The Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium has indicated it will reapply for membership in the Association of Zoos & Aquariums, a move that can’t happen soon enough for a local animal advocacy organization.

Dr. Brian Bonsteel, president and founder of Humane Action Pittsburgh, said the zoo’s anticipated move to rejoin the AZA coupled with last week’s announcement that Dr. Barbara Baker, the zoo’s president and chief executive officer for the past 31 years, is retiring, opens the door to better, more humane animal care at the 77-acre facility in Highland Park.

“We wish Barbara Baker well, but we’re glad to see her move on,” Dr. Bonsteel said. “And we would love to see the zoo re-establish AZA accreditation. It’s the gold standard. We are glad it seems to be on its way back.”

The 64-year-old of veterinary medicine oversaw the modernization and expansion of exhibits and conservation programs at the 123-year-old zoo, but in 2015 she decided to end the zoo’s 29-year membership in the AZA due to a dispute over a new association policy on elephant handling.

Advertise with us

The AZA’s “protected contact” safety policy for elephant handlers — proposed in 2011, adopted by the organization in 2015 and implemented by zoos in 2017 — mandates sturdy barriers between keepers and elephants most of the time. The vast majority of zoos now use protected contact.

The Pittsburgh Zoo has continued to practice free contact, allowing keepers to be side by side with elephants and use social dominance to control them. The zoo does practice protected contact at its International Conservation Center, a 724-acre preserve in Somerset County that specializes in the care and breeding of African elephants.

The zoo announced in March that it would reapply for AZA membership and accreditation, saying the decision was made to comply with requirements of its city lease, which mandates that the zoo be an accredited AZA member.

The zoo has been in violation of that provision since 2015, when Dr. Baker cut its ties to the AZA. The current lease runs through 2022.

Dr. Baker could not be reached for comment for this article.

Advertise with us

“We applaud the zoo board’s decision to reapply to the AZA, but we'd like to see the city write a new lease with some teeth in it,” said Dr. Bonsteel, a Shadyside dentist. He noted that the only recourse for the city if the lease is violated is to evict the zoo and its 8,000 animals.

“And that will never happen,” he said. “What we need is a lease with performance clauses to make sure the zoo is in compliance with AZA animal care standards.”

Dr. Bonsteel said his organization’s issues with Dr. Baker date to 2015, when Pittsburgh City Council introduced legislation to ban the use of bullhooks to control circus elephants and Dr. Baker spoke in opposition to the proposal.

Two years later, amended legislation that banned the use of tools that would cause pain at circuses and other venues, including the zoo, passed, Dr. Bonsteel said.

And in March, council unanimously passed an ordinance banning ownership of crocodilian species, including alligators and red-eared slider turtles. Previously owned animals were grandfathered in, along with exceptions for medical and educational facilities, veterinarians and zoos accredited by the AZA.

Advertise with us

Dr. Baker also spoke in opposition to the ordinance, saying it would put the zoo’s reptile programs in jeopardy. She also said there were other and better accrediting associations than the AZA.

City Councilman Bruce Kraus, who sponsored the bill prohibiting alligators and red-eared sliders as pets, said he was happy to see the zoo finally move toward regaining the accreditation.

"It was absolutely the right thing to do. The zoo has clearly been contractually obligated to do so, and I'm very happy this board of directors sees that as the right thing to do," he said.

A day before Mr. Kraus' reptilian regulation passed in March, the zoo announced it would again seek the AZA accreditation, though the process would “take a significant amount of time,” zoo officials said at the time.

"I don't know that they were intertwined, but they happened at the same time," Mr. Kraus said.

Advertise with us

The AZA is the largest, oldest and most prestigious organization of zoos and aquariums, with 241 members in the U.S. and seven other countries.

After dropping out of the AZA, the Pittsburgh Zoo joined two newer, smaller and less prestigious accrediting organizations, the 60-member Zoological Association of America, established in 2005, and the American Humane Association’s Humane Conservation Program, which was started in 2016 and now has 59 members.

Among ZAA members are the Animal World and Snake Farm Zoo in New Braunfels, Texas, and Oswald’s Bear Ranch in Newberry, Mich.

In 2016 the Pittsburgh zoo became the second zoo and fifth aquarium certified by the AHA’s Humane Conservation Program, joining the Wild Hearts African Farm & Petting Zoo in Lewisburg, Ohio; SeaWorld locations in San Antonio, Texas, Orlando, Fla., and San Diego; and Siegfried & Roy’s Secret Garden and Dolphin Habitat at the Mirage Hotel and Casino in Las Vegas.

Dr. Bonsteel said those associations, which represent smaller zoos and animal parks, cheapened and diminished the Pittsburgh Zoo.

Advertise with us

“I think the pressure is on the city, and the city is starting to recognize that it has a problem with accreditation that ultimately affects the animals,”Dr. Bonsteel said. “As taxpayers, as donors, as parents who take their kids to the zoo, we have a responsibility for the welfare of those animals.”

During Dr. Baker’s tenure two fatal accidents occurred at the zoo. One, in November 2002, involved zookeeper Mike Gatti, who was crushed to death by an elephant during a walk around the grounds.

The second occurred in 2012, when a 2-year-old fell from an observation deck into the African painted dog exhibit and was mauled. On at least six occasions before that accident, zoo staff and volunteers raised concerns about the possibility of a child falling through an open side of the exhibit.

The AZA accreditation office, in response to questions, said it does not have an application on file from the Pittsburgh Zoo, but said it was aware that the zoo intends to apply for accreditation. Any zoo applying for accreditation must meet all standards, including the restricted elephant contact policy.

An international search for Dr. Baker’s successor has begun. She will continue working until new leadership is in place, then will be given the title president emeritus. She will serve as a consultant until the end of 2022.

Donna Hudson, chair of the Pittsburgh Zoological Society board, said the goal is to name a successor by the end of 2021.