

Ms. Pellechio,  master’s student at University of Pittsburgh, said she hopes to land a job at one of the local shelters so she can continue to help.

“We'll just have to figure it out,” she said. “We're not going to leave them.”

Andre White, who has been experiencing homelessness for the past year and half, says the shelter has been his nightly mainstay for the past several months. He said DHS found him a bed at Second Avenue Commons to spend nights in. But he wants to see city and county leadership spend more time listening to people on the ground, saying the trust is broken. Leaving people at a shelter with no “structure” doesn’t get to the root of the issue, he said.

Mr. White wants to see mental health care better integrated into the shelter system and increased assistance with life skills, such as getting a job.

Advertise with us

“We'll go to another area where the same problem persists,” he said. “Instead of pushing the problem elsewhere, just clean the problem up by helping people out.”

In a county that receives $23 million for services related to supportive housing, he wants to see more places open up for people. As he spoke, he gave his last piece of pizza to a friend passing by on a bike.

“People just want to be heard,” he said. “That's all that's all most people want.”

During a public hearing last week about the closing of Smithfield, Council member Robert Palmosina asked county Department of Human Services officials whether they had looked at plans to use the VA site for a low-barrier shelter. DHS officials said they would look into whether the site could be used as a shelter.

At Tuesday's meeting, Aubrey Plesh, director of the Smithfield Shelter, told council members that she was concerned about the guests who would be without their shelter come Wednesday morning. During public comment, she said there are 544 unique individuals who have used the shelter's services in June. At least 60 people will have nowhere to go by tomorrow morning, she said.

Advertise with us

"There are people tomorrow that will have nowhere to go in our county. I don't have an answer. I hope you guys can find one," she told the council.

Earlier in the meeting, Council member Bethany Hallam asked county Executive Rich Fitzgerald about the county's plans for people who would be displaced by Smithfield Shelter. The county executive had just finished giving his quarterly report. Mr. Fitzgerald said, as has been outlined by DHS officials, that Smithfield Shelter was never designed to be a year-round shelter.

"It's not a shelter, like a lot of us think of, with beds and other parameters," Mr. Fitzgerald said. "It's got cots in the basement. So whatever DHS recommends ... is what I'll continue to work on, and see where they go."

Multiple council members still have questions, including Suzanne Filiaggi. Ms. Filiaggi said during the public hearing last week that it's important that city, county and other officials have some sort of "strategy" moving forward concerning helping those who are unhoused.

In an interview after Tuesday's meeting, she said she would like to see more transparency about where the county and city are headed in helping the homeless. It's doesn't seem like there is much coordination between the two, Ms. Filiaggi said.

Advertise with us

She added that the former VA building could be a good idea, but that there needs to be more discussion. There could be stigma associated with housing people in such a place.

"Sometimes it's the perception that's getting in the way -- we don't want to put people in a former institution, because that may give them a diminished sense of self-worth. That is not our goal," Ms. Filiaggi said.