With what one official called “a perfect storm” following a spike in COVID cases, the end of an eviction moratorium and now harsh winter weather, the city’s homeless shelters say they’re full to capacity and scrambling to find slots for new arrivals.
“What you really see when winter weather occurs is just this overall increase in vulnerability,” said Shannon Shaffer, senior manager of operations at Bethlehem Haven, a Downtown emergency shelter run by Pittsburgh Mercy.
The women’s shelter’s 28 beds are currently full, and they’ve had to work with other groups such as Shepherd’s Heart and The Red Door to accommodate overflow.
Ms. Shaffer said not only has the county’s recent end of its COVID-related eviction moratorium created an increase in first-time homelessness and homelessness among women, shelter officials are also seeing worsening mental health problems and a lack of warm clothing donations as the pandemic stretches into its third year.
“We’ve seen an increase in homelessness — and then we have a winter weather event — and we have more individuals seeking shelter,” Ms. Shaffer said. “Really, it’s been a perfect storm.”
At Pittsburgh Mercy’s winter shelter on Smithfield Street, its 68 beds are also frequently at capacity.
Read More

Before the pandemic, the men’s shelter could sleep 150, but distancing protocols reduced how many residents could safely stay in the building.
As the thermometer dropped to 18 degrees on Thursday evening, a line of men layered in sweatshirts and winter coats slowly filed into the shelter inside Smithfield United Church.
Shifting on their feet to say warm, the arrivals were escaping one of the coldest Pittsburgh nights of the winter so far, when temperatures were expected to drop to 8 degrees.
Some smoked cigarettes, while others huddled against the stone facade of the church to protect themselves from the gusts of wind.
Factoring in the wind chill, it would feel like the temperature was below zero out on the street that evening.
Douglas Murry, the shelter’s supervisor, said that his focus was outfitting residents in proper cold weather clothing, which many didn’t have.
“We’re seeing a lot of guys come in with just regular old tennis shoes, and cold, wet socks,” said Mr. Murry. “So we are trying to pull together some resources to get better winter boots down there.”
When the shelter began in the 2000s, it only opened its doors when the city declared a “Code Blue,” temperatures 25 degrees or lower. That policy was eventually updated, and the shelter now operates nightly from Nov. 15 to March 15 every year.
“Typically we see large donations of boots come in, and this year we just didn’t,” Mr. Murry added. “It is a struggle to us, and it’s something we’re going to be worried about.”

Mr. Murry has seen firsthand what happens when his residents lack the proper gear.
More individuals have been coming in to the Smithfield shelter with frostbite on their fingers and toes than normal, he said. While that’s common during the winter, he’s noticed a sharp increase as the temperatures dropped in recent weeks.
“It’s starting to take effect now,” Mr. Murry said, “people not being prepared for these temperatures.”
At Bethlehem Haven, Ms. Shaffer said new arrivals have been better prepared with warm clothing, but instead face mounting mental health issues.
“The trauma of eviction, the trauma of experiencing homelessness for the first time, then the winter weather event” Ms. Shaffer attributed to this increase. “They’re coming to us, and maybe they’re physically prepared, but their mental health symptoms are exacerbated.”
Keeping them safe
Despite the challenges faced by shelters in the midst of freezing temperatures and a lingering pandemic, advocates for the homeless haven’t stopped searching for ways to keep this population safe.
At Bethlehem Haven, which normally only operates during the evening, residents who stayed over last Sunday night when a heavy snow began did not have to leave the next day, Ms. Shaffer said. She’s noticed other night shelters open their doors during the daytime, too.
‘Traditionally, guests would exit the building and search for employment or other things, [but] we’ve accommodated individuals for safety purposes,” she said. “Because we’re very focused on safety during these significant events.”
According to a survey conducted in Jan. 2021, there were 692 homeless identifying people in Allegheny County, 509 who were in shelters.
The county’s count for 2022 was delayed until February, however, due to delays from the rise in omicron cases.
For shelters that are hitting capacity, the county’s Office of Community Services has optioned its Safe Haven Hotel, a converted string of rooms leased from a local hotel. During the pandemic, the rooms became quarantine and isolation spaces for homeless individuals who were COVID positive.

Abigail Horn, deputy director of the OCS, said individuals who can’t be housed at Pittsburgh Mercy are being taken to the hotel, which has an undisclosed location. Her department also assists Shepherd’s Heart, the Catholic Charities of Pittsburgh and other regional organizations.
Ms. Horn mentioned that Shepherd’s Heart, which normally closes during the day, kept their doors open during last weekend’s storm.
“We’re hustling to make sure that folks have somewhere to go,” Ms. Horn said. “We want to make sure everyone has a warm place to stay.”
Later she hinted that an end to this balancing act may arrive by next winter.
According to Ms. Horn, the county aims to open a shelter called the Second Avenue Commons later in 2022. The project is in partnership with Pittsburgh Mercy, the city of Pittsburgh, Action Housing, Allegheny Health Network, UPMC and other organizations.
The five-story, 42,000-square-foot facility will provide 24/7 shelter access to adults, their partners, their pets, as well as healthcare, laundry and single-occupancy housing.
“The idea is that we won’t have to run these winter shelters in churches once we have that new facility,” Ms. Horn said. “We’re really excited about that.”
The following organizations are available to those seeking shelter this winter:
Overnight shelters
(open 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. nightly, doors lock at 11 p.m.)
Smithfield Winter Shelter (open for men, inclusive of transgender and nonbinary individuals)
Smithfield United Church of Christ
620 Smithfield Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219
———-
CHS Winter Shelter (open for women, inclusive of transgender and nonbinary individuals)
Shepherd’s Heart Fellowship
13 Pride Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Daytime warming centers
Catholic Charities Warming Center (open Monday-Friday, 7:30 a.m. to 5 p.m.)
212 9th Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
———-
Red Door Warming Center (open Monday-Friday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.)
202 Stanwix Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Stay safe out there as the temperature dips. https://t.co/vDxnCl2njb
— Pittsburgh Public Safety (@PghPublicSafety) January 21, 2022





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.