Mayor Bill Peduto sought her to bring ethics into the city Law Department. Four years on, Pittsburgh solicitor Lourdes Sanchez Ridge has stepped down to rejoin the private sector, signing on with the Downtown law firm Pietragallo, Gordon, Alfano, Bosick & Raspanti.

But before she vacated her City-County Building office last month, the former federal prosecutor offered parting advice to city council: Trust the lawyers.

In particular, Ms. Sanchez Ridge said council should require that all proposed ordinances gain approval from the Law Department. That way, the city can better prevent expensive lawsuits against questionable municipal rules, she said.

“I have suggested that many times,” Ms. Sanchez Ridge, 56, of Shadyside told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette before she left office last month. “It hasn’t gone anywhere.”

Advertise with us

Council members often consult city lawyers before proposing ordinances, but even “once-in-a-while [exceptions] can get us into lawsuits,” she said. As of last week, seven cases involving challenges to city ordinances were under active litigation, according to Yvonne Hilton, the acting city solicitor.

Some of the matters are consolidated, so fewer than seven ordinances overall are being litigated, Ms. Hilton said. Issues of attorney-client privilege prevent her from disclosing just how much legislation goes to city lawyers for review, she said.

Council President Bruce Kraus said he wasn’t immediately certain what portion of legislation undergoes the screenings. He has worked with the Law Department “to achieve sound legislation” and will keep doing so — “but voluntarily,” he said.

“While I would always encourage legislators to work actively with legal counsel when crafting legislation, I would certainly caution against any form of a mandate in which anyone is required to do that,” Mr. Kraus said. He didn’t delve into rationale.

Council’s newest member, Erika Strassburger, called it good practice for members “to engage the Law Department as early as possible” on ordinance proposals. Yet approval from city lawyers shouldn’t be compulsory, she said.

Advertise with us

“I’m concerned that this sort of mandate would vastly slow down the legislative process” and discourage council “from pushing the boundaries with important bills they believe could pass legal muster but might face a lawsuit,” she said via email.

It wasn’t clear how many cities have codified legal standards for screening legislation, nor in how many variations. Seattle council rules, for instance, order that legislative provisions undergo a review but not necessarily endorsement by the law department there.

“I think it’s common to have [a proposal] reviewed when a review is deemed appropriate, necessary or desirable,” said Rick Schuettler, executive director at the Pennsylvania Municipal League.

Mr. Peduto said he wasn’t certain the city has enough lawyers on staff to review all legislation before introduction. He estimated about a dozen attorneys are on the payroll.

“It becomes an issue of capacity with the attorneys and the workload that they have now,” Mr. Peduto said.

Advertise with us

He praised Ms. Sanchez Ridge for building an Ethics Hearing Board he dubbed open and transparent. The watchdog panel helps uphold the city ethics code, which sets conduct standards for city workers.

The city, meanwhile, is exploring a headhunter to expand the search nationally for a new solicitor, Mr. Peduto said. He began his second term in January. Ms. Sanchez Ridge said she long intended her role as a “one-term type of job.”

She sees a growing trust in city government, illustrated in part by a decline in total lawsuits brought against the city, where the Law Department has been training key personnel in employment law, she said.

“The city deserves somebody who’s always fresh and coming up with new ideas,” Ms. Sanchez Ridge said. “Sometimes when you’re in a job too long, you become stale, and you become a bureaucrat. The city doesn’t deserve that.”

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.