Exiting the large brick and stained glass facade on Greenfield Avenue after Mass on Sunday, St. Rosalia parishioners expressed sadness and disbelief over their priest’s absence.

The Rev. Joseph Reschick, 67, had been placed on administrative leave following an allegation of sexual abuse of a minor in the mid-1980s, according to a statement Pittsburgh Bishop David Zubik released Saturday evening.

“I don’t believe it. Father Joe’s not like that,” said Kathleen Riddell, 69, of Greenfield, a St. Rosalia parishioner since her senior year in high school. “Father Joe has never been nothing but honest with me. I had a lot of problems, and he helped me.”

Father Reschick “vehemently denied” the allegation, a diocese spokesman, the Rev. Nicholas Vaskov, told parishioners. Father Vaskov delivered Mass at the Greenfield church Sunday.

Advertise with us

According to Bishop Zubik’s statement, the allegation had been reported to law enforcement and was being investigated.

It followed a Pennsylvania grand jury report released in August that named 99 suspected abusive priests from the Diocese of Pittsburgh. Father Reschick was not among the named.

Robert Robinson-Dassel, 71, who joined St. Rosalia 10 months ago, said he felt like he had been “punched in the stomach.”

“Being a person returning to the Catholic faith, Father Joe was sort of leading me back into it,” he said. “I have nothing but the utmost respect for him for that.”

“Innocent until proven guilty, but yet he can’t have Mass, he can’t do the Eucharist,” said Dan Primm, 68, a parishioner of 44 years. “When and if he’s found innocent of this, how does he get his reputation back?”

Advertise with us

According to the Diocese of Pittsburgh, clergy on administrative leave “may not engage in public ministry, dress as priests or otherwise present themselves as priests in good standing,” in accordance with the church’s policies in place to protect children.

Father Vaskov, of St. Mary of Mercy in Downtown Pittsburgh, called the time a “challenging week,” both because of the allegation against Father Reschick and Monday’s start of parish consolidation.

He read aloud the letter Bishop Zubik sent to all the parishes at which Father Reschick served.

The investigation “does not imply guilt,” the letter read. “It is intended to safeguard the course of justice while preserving the rights of everyone involved, including both the person who made the allegation and the person against whom an allegation has been made.”

The diocese did not make it clear when Fater Reschick, who was ordained in 1977, began serving St. Rosalia parish.

Advertise with us

Father Vaskov declined to comment further following the Mass. Father Reschick could not be reached.

Ashley Murray: 412-263-1750, amurray@post-gazette.com, or on Twitter at @Ashley__Murray