A bid to boost the pension of one departing Pittsburgh councilwoman had other city employees thinking about improving their pensions Tuesday, but the concept drew a firm warning from the administration of Mayor Bill Peduto.
A bill that would, in the near term, affect only the pension of Councilwoman Darlene Harris was formally introduced Tuesday and is slated for discussion and an initial vote Wednesday. It has raised awareness in the city ranks of a 15-year-old financial recovery measure set to slash the retirement payments to hundreds of future city retirees.
The bill had some employees thinking: If council can fix Ms. Harris’ pension, why can’t it fix them all?
Slow down, urged Dan Gilman, the mayor’s chief of staff.
The mayor’s office, council members and the city controller carefully crafted the city’s financial recovery, he said. “You can’t start to pull out one block at a time. … We need to fulfill the promises that have already been made, which is having a pension fund that is secure" and can pay what's already owed.
A decade ago, the city’s pension fund held roughly 30% of the money it needed to cover foreseeable future payments. Now — thanks in part to the annual transfer of around $26.8 million in annual parking revenue to the pension fund — those obligations are 60% funded. That puts the fund squarely in the “moderate distress” category, according to state pension funding standards.
Read More
The improvement was enabled in part by a plank in the 2004 recovery plan under which employees hired after June 30 of that year would, upon retirement, see their pensions reduced by half of the amount of Social Security they received.
A few post-2004 hires have applied for partial pensions, and have been shocked at the paltry benefit that remains after the Social Security offset, said John Sibbet, president of the city's Municipal Pension Fund Board.
The offset is “just mean-spirited,” he said. Affected employees think they are “going to get a $2,000 pension, and going out the gate they lose it. As soon as the Social Security offset takes effect, you end up with $1,000.”
The offset, he said, “does save money, but it saves money on the backs of the hard-working men and women who spend their careers working for the city of Pittsburgh."
"The employees and taxpayers have all taken a hit because of the Act 47 [distressed] status,” under which the city endured 14 years of austerity, ending last year, said Controller Michael Lamb. “So city employees are going to try go get their benefits back.”
But any change in pension benefits should be comprehensive — not “elected officials only” — and it shouldn’t erode the retirement fund, he said.
Police and firefighters don't pay into Social Security, don't receive that federal benefit, and thus have never been subject to an offset. The offset applies, though, to nonunion employees hired after June 30, 2004. It also applies to some unionized employees — for instance, public works laborers and drivers hired after Jan. 1, 2007.
The legislation introduced this week by Councilman Ricky Burgess would eliminate the offset only for the nine council posts, the controller and the mayor — and only for those who were in the city’s employ after Jan. 1, 2020, and reached required ages and years of service. Ms. Harris, who lost her bid for a fourth full term this year, is set to end her city service Jan. 6.
Giving her and some future retiring elected officials full pensions wouldn’t cost much. But it would be illegal under state law without a full actuarial study of the long-term costs, according to the mayor’s administration. It would also run afoul of a city code provision passed in 2017 that bans pension enhancements, except those granted through collective bargaining.
Eliminating the offset for all nonunion employees — a concept not yet proposed, but bandied about council this week — would eventually boost the city’s annual payout for pensions by around $7 million.
“What are the cost savings they plan to implement to pay for that?” asked Mr. Gilman. Asked about the arguments by some employees that the offset is unjust, he said, “It’s not a question of just or unjust. It goes to the ability to pay for it.”
He said the administration would conceivably consider a budget-neutral pension fix proposal, if one was presented.
The city’s top firefighters union official declined to comment on the offset issue Tuesday, but urged council to take steps to protect the pension fund.
Ralph Sicuro, president of the International Association of Fire Fighters Local 1, said the city is nine years into the 30-year arrangement under which parking revenue is pledged to the pension fund, and should “add additional years, possibly 10 years, maybe even more” to the pact.
Mr. Peduto, who was in Madrid Tuesday for a climate change conference, has been employed with the city since 1996, and so is not subject to the offset.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.