The gunfire had just stopped. The 11 dead had yet to be named.
Stationed near Tree of Life synagogue, Dan Gilman turned to Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald with a somber prediction:
We’re going to know all the casualties.
“This wasn’t a [shooting] at a random site, where you would have no idea who was in there. You knew it was going to be predominantly Squirrel Hill Jewish community members,” said Mr. Gilman, the mayoral chief of staff, who knew four victims in the Oct. 27 massacre.
The mass shooting has devastated city hall in intimate terms, leaving some Pittsburgh officials to mourn profound personal loss as they navigate their public duties.
In Mr. Gilman’s case, his mother-in-law is grieving two brothers: Cecil Rosenthal, 59, and David Rosenthal, 54.
Lynette Lederman, a former Tree of Life president and an executive assistant to Councilman Corey O’Connor, lost eight friends.
Mr. O’Connor and Mr. Peduto each knew five of the dead.
Paul Leger, the board chairman at the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, confirmed his brother Daniel Leger, 70, is among the wounded survivors.
That doesn’t begin to count many more city workers — past and present — who lost friends, escaped bullets or hold membership in the three congregations that came under fire.
“As bad as this is for the Jewish community, it’s affected our entire community,” Mrs. Lederman said Monday.
Her return to city hall last week brought warm hugs, heartfelt sympathies and condolences “in the midst of the most unimaginable darkness,” she said.
“Nobody is going to intimidate us. No anti-Semite is going to intimidate us,” Mrs. Lederman said of the Jewish community.
In a brief interview, Mr. Peduto said shooting victims and their families have taken priority for the city. He shoved off his day-to-day work last week, opening his schedule to visit hospital rooms, funeral services and residents in grief.
“I have been able to find an inner peace, and it has been reassuring,” the mayor said. “I’ve also realized that my role in this is to be there for others who are grieving.”
At the same time, Mr. Peduto said, he’s struggled the last several days with being alone. “So being with the community and being with the families has been cathartic to my own well-being.”
His office announced Monday a public assembly for noon Friday in Point State Park, Downtown. Residents throughout the Pittsburgh region are invited to honor those killed at the synagogue and to call for peace, the Peduto administration said.
Those who can’t attend could hold their own moments of silence at the same time, his office added.
Meanwhile, Mr. O’Connor said he’s found solace in staying busy, talking to his constituents and keeping up with local events.
“And then some nights when you do get home, having my wife there just to talk, my mom walking up the street with her — that little day-to-day stuff that you’re used to, in times like this, makes it a whole lot easier,” said the councilman, who represents part of Squirrel Hill. “It’s been real tough for everybody. You just keep going, and it makes a big difference.”
Colleagues have praised Mr. O’Connor’s resolve and focus since the shooting. At a council meeting last week, Councilman Anthony Coghill said Mr. O’Connor took initiative after the violence to walk the streets and talk with people the same day.
“It was very indicative of you and your father, I've got to tell you,” Mr. Coghill told Mr. O’Connor, referring to late Mayor Bob O’Connor.
Council also recognized Erika Strassburger, who joined the body in April. Her East End district includes Tree of Life. She knew the Rosenthal brothers as acquaintances and other victims in passing, Ms. Strassburger said.
“There wasn’t much that couldn’t be put on hold to focus solely on whatever needed to be taken care of, whether it was being present at the memorial site, being present at memorial services, being there for family members or attending vigils and community events,” she said.
Typical business began to resume Monday for her council office, with more routine calls and inquiries coming in.
“It doesn’t feel normal. It’s a new normal,” Ms. Strassburger said. “But today is the first day we’ve been able to get back to some kind of normalcy.”
Elsewhere in city hall, associate solicitor Wendy Kobee said she’s felt compassion and “fundamental human decency” as the administration reaches out to affected families. She sits on the board at Dor Hadash, a congregation at Tree of Life.
“In terms of reaction from city hall, it’s actually made me feel safe, that it’s OK that I live here,” Ms. Kobee said. “Actually more than OK that I live here.”
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.