Construction unions expect hundreds of new jobs if Peoples Natural Gas forges a joint venture with Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority and other water systems.

Improvements including a new treatment plant and pipelines could soar into the billions of dollars, according to the Pittsburgh Regional Building and Construction Trades Council. The 17-union coalition is urging the city to accept an unsolicited proposal from the gas company.

But PWSA already relies heavily on union labor and plans to bring in more, with some $1.2 billion in system work anticipated in the next five years alone, executive director Robert Weimar said this week. Labor accounts for up to half of such expenses, although he wasn’t immediately certain how many jobs would arise from the projects.

“For the union to think they’re going to get a different perspective by working through a proposal from Peoples Gas — that’s just not the case,” Mr. Weimar said. Union workers “have the same opportunities with the contractors we have, which [would], in fact, be the same contractors that are hired by Peoples gas.”

Advertise with us

The trades council did not comment late this week. Mr. Weimar said he didn’t know of any discussions between the labor group and PWSA before the council endorsed the Peoples proposal.

He said PWSA doesn’t have enough detail to evaluate the the pitch from North Shore-based gas utility, which argues it would save time and money by replacing gas and water lines in tandem. Specifically, Peoples wants what it terms a partnership to rebuild and supply the city-owned PWSA system. The arrangement would have a board made up of public representatives and officials from Peoples Water, a Peoples subsidiary, according to the company.

The entity would own new water pipelines put in the ground, with the entire distribution system eventually belonging to the partnership. A $350 million drinking water plant would take shape in O’Hara and could supply both the PWSA service area and neighboring communities, Peoples has said.

“We can build a brand new water treatment facility together, powered by 100 percent renewable energy, instead of investing public money in an old, outdated PWSA water treatment facility well beyond its useful life,” Peoples CEO Morgan O’Brien said in a statement. The trades council believes Peoples has the only plan “that will create a water system that we all can be proud of,” according to a labor letter to city leaders.

Still, Mr. Weimar said Peoples can’t assess PWSA’s own self-improvement blueprint — nor offer a complete comparison. That’s because the authority has yet to finalize a compliance plan that’s due before the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission in September for regulatory review and approval, he said.

Advertise with us

The plan will detail a comprehensive program to tackle the leak-prone PWSA system and operations, including shortfalls cited by state House Speaker Mike Turzai, R-Bradford Woods, Mr. Weimar said. A longtime advocate for privatizing PWSA, Mr. Turzai tangled with Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto through press releases over the past few days. The speaker highlighted water leaks, unbilled accounts and unmetered use at city facilities, among other issues.

“PWSA continues to be grossly mismanaged, as it has been for decades, which forced the Legislature to take action placing the PWSA under PUC oversight,” Mr. Turzai said in an opening salvo. “Mayor Peduto and city council need to take the calls of the private sector and organized labor to help provide safe drinking water to the people of Pittsburgh seriously.”

Mr. Peduto later cast the comments as “bizarre,” saying PWSA is making strides to lessen lead contamination, increase capital budgets and craft a long-term action plan. A pending city proposal would overhaul board governance at the authority.

Mr. Turzai “has a philosophical belief that private industry can do things better than government. I disagree with him on that,” Mr. Peduto said Friday. “He has one motive that he wants to see, which is privatize this system.”

At the same time, PWSA can’t go unchanged, the mayor said. The status quo would guarantee “continued failure,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto asked the authority to finish a 12-year plan by late September. Then the city can ask outside parties: “Can you do it better?” he said.

“We’ll look at proposals from partnerships that could be created that [could] then save ratepayers money, secure the water and provide a better water treatment,” he said. The city won’t outright sell the water system or privatize operations, he added, arguing that would give up a city asset.

No matter what, Mr. Weimar said PWSA plans to solicit the private sector for help with long-term improvements. Paul Leger, the PWSA board chairman, said he prefers to engage union workers in that process.

“Nothing is grinding to a halt [at PWSA] based on anybody’s public or private proposal,” said Mr. Leger, who forecast a “hot and heavy battle” over the utility. A number of other companies, such as Pennsylvania American Water Co., have expressed interest in PWSA.

“This ain’t done yet,” Mr. Leger said.

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.