Two people dressed as bananas huddled together in a crowd of roughly 200 people on the Mon Wharf when Carlos Schrader, wearing a Pittsburgh police bomb squad T-shirt, reached into his truck to pull out a bullhorn.

“Listen up!” he said in a booming voice. “The water speed is 1.7 miles an hour. That’s very fast for water. We don’t want River Rescue to have to work, so bunch up and help each other in and out of the water.”

Asked why the bomb squad was on hand for the 2019 Polar Bear Plunge, he said, “I’m gonna jump! This will be my 33rd year.”

The annual New Year’s Day tradition that compels some people to leap into cold rivers all over the world goes back to the 1920s in Pittsburgh, when the Polar Bear Club formed, said Frank Nelson, president of the local club, who has made the plunge 54 times. As coach of the Franklin Regional High School diving team, he inspired several members of the team to jump in with him.

Advertise with us

Last year’s air temperature was around 12 degrees for the plunge, but Tuesday’s, at 9:30 a.m., was in the mid-40s as roughly 50 people leapt or lowered themselves into the 38-degree water of the Monongahela River. Family and friends held their cell phones, bathrobes and other dry clothes.

Some people wore swimsuits, some wore jeans and sweatshirts. Some stripped down to skivvies. Leah Micklo, of McKeesport, wore an elf costume.

She was compelled to take the plunge because of a recent life-threatening illness that made her feel more emboldened.

“It’s exhilarating,” she said, minutes before hitting the water. “It’s a good way to get high without drugs.”

Asked how she knows that, this being her first time doing the plunge, she said, “because I’m on a high now!”

Advertise with us

There were, among others in costume, a Santa Claus, Superman and Elvis Presley. In their regular clothes, the participants included a retired teacher, a plumber, an actor, a school bus driver, a home health worker and a shelf stocker at a grocery store.

Kim Eaton of Pleasant Hills, an Allegheny County Common Pleas judge, stood with her small mixed-breed dog, Charlie, and said, “My husband is Elvis.” She nodded toward a man who was sort of dancing toward her in an Elvis costume. “This will be his fourth year as Elvis.

“Last year, when it was 2 degrees, I told him, ‘OK, now you’re pushing stupid,’” she said. “But he did it. It makes him happy. He and Santa Claus became friends.”

“In the end, it’s for a good cause,” said Elvis, aka David Etzi, a consumer protection agent for the state Attorney General’s office. “It’s something to do that’s kind of fun. I didn’t think I’d do it again, but after you do it the first time, it gets contagious.”

William Kofalt of Coraopolis wore a full-body polar bear suit he has worn for four plunges.

Advertise with us

“It makes it a little more difficult” to get out of the water, he said, “but I wanted to be a polar bear.”

Scott Walton of Blairsville has worn his Superman costume, complete with red cape, for seven plunges.

“It’s one of those things you do to have a great memory,” he said. “It’s something you can say you did. It’s not crazy. It’s about enjoying life, living, having fun.”

“We don’t use the C word,” said Mike Sauter of Pleasant Hills. “Well, I’m moderately crazy. I skipped last year when they had to break the ice with a hatchet. My wife said, ‘Your health insurance won’t cover this.’ ”

Some people who jump in the Mon also seek other daring experiences. Mr. Sauter also skydives, as does Keith Miller of Plum, who took the plunge for the first time this year.

Advertise with us

“I’m getting older [near retirement age] and decided to do more things,” Mr. Miller said. “I think there is a mental health benefit. It makes you feel you can do things that other people don’t. Not that you’re better. It’s just a challenge, and adrenaline is part of it.”

Too few people take risks, several participants agreed, and the Polar Bear Plunge is a relatively safe risk that requires a little bravery, and it’s full of camaraderie. Many people return each year, dressed in their recognizable outfits. They hug, fist bump, say “hey, hey, hey!” or “brother bear!” and laugh as if at a great joke.

“I need to do everything [riskwise] before my wife retires because she’ll just want to go to Europe and other blase things,” Mr. Sauter said.

The event raises money for Project Bundle-Up with every “Polar Bear Plunge” T-shirt purchased. Project Bundle-Up is a local organization that provides new coats and mittens to children in need.

Gaven McCuean was one of the youngest participants. He is 13, from North Huntingdon. He has jumped in for the past five years with a family friend, Don Rozman, whose 11-year-old son, Kyle, was killed in 2014 in a car accident.

Advertise with us

“This was the big event we did together, and he loved it so much that I continue to do it for him,” said Mr. Rozman, of New Castle.

“I love the cold,” said Gaven. “I’m shivering, but it was a goal.”

If you arrived as a spectator thinking anybody who jumps in the Mon in January has to be crazy, you might have left thinking the world could use more light-hearted, fun-seeking people.

Mr. Walton, aka Superman, said, “Too many people don’t do things like this. There’s this sense of togetherness, with people helping you out” of the water. “It brings people together.”

Don Santoriello, a retired city firefighter, was volunteering with the Salvation Army, which had a warming tent and a truck dispensing hot chocolate. Asked if he considered taking the plunge he said, “My mamma didn’t raise no fool. I had to do that in the Marines, and I’m not doing it again.” Then he smiled. “But it’s a fun thing. God makes all kinds of people.”

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.