The City of Pittsburgh must implement, by year’s end, a standardized interview process for job candidates and provide new training to its roughly 200 hiring managers as a result of an age-discrimination allegation by a former employee.
The city hasn’t previously had any consistent interview guide for managers across city departments, according to its Department of Human Resources.
The Pittsburgh Human Relations Commission, which investigates discrimination complaints, flagged the lack of policy after Roy Cox, a former Bureau of Emergency Medical Services employee who was hired in 1977, filed a complaint in 2017.
Mr. Cox, 65, whose complaint was cross-filed with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, alleged he was passed up for the position of assistant chief, which, according to city records earned a salary of $94,432.88 in 2017.
He said by phone Monday that he believes the person who EMS promoted was “very young, [with] very little experience.”
The city “denie[d] any allegation ever made against it by Mr. Cox including violations of Age Discrimination in the Employment Act, the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act, or the City Code of Ordinances,” according to the settlement agreement, which the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette obtained this month through a request under the Right-to-Know Act.
The candidate chosen for the assistant chief job was Amera Gilchrist, who began working for the bureau in 1999 and has recently been promoted again to be the city’s new EMS deputy chief. At the time of her promotion to assistant chief, she worked at the same rank as Mr. Cox, who was making $80,998.44. The city’s Department of Public Safety does not comment on personnel or legal matters but defended Ms. Gilchrist’s promotion as “based on merit,” said spokesman Chris Togneri.
Council approved a $19,000 settlement payment to Mr. Cox in February, and as part of the agreement, he retired.
“Through our investigation and enforcement powers, we were able to determine that appropriate measures were not in place to ensure equal and fair hiring practices within the City of Pittsburgh and took corrective action to remedy this issue,” said Megan Stanley, interim director of the Pittsburgh Human Relations Commission, in an email statement.
Now, also as part of the agreement, the city has until the end of this year to roll out training on legal versus illegal interview questions and how to take comprehensive notes and documentation during interviews. The city also has to implement an interview guide “based on citywide competencies and departmental technical skills,” said Janet Manuel, director of the city’s Department of Human Resources and Civil Service.
Additionally, the city’s EMS bureau will be required to consult with the Department of Human Resources on best practices for promotions, including developing criteria for candidate selection, developing interview questions and maintaining interviewer ratings, according to the settlement.
The commission will monitor the city’s training for one year.
Ms. Manuel said that city hiring managers were previously able to structure interviews as they saw fit. The new guide will instruct them to ask both behavioral and technical questions “so that way we have that better picture, that better understanding of what the candidate can bring to the table.”
She said that comprehensive documentation of interviews will help the city to explain why some candidates weren’t chosen.
“It’s not so much that it’s hard for the city to articulate, but sometimes it’s hard for the [candidate] to understand because they have their heart set on that desired position while receiving the unfortunate news that they were not selected,” she said.
She added that the city “continues to take pride in its hiring process and being fair and equitable and believes that this training will just continue to elevate us.”
Mr. Cox said that he has a difficult time understanding why he wasn’t chosen after a long career of working up through the ranks and being a training officer for the federal Disaster Medical Assistance Team.
“It was sad because I was there for 41 years. To me, I live and breathe EMS,” he said. “I believe anybody who deserves the job and has the credentials should have it. Not that I’m having issues dealing with it, but there’s not a minute that goes by that I don’t feel bad and not content with how the outcome was.”
Ashley Murray: 412-263-1750, amurray@post-gazette.com or on Twitter at @Ashley__Murray






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.