Three Democratic challengers took turns taking shots at incumbent Bill Peduto’s record in a mayoral debate on Mother’s Day morning.
Tony Moreno, a retired police officer, went after the two-term incumbent’s record on affordable housing issues, while state Rep. Ed Gainey and Michael Thompson, a math tutor, took turns hammering away at Mr. Peduto’s handling of community policing and social justice protests.
The candidates also revisited the city’s ongoing recovery from the coronavirus pandemic.
The hourlong debate, held less than two weeks before the May 18 primary, was sponsored by The Black Political Empowerment Project, a group launched in 1986 to help create political and economic power for people of color in Pittsburgh. It was hosted by WPXI-TV and moderated by news anchor Lisa Sylvester.
All four candidates said they supported Gov. Tom Wolf’s decision not to lift mask mandates until 70% of adults are vaccinated.
“We need to make sure public health is No. 1, because at the end of the day, we’ve seen what this [pandemic] has done,” Mr. Gainey said.
Read More
They also agreed that the one way Downtown businesses — those that lost employees during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic — could get their workers back on the job would be to provide more incentives.
Mr. Gainey suggested providing help with parking and transportation costs along with health care coverage, while Mr. Moreno, without being specific, called for reducing the oversight in bars and restaurants that he said were obstacles to doing business in the city. Mr. Peduto and Mr. Thompson, the math tutor who also is a ride-share driver, proposed bigger paychecks.
“Poverty wages won’t cut it,” said Mr. Peduto, who predicted that Pittsburgh will come out of the pandemic in a very strong position. “Post-COVID, there will need to be better pay and better benefits for workers, and the workers will be there.”
Things got more touchy when Ms. Sylvester asked how they would work to make civilian oversight of police activities more effective.
Mr. Peduto defended his work with the police department and its efforts at de-escalation tactics and said his administration has worked hard to improve its police-community relations.
“We have been able to create more accountability and transparency by making ethics independent, and bringing in investigations and oversight outside of public safety and placing it under law,” he said.
But a continuation of a community dialogue doesn’t necessarily mean the community takes over the police department, he added — just that the community has a voice in the type of police department it wants to see.
That brought an impassioned response from Mr. Thompson.
“If things were going well, you wouldn’t have people in the streets, you wouldn’t have people surrounding Bill Peduto’s house and yelling all night and demanding change,” he retorted.
Because the police are not beholden to the people, Mr. Thompson said, what the city needs is “real reform,” like in East Pittsburgh, where Pennsylvania State Police has taken over patrol.
Mr. Gainey took issue with the fact that the Black community makes up 23% of the city’s population but accounts for 65% of arrests. He also took Mr. Peduto to task for Pittsburgh police using pepper spray on peaceful protesters at close range in Mellon Park last August.
“We need to improve the citizens review board and give them more power so we can create a city where we’re really working on police community relations,” Mr. Gainey said.
“The number one reason we should fire Bill Peduto as our mayor is because of this topic,” Mr. Moreno said. “Civilian oversight is an abject failure,” largely because of the board itself, which he claimed meets only eight times a year, has a $650,000 annual budget, and fails to conduct actual investigations.
Mr. Peduto responded that when he took office in 2014, “we inherited a broken city.” Both violent crime and homicides have gone down over his tenure, he noted, along with the number of lawsuits against officers. He added that the city has taught de-escalation tactics so well, that in all of 2020 only two police officers fired their weapons, and in both cases it was after they were shot at.
“Results and facts matter,” Mr. Peduto said. “Real reform has been occurring.”
“We’re over-policing in neighborhoods where we say we want to build a trust,” Mr. Gainey countered.
Mr. Moreno, who spent 24 years on the city’s police force before retiring in 2018, pointed out that Mr. Gainey’s district has the highest crime rate across the city, so “of course” the police are going to be there. The real problem is the lack of jobs.
“We have been ignoring our communities and blaming it on the police officers,” Mr. Moreno said.
The candidates also were asked about calls to defund the police. Mr. Thompson said his focus was on a new vision of public safety that would replace armed police officer response to calls with alternate approaches, such as sending a social worker. Mr. Gainey agreed that social workers would help to de-escalate certain situations.
Mr. Peduto said no community group or neighborhood has asked for less police, and that calls for defunding are “part of the ‘hashtag politics’ that has taken over a national discussion.”
The candidates all agreed that early education is essential to ensure that children enter the school system ready to learn.
Mr. Gainey said another good step would be meeting with the superintendent and school board, something that he says the Peduto administration has not done in three years. He also suggested repurposing some city buildings for more after-school programs and working to get better broadband into poor neighborhoods.
The most heated discussion involved the lack of affordable housing.
Mr. Peduto said Pittsburgh has one of the lowest costs of housing in the nation, and that his administration was focused on building more units to assure that supply outpaced demand.
Mr. Thompson countered that the real problem with Pittsburgh housing is that developers are too politically connected and receive tax breaks because of those connections.
“A developer’s job is to build things. We should take that money and use it to make a better Pittsburgh instead,” he said.
Mr. Gainey noted the thousands of Black residents who have “been moved or displaced or forced” out of the city. He accused Mr. Peduto of being disingenuous about whether he was aware of the deal to redevelop the Penn Plaza apartments in East Liberty, where more than 200 people were told they had 90 days to find a new place to live because of redevelopment efforts. Penn Plaza was eventually torn down and replaced with an office and retail complex that includes a Whole Foods Market.
“We have to be honest with our citizens,” Mr. Gainey said. “That’s leadership and accountability.”
The candidates said nonprofits need to make a larger contribution to the health of the city.
“We need to approach them and demand more,” said Mr. Moreno, pointing out that Mr. Peduto and Mr. Gainey were both positioning themselves as candidates, when in fact both are in charge as elected officials. “They have done nothing about it for decades.”
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.