Pittsburgh Public Safety's Bureau of Animal Care & Control should consider building its own animal shelter as an alternative to contracting impound services, a city controller audit found.

The audit, released this week by the office of City Controller Michael Lamb, said the city’s reliance on Humane Animal Rescue’s impounding services provides no alternative if the local government and HAR were unable to reach an agreement.

“[Animal control] averages 1,200 stray animal pick-ups annually,” the audit reads. “The only other animal shelter large enough in the area to handle this workload is Animal Friends” in Ohio Township.

Animal Friends, a “no-kill” shelter, already turned down such an offer from the city because the location operates at 94% capacity daily, the audit says.

Advertise with us

The alternative could be a municipal shelter that the city could build on one of its vacant properties, the audit suggests, although it urges the completion of a full cost-benefit analysis first.

In its response, public safety officials said they agreed a city-owned animal shelter would “alleviate many issues, but would be a massive financial commitment and take multiple years before becoming fully operational.” The feasibility of the project will be discussed with public works, the response said.

The city and HAR agreed in September 2020 to extend their contract for one year, but the future of their stray animal detention contract remains uncertain, the audit says, as the executive director of HAR would not discuss a contract exceeding one year.

Another suggestion that the bureau invests in an incinerator or crematorium to reduce the smell of dead animals being stored prior to their disposal at a landfill was rebuffed by public safety.

“The cost and time savings of not traveling to a landfill would be offset by cost and time lost to fueling, maintaining and operating the incinerator,” the response reads, adding that it is unlikely the bureau could find an appropriate location due to the debris and fumes caused by such an operation.

Advertise with us

Other recommendations included that the animal control bureau should update its reporting systems and methods of data collection.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazettec.om; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli