FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — Under the beaming South Florida sun and swaying palm trees along Fort Lauderdale’s beachfront promenade, Bill Brown wonders what might have been if the city’s former police chief had the chance to finish what he started.
Mr. Brown is president of Fort Lauderdale’s Central Beach neighborhood association. Boasting a miles-long beach, boutiques, clubs, tiki bars and ritzy hotels, this neighborhood — and the city itself — is a palm-dotted piece of paradise. It’s also the kind of place that has rapidly attracted a more diverse population and, in Mr. Brown’s view, was ready to see a police department that reflected that change when chief Larry Scirotto took the helm in 2021.
But less than a year later, Mr. Scirotto was fired amid allegations that he favored non-white job candidates.
“There's that word, change,” Mr. Brown said in an interview here this month. “Things changed quickly. The mindset of certain individuals did not change as quickly.”
Now Mr. Scirotto is Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey’s pick to lead the city’s police department. His nomination was approved by City Council on Tuesday. Interviews with Fort Lauderdale residents and neighborhood groups show that even in a place where he was fired, Mr. Scirotto’s vision for police reform resonated with those tired of the status quo.
Mr. Scirotto, 49, spent 23 years with the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, rising to be the youngest assistant chief in department history. In that position, he implemented policies and procedures to diversify officer ranks. He has said those efforts were a primary reason he was hired in Fort Lauderdale.
“He excelled through the ranks to help facilitate change” in Pittsburgh, Mr. Brown said. “And that was one of the things that impressed a lot of the community leaders who had great hopes he would be able to make the change in our community.”
Christina Currie, a lawyer who chaired the Citizens’ Police Review Board in Fort Lauderdale, was among those who listened in on a day of interviews with Mr. Scirotto and other candidates during the hiring process. The interviews lasted about eight hours and, by the end of the day, she felt the choice was clear.
“The person who came out on top was Larry, so I think it's pretty obvious that the approach that he was coming to the table with was what the community wanted,” she said.
Soon after he took the job, Mr. Brown recalled, Mr. Scirotto joined a neighborhood meeting via Zoom to discuss his approach to policing. Central Beach residents liked what they heard, Mr. Brown said.
“They were excited to hear that more officers are going to be community-oriented and have more direct contact with the public,” he said. “It was a new approach to community policing, and from what he had expressed, it was very successful in not only the Pittsburgh area, but also in other cities around the nation.”
But ultimately, Mr. Brown believes it was those same ideas that led to Mr. Scirotto’s ouster last year.
A report from a law firm Fort Lauderdale hired to investigate concluded that his approach to hiring and promotions unfairly focused on minority candidates. The report, which is included in a wrongful termination lawsuit Mr. Scirotto filed against the city, said he once pointed to a conference room wall bearing photos of the department’s command staff and said it was “too white” and that “I’m gonna to change that.”
Mr. Scirotto has defended his hiring practices and has filed a lawsuit against Fort Lauderdale city officials.
“I promoted 15 people. Nine of the 15 were white men, six were minorities,” Mr. Scirotto, who has been serving as acting chief pending his confirmation, told City Council during a public interview last week. “To suggest that I chose unqualified people to sit in these seats is disingenuous and just an outright lie.”
Local groups were quick to rally to Mr. Scirotto’s defense after he was fired. The Dolphin Democrats, the oldest LGBTQ political organization in Florida, passed a resolution demanding he be reinstated and that the city consider imposing “less severe” punishment for “any missteps he made.”
Cecil Stone, president of the Fort Lauderdale Black Police Officers Association, wrote a letter to his members assuring them that the “overwhelming majority” of their coworkers believe non-white officers are “equally qualified” and as “capable of leading the police department” as any other group.
Mr. Stone said the city’s discrediting of Black and minority officers with master’s degrees, “stellar reputations” and “exemplary work history” was “nothing short of appalling.”
“We will make sure you get the respect and congratulations you deserve not because of your skin color or sexual orientation but because of your intelligence, commitment to the values of policing and your dedication to service,” he wrote in the letter.
