Finalists for the Pittsburgh police chief job include two former city bureau of police employees and the former chief of police in Boise, Idaho, the Post-Gazette has learned.

Jason Lando spent more than two decades with Pittsburgh police and for years led the Zone 5 station. He’s the current chief in Frederick, Md.

Larry Scirotto was an assistant chief in Pittsburgh and most recently led the Fort Lauderdale, Fla., department before he was fired for allegedly favoring non-white candidates for promotions.

The third finalist is Ryan Lee, who narrowly escaped felony charges for severely injuring a fellow officer while demonstrating a suspect-control movement during a staff meeting and was ultimately asked to resign last year amid complaints from coworkers.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey said early this week that, after a search process that stretched for more than nine months, he would announce the city’s next chief within two weeks. At the time, he declined to say how many finalists there were.

Chief Lando left Pittsburgh in 2021. He worked as an officer and commander in Zone 5 and had most recently led the city’s Narcotics and Vice division prior to his departure.

In Pittsburgh, he was lauded for his work to improve police-community relations, praise that carried over to Maryland, too, with Mayor Michael O’Connor last year calling Chief Lando’s work outstanding.

In Frederick, Chief Lando launched what’s called the crisis car — an unmarked police vehicle staffed by a plainclothes officer, an emergency medical technician or paramedic and a mental health care professional. The team responds to mental health emergencies throughout the city.

Mr. Scirotto was an assistant chief in Pittsburgh until he retired from the bureau in 2018. Before that, he’d been a finalist to lead the Portland, Ore., police department. He accepted the Fort Lauderdale job in June 2021 and took over the department that August.

Advertise with us

He served for about six months before he was fired for his alleged focus on hiring and promoting minority candidates.

Mr. Scirotto told CNN in the aftermath of his firing that he’d promoted 15 people from August to November 2021, six of whom were ethnic or gender minorities. He said they were promoted based on merit.

“None of them were promoted because they were in a protected class,” he told CNN. “They were promoted because they were the best candidates.”

An investigation of complaints about Mr. Scirotto’s hiring practices noted he’d once said the photos of police personnel on a conference room wall were “too white” and remarked that he would change that, according to the Tampa Bay Times. And once, while considering whom to promote, Mr. Scirotto said, “which one is [more Black]?” the investigation found.

The report that led to his firing concluded: “Overall, there is a very divisive atmosphere within the department based on the perception the chief is intentionally using race, gender and sexual orientation as attributes necessary for promotions.”

Advertise with us

It continued: “While the goal to diversify is an important and laudable goal it must be accomplished in a legally permissible manner,” the newspaper reported.

Mr. Scirotto sued the city last month, claiming he was wrongfully terminated. His attorney called the allegations of an improper minority-first approach baseless ones that have “severely damaged his reputation,” according to NBC6 in Florida.

He has continued his work as a college basketball referee, which he started in the 1990s. He has worked for the Big Ten for more than a decade, according to a profile by Slate.

Mr. Lee spent nearly two decades with the Portland Police Department before he took over as the top cop in Boise.

He spent just over two years as head of the Boise police before he was asked to resign. He was confirmed unanimously by Boise City Council in June 2020.

Advertise with us

Mayor Lauren McLean at the time called him the “perfect choice” for the city, according to the Idaho Statesman. The announcement came just weeks after the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police sparked protests and demonstrations nationwide.

The October 2021 incident allegedly involved Mr. Lee demonstrating two types of holds on a sergeant during a staff meeting, which ended with the sergeant severely injured. The sergeant later claimed Mr. Lee broke his neck.

Eight months later, Idaho State Police announced there would be no criminal charges filed against Mr. Lee. The county prosecutor’s office indicated there was enough evidence to charge the chief with a felony but concluded the charge couldn’t be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, according to the Statesman.

In a letter written by Clearwater County Prosecutor Clayne Tyler and obtained by the Statesman, Mr. Tyler wrote, “This decision was not reached lightly nor without angst, as it truly is a close call.” The letter was dated Aug. 26, 2022, according to the newspaper.

Just over three weeks later, KTVB reported that nine officers had filed complaints against the chief in the spring of 2022 alone. A memo obtained by the TV station and written by Office of Police Accountability Director Jesus Jara recommended in April of that year that the chief be put on paid leave pending further investigation.

Advertise with us

The office ultimately recommended that a third-party firm specializing in “employment law and potentially hostile work environments” should take over the investigation.

Emails obtained by KTVB alleged Chief Lee called his employees names like “a—hat,” “idiot” and “hucklebuck,” a derogatory term for hillbilly. The emails, according to the TV station, allege “rampant favoritism” and a fear of retaliation among Mr. Lee’s employees.

A day after the TV station aired the story regarding the complaints, Mayor McLean asked the chief to resign, according to the Spokesman-Review.

As he rose through the ranks in Portland, he became known for his research and expertise on crowd control tactics, the Idaho Statesman wrote in a profile upon his hiring in Boise. Key to Portland’s new techniques was a protest liaison — someone meant to build rapport with protest group leaders and encourage them to self-police when it came to violent protesters.

In 2019, though, text messages came to light between the lieutenant Mr. Lee chose to lead protest responses and the organizer of the right-wing group Patriot Prayer. The Statesman reported that the texts showed “friendly sounding information-sharing.”