She's an unabashed critic of the status quo in city government and the only Pittsburgh City Council member who has a mini-resistance movement dedicated to unseating her.

She's Darlene Harris, the longtime North Side political force whose leadership style — confrontational and unwavering — has made her one of the most polarizing figures in town.

And if it's up to her critics, her 12-year reign there will come to an end in 2019.

For now, Mrs. Harris' electoral defeat is only a dream for her resistance, which makes itself known on Facebook and has been vocal, for years, against the District 1 councilwoman. This time around, they're hoping for one candidate who can coalesce support in the North Side — but not two, or three, who would only divide Mrs. Harris’ opposition.

Advertise with us

For now, their hope is in Chris Rosselot, a former aide to U.S. Sen. Bob Casey in Pittsburgh who announced his candidacy last week. The 38-year-old Spring Garden resident used to support Mrs. Harris — who he said showed a “streak of independence” years ago that was attractive to North Siders — but now criticizes her for being unwilling to cooperate with Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration. The departure of Mrs. Harris — who is often at odds with the mayor and council President Bruce Kraus — would leave behind a council much more friendly to the administration.

But Mrs. Harris has built up an army of backers in the district over the years, enough to carry her thrice to re-election after first sweeping into council by special election in 2006. Those supporters, many of whom flood her social media accounts with everything from holiday wishes to random hellos, express appreciation for her dogged approach to governing — a get-things-done attitude that doesn't always make friends, they say, but sticks up for residents.

"If you need something fixed, if you you need something worked on, she's very good at that. She rolls up her sleeves and helps you," said Barbara Burns, a former city council member who held the District 1 seat in the late 1990s.

But to her detractors in the district, Mrs. Harris is an agitator whose shaky relationship with the administration -- she ran unsuccessfully against Mr. Peduto in 2017 -- has negatively impacted residents.

"I respect her tenacity, but I feel that she has been more focused on adversarial tactics than on making progress for the North Side," said Helen Ewing, a Brighton Heights resident who has lived in the district for about six years and has followed the councilwoman's voting record closely. Having spoken to her at many community meetings, Ms. Ewing, a 29-year-old communications coordinator at Carnegie Mellon University, said she's come away with the feeling that Mrs. Harris "only represents a narrow contingency of Northsiders."

Advertise with us

Mrs. Harris, who has confirmed she's running for re-election, has maintained that her 45 years of involvement in North Side communities distinguish her from her usual primary challengers. She could not be reached for this story.

Her district, which snakes from Allegheny Center through Spring Hill and up to Observatory Hill and Brighton Heights, has never elected a Republican, pinning the Democratic primary in May as the anti-Darlene resistance's bulls-eye this cycle — their last shot for at least another four years until council's odd numbered districts are up again.

The only way she'll lose this time, once and for all, her critics say, is if Democrats can coalesce around one formidable candidate. If too many candidates jump in the mix, they run the risk of splitting the vote like they did in 2011, when Mrs. Harris emerged from a four-person primary field to win by a few percentage points.

"What's been happening over the years is, you get two or three or four people to run and the vote is split three ways," said Jeff Heil, a 45-year-old Observatory Hill resident who has lived on the North Side for 20 years, "and Darlene keeps squeaking by because the other two-thirds of the folks are supporting the other two candidates. She's winning by slim margins."

Technically, Ms. Harris' foes haven't, in combination, cleared the two-thirds mark. But neither has she, in her last two reelection bids, gotten more than half of the votes in three- and four-candidate fields.

Advertise with us

Mr. Heil, who leads the online resistance to Mrs. Harris through a locally-popular Facebook page, has taken the stance over the years — sometimes in public spats with the councilwoman -- that Ms. Harris only takes care of her neighborhood, Spring Hill.

Mr. Rosselot said he isn't running "anti-Darlene," but can "offer better solutions" for the district. He said Mrs. Harris' "lack of collaboration" has kept resources away.

"The last couple years sort of was a tipping point in the sense that Darlene's inaction — whether it's an unwillingness or inability to work with others — has, in my viewpoint and of the folks that I've talked to, harmed the district," Mr. Rosselot said.

In his six years in Mr. Casey's office, Mr. Rosselot said he handled regional issues on the senator's behalf, where he "got to know a lot of the stakeholders" in the city. Since then, he's worked on the neighborhood level for the Community Alliance of Spring Garden and East Deutschtown.

Having moved to the North Side in 2003, Mr. Rosselot said he's noticed that while real estate development and investment have been good for neighborhoods, some have been left behind — and even those areas that are seeing development are not including residents in those discussions and sometimes pricing out young professionals.

Advertise with us

"When I'm talking to a young professional who moved away to another city five years ago from Pittsburgh and comes back and can't move into the same neighborhood that they once lived in, that's sort of concerning to me," Mr. Rosselot said.

But for Mrs. Harris' fans, her leadership has gotten results for the district. Janice Stauffer, a nurse at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh who has lived on the North Side most of her life, said she will support the councilwoman for re-election because "she cares about the district and its people, and she makes an effort to use her position to get things done that 'the little guy' can’t when dealing with local government."

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.