April 4, 2009.
It’s a date that bears as much infamy as nearly any other in Pittsburgh history.
A date that reminds police officers of the dangers they face at work every day.
“It seems like yesterday,” Pittsburgh police Chief Scott Schubert said in a recent interview at bureau headquarters on the North Side. “It always seems like yesterday.”
Thursday marks 10 years since Pittsburgh police Officers Paul Sciullo, Stephen Mayhle and Eric Kelly stood and fell together. Ten years since that sunny Saturday morning morphed into one of the Steel City’s darkest days.
The fatal ambush at a home in Stanton Heights changed the psyche of policing in Pittsburgh like few other events.
Read More
“The magnitude of what occurred is something that’s always on our mind,” Chief Schubert said.
That day has been seared into Chief Schubert’s mind — and he remembers it in great detail — but it began like any other weekend morning.
Then, he was commander of the Zone 6 station in the West End. He got up and jumped in the shower, planning to go to Point Park University, where he was working on a master’s degree.
But his wife called into the bathroom, telling him officers were being shot at and needed help. He threw on some clothes and drove his unmarked police car to Fairfield Street. He was familiar with the area because he had previously worked in the Zone 5 station, which encompasses Stanton Heights.
Shortly after 7 a.m., Officers Sciullo and Mayhle responded to a 911 call at 1016 Fairfield St. The call was for a domestic dispute between then-22-year-old Richard Poplawski and his mother, Margaret. They argued after she discovered that his dog had urinated on the floor.
Mrs. Poplawski opened the door to allow the officers inside the house, where her son, unbeknownst to her, lay in wait with a shotgun. Officer Sciullo was shot first.
Officer Mayhle gave chase through the house and returned fire, but Poplawski was protected by body armor. Poplawski grabbed an AK-47 assault-style rifle and followed Officer Mayhle back outside, where he shot and killed the officer.
Officer Kelly was heading to his home in Stanton Heights after his shift ended. But he hurried to the scene when he heard that fellow officers were in trouble.
“I think that speaks volumes of his character,” Chief Schubert said. “And that’s exactly who he was.”
Officer Kelly was shot as he stepped out of his SUV.
Officer Timothy McManaway arrived a short time later and tried to help Officer Kelly. In the process of pulling Officer Kelly behind a vehicle for cover, Officer McManaway was hit on the hand by a bullet or shrapnel. They were eventually rescued by a SWAT team; Officer Kelly died later at UPMC Presbyterian.
Poplawski gave himself up after a four-hour gun battle with police in which another officer, Brian Jones, broke his leg.
The events still resonate long after the gunfight, long after Poplawski was sentenced to death, and long after the house at 1016 Fairfield St. was demolished.
“I think everybody recognized that could have been any three officers at any place,” Chief Schubert said.
Poplawski had been stockpiling weapons, and his mother told a 911 dispatcher that there were guns in the house, but because of human error that information wasn’t relayed to the officers.
Allegheny County dispatchers still ask callers whether there are weapons in a house, but their training ensures that officers get all the information before approaching a scene.
Chief Schubert said his officers now participate in ambush training, learning ways to best respond if they are attacked in a car or a house.
Training, though, only goes so far.
Police, Chief Schubert said, become a sort of family. And it’s impossible to prepare for losing a member.
Chief Schubert knew Officer Kelly from his days in Zone 5 in the 1990s.
“Always had a smile on his face, always,” the chief said. “And it brought a smile to your face. He was just always so positive.”
He didn’t know Officers Sciullo and Mayhle, both two-year veterans of the force at the time of the shooting, but he got to know them after their deaths.
After April 4, 2009, the chief said he took solace in learning more about the fallen officers through their families.
“It’s the families that got us through this,” Chief Schubert said. “Even 10 years later, they’re the ones that helped get us through this.”
Tomorrow: Family members of the fallen officers talk about the aftermath of the shootings.
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.