Pittsburgh City Councilwoman Deb Gross said this week that she would like the city to add a staff member to the city’s historic preservation office in upcoming budget discussions.

Ms. Gross, a preservationist who helped organize demonstrations to oppose former Mayor Tom Murphy’s Fifth and Forbes project that would have razed part of Downtown, sees adding a staffer in an office that now has two employees as a first step in addressing issues raised by the Post-Gazette’s recent series “Tearing Down History.”

The series showed how, over the past 25 years, the city has lost nearly 300 buildings from a list of nearly 1,900 structures in the city’s only street-by-street survey, the Pittsburgh Register of Historic Places. The bulk of them were taken down after the buildings were neglected, first by their owners and then by the city in many cases.

The series had “excellent timing because we’re in budget season,” Ms. Gross said.

Advertise with us

“Some of my colleagues are not concerned about historic preservation,” she said. “But I hope we can agree on some measures to help preservation and I’d hope we’d bring this up in the budget hearings.”

Mayor Bill Peduto indicated he does not plan to include a position in his upcoming city budget proposal, but the council is welcome to add one.

Read More

“The administration is always open to proposals to increase staff,” his spokesman, Tim McNulty, said in an emailed answer to questions, “but council would need to simultaneously propose a budget cut to offset the increased spending and keep the budget balanced.”

Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said adding a position is timely.

“I think that every department in the city of Pittsburgh could use more help,” she said. “But because preservation is more relevant now to a lot of people, I think people know [the historic preservation department does] need more help.”

Advertise with us

Though Ms. Gross was right that not all of her council colleagues are as supportive of historic preservation as she is, six other council members who responded to the Post-Gazette’s request for responses to the series said they saw merit in the ideas that preservationists and Mr. Peduto outlined in the Post-Gazette series to address preservation.

One of those ideas was a concept known as “core and shell” that has been proposed by multiple preservationists over years. Under the idea, the city would take money it might spend to demolish a building — currently about $39,000 per building in the city — and, instead, use it to stabilize the building by putting on a new roof and sealing windows and doors, until someone who wants to redevelop the building can be found.

Even council members like Ricky Burgess, who has long been vocal about his disdain for the way the city wields historic designation power, said an idea like core and shell might be worth exploring.

“I think it depends on the neighborhood and the house. I don’t think it’s a blanket answer,” said Mr. Burgess. “I think it could be used for certain buildings in certain neighborhoods.”

Council member Anthony Coghill, who, like Mr. Burgess, expressed concern that any historic preservation work preserve the rights of property owners, said a core and shell program could work and could “certainly be cheaper than tearing it down if it costs $30,000 now to do demolition.”

Advertise with us

Another idea in the Post-Gazette series, proposed by Mr. Peduto, to create a new ordinance that would automatically put a 90-day delay on any demolition request to tear down any building left on the register list, had all seven council members who responded saying they’d at least like to take a look at the idea.

“I’d have to hear more about that,” Councilman Corey O’Connor said.

He liked the idea that during the 90-day delay, preservation and neighborhood groups would be asked if they thought buildings could be saved, meaning it would bring “people to the table for a larger conversation about what that building means to the neighborhood.”

Ms. Gross said the idea for a demolition delay should be applied to all demolition requests in the city to give more time to review them because “we’ve been handing them out like candy.”

Mr. McNulty said in an email it is “undetermined” if a demolition delay ordinance will be ready this year.

Advertise with us

Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, said she would like to explore the idea of delay ordinance, but added: “I don’t want to adopt anything that contributes to the perception that it takes the city too long to do anything.”

But Ms. Strassburger, like most of her colleagues, said the issue of historic preservation comes up all the time, and not just at city historic review commission meetings.

The findings in the Post-Gazette series are important she said, and bolster a study the city did years ago, she said, “about how important our historic buildings are to our economy and our brand.”

“The study said the best thing Pittsburgh has going for it is its historic buildings, and if we believe that, we need to protect that asset,” she said.

Councilwoman Darlene Harris, like every council member who responded to the Post-Gazette, had specific historic buildings in her district that she worries about. For her, she said, it’s the 143-year-old former state prison in Marshall-Shadeland.

Advertise with us

“I’m concerned about the penitentiary,” she said. “What could we do with that? You can’t build condos or anything residential there because it’s next to Alcosan” and its sewage plant.

Mr. Burgess said preservation of any building, for him, will have to take a back seat to providing more affordable housing, but if there is a way to do both, he would support that.

“I’m not saying you can’t” do both, he said. “But what guides me is the whole idea of taking communities of concentrated poverty and transform them into stable mixed income communities.”

“I’m not against historic preservation, I just have a higher purpose which is affordable housing.”

Ms. Strassburger said she was heartened to hear the discussion that has ensued this week across the city over the issues raised in the Post-Gazette’s series.

Advertise with us

And even though nearly 300 of the 1,900 buildings in the register are gone, she said, “Maybe it’s not too late to save the rest, given the attention the story is drawing to this.”

“If [a historic building] is the asset we say it is,” she said, “we should do everything we can to preserve it.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill.