Cleaning-service workers arrived at Nova Place on the North Side Monday and found out that they no longer had jobs after their contract expired.
New York developer Faros Properties, which owns the Allegheny Center site, signed a contract recently with Carnegie-based Checklist Cleaning Services — its workers represented by the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades District Council #57 of Western Pennsylvania.
Faros was previously contracted with the Huber Group — its employees represented by the Service Employees International Union 32BJ. The SEIU protested the deal over the weekend on Children’s Way on the North Side in support of building cleaners.
Charese Carter, a cleaning-service worker at Nova, said they were surprised Friday when she and her colleagues were told they would likely be losing their jobs.
A new contract with out-of-state Nova Place developer may put local union workers out of a job
“They slid this one right under us. The only thing we were told is that we were going under new management,” she said. “So we kept coming to work, doing our duties. The next thing we find out is that they’ve gone with a union that pays way less.
“We work our behinds off. We work hard for the money that we make,” Ms. Carter said. “We just want to keep our jobs.”
A Faros Properties spokesperson said that the bid went out seven months ago, and the developer “has entered into an agreement with the Carnegie-based Checklist Facility Maintenance, a Pittsburgh-based, minority-owned business,” said Gretchen D’Atri, marketing director for Faros.
She said the Huber Group was given more than 30 days of notice in writing that its contract had been terminated.
“How the Huber Group notifies their employees is up to them, and it’s shocking and unfortunate that they didn’t inform their employees until Friday,” she said.
In a follow-up email on Monday, Ben Huber, president of Huber Group, said the company notified employees two weeks ago. “Our employees had at least two weeks notice that a new contractor would be taking over. In addition, we complied with our obligations under our contract with the SEIU.”
The company had not told workers sooner because it was “reluctant to notify our employees without knowing the identity of the new contractor because we could not answer questions we anticipated would be raised by our employees concerning their employment status,” Mr. Huber said. “We wanted to ensure a smooth transition so as not to impact the quality of our service to Nova Place.”
He said employees have been cleaning Nova Place since August 2016 and were paid $15.25 an hour.
As to why Faros switched contractors, Ms. D’Atri said it “came down to quality-control issues that were not improving.” Faros based the new contract on “a variety of factors, one of those requirements was that the new contractor had to use union labor.”
Sam Williamson, Western Pennsylvania-area leader for SEIU 32BJ, said the union hadn’t learned until Friday that ”the contractor who is coming in so far has refused to allow the existing workers to apply for their jobs,” he said.
Cori Bingham, Checklist’s founder, refutes that claim and said he was in the Nova Place concourse for more than eight hours a day last Tuesday through Friday, interviewing potential candidates for several full-time positions, but less than the 10 to 12 part-time jobs Huber offered.
Since Mr. Bingham was working with IUPAT, he said he couldn’t put up signs letting people know he was interviewing “because it would be viewed as poaching” workers from SEIU.
But Mr. Bingham claims that employees on the property were likely aware that he was interviewing as early as Tuesday.
“I was apparently known as the scary guy with the backpack,” said Mr. Bingham, in part because Checklist is known by some as a company that in its 11-year history hasn’t traditionally hired union workers. But Nova Place is more than 99,000 square feet, and “we’re working with union workers,” he said.
Located in the former Allegheny Center Mall space, Nova Place has 1.5 million square feet of office space that includes tenants such as Confluence, PNC, Bank of America and co-working space Alloy 26. Its amenities include a gym, a garage and Federal Galley, a food hall from the Galley Group.
Faros, a rising-star developer, bought Allegheny Center in 2015. Faros’ properties include office complexes in Boston and Westchester County, N.Y., and historic properties in Nantucket, Mass.
As far as salary differences between Huber and Checklist, Mr. Bingham did not say what the hourly wage range is for cleaning services at Nova Place. “Like any union, we have a minimum,” he said. “But I never do anything on the scale of minimum.”
Mr. Bingham says his company offers benefits including public transportation reimbursement, a company Uber account for employees to use, and at Nova Place, they are providing parking leases and gym memberships.
An SEIU spokesperson has not yet responded to Mr. Bingham’s claim that SEIU knew before Friday that Faros Properties didn’t sign with them.
This is at least the second time within a year that cleaning service workers in the area represented by SEIU have faced the loss of their jobs.
In August, the SEIU filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board, claiming that The Ellis School in Shadyside refused to rehire Alder Services custodial workers because of their union membership. The complaint also accused the new contractor, Homestead-based General Cleaning, with “recognizing another union and entering into a collective bargaining agreement with such union to cover the cleaners without any demonstration of majority support by the cleaners for the union.”
Representatives from The Ellis School said poor cleaning, physical fights between employees and a situation that left one student “uncomfortable” were among reasons the school did not renew the contract for its former cleaning services company.
On Monday morning, a former Nova Place Huber employee visited the Checklist office in Carnegie and has been hired for full-time work. With all other positions filled, she is the only worker of the former Huber group who will be working there.
‘We have more jobs available,” Mr. Bingham said. “We’re always looking for more qualified men and women.”
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.