The Hill District has spent most of the past 40 years without a full-service grocery store. Now, several grocers are vying to change that after the neighborhood’s most recently available grocery store shut down in 2019.

On Monday night, more than 100 Hill District residents heard presentations from four businesses bidding to take over the 30,000-square-foot vacancy left by Shop ‘n Save in the Centre Heldman Plaza. The Urban Redevelopment Authority, which now owns the plaza, is soliciting feedback from community members to help choose a vendor.

The businesses provided a variety of different options, including a co-op model, diet-focused food, and Asian- and Middle Eastern-themed store items. Before the meeting, each grocer filled out a questionnaire describing their plans for the vacant space.

The Family Tree Food Company, owned by Daniel Craddock and Khalid Morris, aims to bring natural, organic food to the Hill District at an affordable price, Mr. Craddock said. He compared the shopping experience to that of Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s.

Advertise with us

“We aim to meet the nutrition needs of our city,” Mr. Craddock said.

To achieve that goal, Mr. Craddock and Mr. Morris said, they plan to put a licensed dietitian in the store to help customers pick out food that’s beneficial to their health. They said the store will also have pre-prepared meals that can be customized based on dietary restrictions.

The Family Tree Food Company does not operate any grocery stores, but Mr. Craddock is working to open a location in Denver.

Pierre Development, owned by local chef Claudy Pierre, proposed a co-op model for a new grocery store, one that customers and employees would jointly own. Mr. Pierre suggested filling the space with a grocery store, a hardware store, a pharmacy and an eatery — “a one-stop shop,” he said. Mr. Pierre operates a number of food-centric businesses in the Pittsburgh area.

Fresh International Market operates several Asian-themed full-service grocery stores throughout the country. The grocery store chain, owned by Bowen Kou, offers a large domestic goods section and a smaller Asian goods section, with a large assortment of seafood and fresh produce.

Advertise with us

If chosen as the Hill District’s grocer, Mr. Kou said Fresh International Market would offer one aisle with items directly from Pittsburgh suppliers. Mr. Kou said his main priority is supplying shoppers with fresh items while keeping prices low.

Abdullah Salem was the only one among the bidders to own another grocery store in Pittsburgh. He runs Salem’s Market and Grill in the Strip District, a Middle Eastern market, butcher shop and eatery. Mr. Salem said if he were chosen to operate the Hill District’s lone grocery, he would provide a full-service grocery store with a combination of domestic and Middle Eastern goods.

“We intend to deliver that Whole Foods experience in a way that does not cost a whole paycheck,” he said.

Mr. Salem grew up in Pittsburgh and attended Schenley High School.

Throughout the nearly three-hour meeting, Hill District residents weren’t afraid to make their opinions heard in the Zoom chat.

Advertise with us

One of the meeting’s participants, Will Parker, said in the chat “it’s a ‘no’ for me if you haven’t spoken with Hill District neighborhoods.”

Many participants said that they did not like the idea of a co-op owned grocery store. Others expressed concern that an upscale and expensive grocery store would be out of reach for most Hill District residents, who make on average just over $20,000 a year, according to Census data.

In response to those concerns, all grocers said they would try to keep their products affordable and hire community members to work at their store. Mr. Craddock, of the Family Tree Food Company, said his store would hire up to 72 neighborhood residents at a minimum wage of $15 an hour.

Hill District residents will have until Sept. 30 to fill out a Google form to rate the presentations and select their favorite two grocery store options. URA representatives say they hope to select a grocer by the end of 2021.

Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com