Ms. Currie said in an interview that Mr. Scirotto came into the department with a target on his back, someone seen as an “outsider” and a threat to a long-established “good ole’ boy” system. While he had the backing of the community, she said, he didn’t have full “buy-in” from Citizens’ Police Review Board or everyone in the department.
She noted that former Chief Rick Maglione had been allowed to stay at the department as a major even after Mr. Scirotto took over.
A city spokesperson declined to provide comment on pending litigation.
“You had a certain population of individuals who worked at that law enforcement entity that were in power for a very long time, and they seem to think things were OK because that’s what was working for them for a long time,” Ms. Currie said. “There absolutely was a lot of resistance to Larry.”
She remains outspoken that Mr. Scirotto’s firing was unjust and only further eroded community trust in the department.
“When the community says, ‘This is the type of leader that we're looking for, we support this, we're engaged, we're participating,’ and then all of a sudden you take that person away?” she said.
“Do you think that it makes me trust what they're doing with law enforcement?” Ms. Currie said. “Terminating him and calling him a reverse racist, do you think that that improves the circumstances at the heart of bad relationships between law enforcement and the community?”
Not all of Mr. Scirotto’s agenda was well received by community leaders and stakeholders.
He wanted to shake up Fort Lauderdale’s neighborhood action teams, or NATs — officers designated as community liaisons. Their main job was to interact with residents, but Mr. Scirotto wanted that to be something every officer took on.
For some community members, it was too much too soon, said Mary Peloquin, president of the Council of Fort Lauderdale Civic Associations, a coalition of about 60 civic and homeowner groups.
“They were people that you could call on right away, and he disbanded that immediately,” she said. “I was disappointed because our whole community action team… it was just gone. I was like, ‘Well, who do I call now?’ You know, I was responsible for my own neighborhood. A lot of people really lost their minds.”
Mr. Scirotto has advocated a similar approach as he takes over the department in Pittsburgh.
“If all of our officers are accessible, our officers are available, then those that will be responding in times of crisis will have the best opportunity to succeed,” he told the Post-Gazette in an interview last week. “When we make it a unit’s responsibility, well, that’s not the person that answers the call in the middle of the night.”
Jackie Scott, who has lived in Fort Lauderdale since 1950, has been civically active since the 1980s and served on roughly 15 different city boards. She had been friends with police chiefs in the past, but she said she never saw anyone with a “passion” for the job like Mr. Scirotto.
She viewed his firing as “political retribution.”
“I was just angry,” she said. “I was disappointed. We don't need to have law enforcement controlled by the good ole’ boys. We need to have a department, Pittsburgh needs to have a department, where it's run by someone that doesn't operate that way.”
When talking about Mr. Scirotto’s fit for the role of police chief, some pointed to how Fort Lauderdale has changed over the last decade,
The city has grown — and fast. The slow-paced, retiree-centric coastal towns found elsewhere in the state aren’t here. Fort Lauderdale saw consistent population growth from 2011 to 2020.
Since 2010, the downtown population alone has skyrocketed 80%. And across the city, the population has become increasingly multicultural. More than 21% of residents are foreign-born, primarily from Latin America. The city also boasts one of the largest proportions of Haitian-born residents in the U.S.
And the last decade saw a 43% rise in residents ages 25 to 44.
“City leaders wanted change,” Mr. Brown said. “They saw the change in demographics in Fort Lauderdale. I just find it very disturbing to [fire Mr. Scirotto] knowing the importance of diversity.”
Like in Fort Lauderdale, Mr. Scirotto has called for a more diverse police force in Pittsburgh. This time, he’s coming to a city changing at a slower pace. In recent years, Pittsburgh has increasingly attracted a younger population, but it remains mostly white. The city’s Black population dropped 13% between 2010 and 2020, according to census data.
While Ms. Scott was disappointed Mr. Scirotto didn’t get to see through his long-term vision for the police in Fort Lauderdale, she was happy to see him return to Pittsburgh.
“Even after this whole firing happened, he still ended up being selected,” she said. “He landed in a place where he's already known and trusted, and people, obviously, they can read between the lines.”
Mr. Brown put it this way: “Fort Lauderdale’s loss is Pittsburgh’s gain.”
—Megan Guza and Hallie Lauer contributed to this report.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.