An effort to ban plastic bags in Pittsburgh is teeing up a debate between two sides of advocacy: industry vs. environmental.

“Any bag in the environment doesn’t belong there,” said Zachary Taylor, the director of the American Recyclable Plastic Bag Alliance, which represents the plastic bag manufacturing and recycling industry. “But, banning plastic bags opens the door to unintended consequences, while maybe not achieving the underlying goal of dramatically reducing litter in the community.”

Logan Welde, a staff attorney and the director of legislative affairs for Clean Air Council, an environmental nonprofit based in Philadelphia, calls that “industry propaganda.”

“These are myths that industry creates to make everyone feel better about the waste that we are creating in our societies,” he said.

Advertise with us

The two sides got a chance to voice their arguments — and help shape the legislation that would put the bag ban in place — at a meeting Friday with Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, who introduced the legislation in November.

Under the proposed legislation, Pittsburgh shoppers would be encouraged to bring their own reusable bags to the grocery store or other retailers — or could purchase a paper bag for a 15-cent fee. Plastic bags would not be an option.

Businesses would keep the proceeds from that fee, partly to offset the cost of paper bags or reusable bags. The legislation also would likely include some exemptions for things like bags used at dry cleaners or pharmacies.

Some of the details of the legislation are still up for debate and the discussion at Friday’s meeting focused on how to enforce a ban and whether to include a “carve-out,” or exemptions, for people who receive SNAP, WIC or other social service assistance.

Ms. Strassburger also asked how to weigh the different types of bags and restrictions the legislation could put in place: Should there be a ban on plastic and paper bags? What about a fee for both? Or, a fee for one and a ban on the other?

Advertise with us

“What we’re trying to get at is almost social science,” Ms. Strassburger said. “What is going to change consumer behavior?”

Advocates for the plastic bag ban point to the impact of plastic on our environment as a reason to reduce single-use bags.

PennEnvironment, an environmental group that advocated for the legislation, estimates the proposed ban could prevent more than 108 million single-use plastic bags from entering the waste stream, based on bag consumption in the city of Pittsburgh.

But critics, including Mr. Taylor from the American Recyclable Plastic Bag Alliance, say these types of bans could have unintended consequences.

It could be difficult for small businesses to afford paper bags for customers, or to enforce a ban on plastic. It could be expensive for low-income shoppers to pay a fee. And a ban on plastic could push customers to use other types of bags that could have a greater impact on the environment, like paper.

Advertise with us

On top of that, plastic doesn’t make up a big portion of waste in landfills or litter, he said. Already, some stores offer programs to let customers bring plastic bags back, allowing them to be recycled and turned into new products, like railroad ties, composite lumber and more bags.

“Policies should be demonstrated in such a way to ensure the unintended consequences don’t outweigh any benefit,” Mr. Taylor said. “We’d love to be part of the discussion and talk about alternative approaches without opening the door to unintended consequences of forcing people to use bags that have greater environmental impact.”

Mr. Welde from the Clean Air Council pushed back, arguing that Mr. Taylor wasn’t looking at the right statistics. Consumers are already paying for bags, he argued, because businesses are baking that cost into the price of items. And plastic bags may make a small percentage of litter but one bag can clog a sewer system, he said.

In Pittsburgh, plastic bags make up about 5% of all the trash on the streets, according to estimates from Litterati, a crowd-sourcing platform where volunteers can report litter they identify.

Bags in general make up about 8% of litter, excluding cigarette butts and other trash that isn’t identifiable. Of that 8%, 15% are paper, 15% are unidentifiable and nearly 70% are plastic.

Advertise with us

Aftyn Giles, the senior sustainability coordinator for the city of Pittsburgh, said about 10% of the plastic bags consumers use are recycled.

They’re likely to be recycled only once, meaning “they’re downgraded from bringing in groceries” to something that lines our trash cans, she said. “And, ultimately, thrown away after only one use.”

At Friday’s meeting, industry and environmental advocates agreed that enforcement of a ban would need to be simple.

Mr. Welde pointed out that exemptions, including a carve-out for low-income residents, could make enforcement difficult.

Mr. Taylor agreed that the design should be streamlined, adding that checking “which stores are using which bags creates the potential for a game of whack-a-mole.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Strassburger suggested a self-certification system like the program Allegheny County set up when implementing and enforcing health and safety guidelines for businesses amid the COVID-19 pandemic.

Right now, Council members are still discussing where this legislation would “live.” In other words, which department would be in charge of enforcement.

The list of contenders so far includes the Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections or environmental services or “somewhere in sustainability and resiliency.”

This article has been corrected to reflect Mr. Taylor’s willingness to discuss alternative approaches to the proposed legislation on plastic bag use that would not introduce unintended consequences, rather than proposed alternatives to plastics.

Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1565.