World-renowned experts are coming to Pittsburgh next week for a conference aimed at ending hate-based violence around the globe, but two local groups are criticizing event organizers for inviting several keynote speakers who they say have contributed to that extremism.
Bend the Arc: Pittsburgh and Casa San Jose, left-leaning groups that advocate for immigrants and refugees, expressed disappointment in the Eradicate Hate Global Summit’s inclusion of former President George W. Bush; former Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Ridge, the founding secretary of the Department of Homeland Security; and Alejandro Mayorkas, the sitting DHS secretary.
“It is gratifying that President Bush, Secretary Mayorkas, and Mr. Ridge wish to lend their stature to the cause of eradicating hate, and we recognize that their prominence helps to draw attention to the ambitious and critical work of all the summit attendees,” the two organizations said in a joint statement. “However, the legacy of their work stands in stark contrast to lofty goals of the summit itself.”
The organizations said Mr. Bush’s legacy “is one of promoting, not eradicating, hate.” They noted that the former president responded to the 9/11 terrorist attacks by creating the Department of Homeland Security, which they say “exploited anti-Islamic fervor to justify an aggressive expansion of domestic surveillance, harassment, and entrapment of Americans who practice Islam, have Arab or Middle Eastern heritage, or fit a stereotype of these cultures.”
The organizations noted that DHS was founded under the leadership of Mr. Ridge and that its work continues under Mr. Mayorkas.
Event organizers said they had no response to the joint statement.
Read More
The summit was organized in response to the Oct. 27, 2018, mass shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill, believed to be the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history.
Bend the Arc: Pittsburgh and Casa San Jose said in their joint statement that although the alleged synagogue shooter targeted the Jewish community, he believed in a white supremacist conspiracy known as the “replacement theory.” The conspiracy is based on the false idea that Jews control immigration to the U.S. and want to turn white people into a racial minority by replacing them with immigrants of color.
“If one of the summit’s goals is to ‘maintain broad public vigilance against hate crimes by highlighting the diversity of its victims,’ we need to acknowledge that the people targeted by the War on Terror and DHS are often themselves victims of hate,” the organizations said. “We need to acknowledge that elevating the voices of Bush, Ridge, and Mayorkas in a conference against hate instead whitewashes their roles in racially-based human rights abuses.”
Mr. Bush and Mr. Ridge are scheduled to give virtual keynote speeches Monday. Mr. Mayorkas will be a keynote speaker Tuesday.
The summit runs Monday through Wednesday at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center in Downtown and features dozens of local, national and international professionals in a variety of fields who will participate in panels and other activities over the three days.
By the end of the event, organizers said, the experts should come up with achievable goals that can be worked on in the coming months and reviewed at a summit around the same time next year.
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.