Sports betting and internet-based lottery games are here, casino games on your phone will likely be available within months and new mini-casino options closer to home for many Pennsylvania should be open a year from now.

Such new forms of gambling — even though many are yet to get started — are on pace to give the state a $300 million-plus cash infusion through new fees assisting its general fund. And that’s not even taking into account the prospects still ahead for playing devices similar to slot machines at certain truckstops and casino-style games on computer tablets at airports.

The extent of any greater social cost from the gambling proliferation authorized in wide-ranging October 2017 legislation remains to be seen; financially, however, it appears to be the windfall state officials hoped for when enacting it to address yet another anticipated budget shortfall. Whether it will work out as well for the casinos themselves remains to be seen.

The Wolf administration anticipates a surplus by June 30 for the current fiscal year, and spokesman J.J. Abbott said the budget counts on $203.4 million in casino-related fees tied to the gaming expansion. The current rate of collections is on pace to meet or exceed that, even though casino industry representatives at first condemned the fees and tax rates as too high for them to want to take part.

Advertise with us

“The large number of participants signing up suggest that the tax rates are appropriate,” Mr. Abbott said last week.

“The tax rates and fees were carefully considered during the process leading to enactment, and the gambling expansion has generally worked out as expected,” he said, while acknowledging that future state budgets won’t benefit from the same one-time fees being realized in 2018-19.

Pennsylvania has 12 casinos, plus one more under development in Philadelphia, and their combined slots and table games revenue — equivalent to patrons’ losses — already amounts to more than $3.2 billion annually. Some $1.3 billion of that is claimed by state and local governments as taxes. That revenue will climb in future years from the new forms being allowed, though the additional amount will be much smaller than from existing slots and table games.

All of the casinos had the option to participate in the expansion, though the state’s financial plight — rather than gaming industry lobbying — prompted the new gambling opportunities. With the region’s Meadows Racetrack & Casino and Lady Luck Casino Nemacolin being notable exceptions, most have been willing to pay for one or more of the following additions:

• Up to 10 mini-casino licenses — for facilities with up to 750 slot machines and 30 table games — were available by bid at Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board auctions. Only five were obtained, but their combined auction prices were just over $127 million. No local casino bid to have a satellite, but two will be operated in Western Pennsylvania — in Big Beaver and Hempfield — by operators from across the state. They may be ready to open by early 2020.

Advertise with us

• Ten in-state casinos and two from outside Pennsylvania claimed an internet gaming — or iGaming — license, entitling them to provide slots, table game and poker play by computer, tablet or smartphone to anyone within Pennsylvania’s boundaries. The fee was $4 million for any one of those choices or $10 million for all three. The state’s fees, still being collected, amount to $114 million. The new gaming could be available between April and June, a gaming board spokesman said, if a new Justice Department interpretation of the federal Wire Act does not interrupt those plans.

• Taking advantage of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling, the state allowed sports betting for casinos willing to pay a $10 million fee. Seven have done so, with four operating thus far, including Rivers Casino. They also will be allowed to take sports bets by computer or phone, which is likely to become available in the second quarter like the other iGaming.

The Rivers initially applied for a non-sports iGaming license, then withdrew it. Casino spokesman Jack Horner said it still “intends to add iGaming, but timing and plans for doing so are yet to be determined.”

The Rivers has the same parent firm (Rush Street Gaming) as SugarHouse Casino in Philadelphia. Since SugarHouse has already paid $10 million for the full iGaming license, it is possible the Rivers could partner with SugarHouse and encourage its regular customers to use the Philadelphia casino’s website and app instead of paying to create its own.

The Rivers sportsbook, meanwhile, has seen heavy volume but that hasn’t quelled grumbling about the state’s 36 percent tax rate on sports betting, which is higher than in most states.

Advertise with us

“While we’re pleased with the initial interest in sports betting at Rivers and the new guests it’s attracting, we are still concerned about the long-term profitability of the business, given the disproportionately high Pennsylvania tax rate on sports betting,” Mr. Horner said.

That sports betting tax, and a 54 percent tax rate on the slot machine games to be played by phone or computer, have led some analysts to question if Pennsylvania is hurting potential revenue by limiting the quality of the product casinos may feel able to offer and ultimately deterring some customers.

Pennsylvania’s license fees “are a lot of money off the top from the word go, and the tax rates are slimming [potential profit margins] across the board, said Chris Grove, an industry consultant for Eilers & Krejcik Gaming. “We’re waiting to see where the casinos recoup some of that money because they are in this to make a profit.”

Some companies that may not like the fees and taxes could be accepting them simply to keep up with competitors in the state. The participating casinos are likely also factoring in the need to do something different to attract new customers, said Peggy Holloway, a gaming analyst for Moody’s Investor Service.

“The new demand for casino gaming has been very modest in recent years, and I think operators decided pursuing these other options would enhance their ability to grow revenue,” she said. “I think the view is sports betting, online gaming, et cetera is going to provide some incremental revenue for the industry. ... Until they’re up and operating, we won’t really know.”

Advertise with us

State Rep. Jim Marshall, R-Big Beaver, the new chairman of the House Gaming Oversight Committee, said it will take time to see how the new gaming works out, but the fees have met the state’s short-term needs and the industry shouldn’t be looking for any quick tax changes.

“As long as these new new [internet] games and sports betting are successful, then I think both the commonwealth will benefit and the casinos will benefit,” Mr. Marshall said. “We do have higher tax rates for gaming and casinos than other states, but we have a lot of revenue that comes in because of that. ... We may have to scale back at some point, but I wouldn’t see anything happening in the very near future.”

While fees and taxes factor into casinos’ decision-making about the expansion, the Meadows and Lady Luck have had additional issues limiting the changes in southwestern Pennsylvania.

The Meadows spent most of 2018 awaiting completion of its purchase by a new owner, Penn National Gaming, which also owns Hollywood Casino near Harrisburg.

Tony Frabbiele, the new general manager at the Meadows, said any decision to enter into sports betting there will eventually depend on performance of the sportsbook that opened in November at Hollywood Casino. Meanwhile, rather than spending millions on its own internet gaming license, Mr. Frabbiele said the Meadows will market to its customers the iGaming site of affiliated Hollywood Casino once that becomes available.

Advertise with us

Lady Luck is the smallest casino in the state, classified with Valley Forge Casino Resort as one of two “resort” casinos. Its size might be a disincentive to invest $10 million in either sports betting or iGaming, but it could elect two other options from the gambling law that Valley Forge has already pursued. It could pay the state $1 million to drop a restriction that the casino can be patronized only by those also using the resort for other purposes, and it could pay $2.5 million to raise the cap on its number of slot machines.

Lady Luck is in the process of coming under new management by Churchill Downs Inc., which recently acquired Presque Isle Downs & Casino near Erie. A Churchill Downs spokesman said there would be no comment on the possibility of any changes at Lady Luck until it takes over later this year.

Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.