The Pennsylvania Health Department has reduced by more than $200,000 an unusually hefty fine it imposed on the Charles Morris Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Squirrel Hill for a patient’s accidental death by strangulation in bed rails.
The nursing home had appealed the original $235,000 fine the state imposed in December for circumstances surrounding the death of prominent Pittsburgh businessman and philanthropist Robert Frankel. A settlement agreement dated March 28 and provided by the department Friday indicated the fine had been reduced to $15,250.
“Through the appeal process, the penalty was reduced to focus on the most egregious deficiency (or deficiencies) identified,” department spokeswoman April Hutcheson said in an email when asked for explanation of the reduction.
The original fine, one of the largest penalties in the state agency’s history of nursing home regulation, followed an investigation of the Sept. 17 death of Mr. Frankel, 89, the father of state legislator Dan Frankel of Squirrel Hill.
Mr. Frankel, who had both mental and physical impairments, died from asphyxiation in the middle of the night when his neck was trapped in a bed rail. Due to the risk of such entrapment, federal guidelines call for such railings to be used as a last resort in long-term care facilities, following careful assessment of the patient’s condition and a doctor’s authorization of their necessity.
The state’s report said Mr. Frankel had not been properly re-evaluated for appropriate use of bed rails, or side rails, as his physical condition changed. In the aftermath of his death, the Charles Morris center, operated by the Jewish Association on Aging, announced it was discontinuing use of bed rails entirely.
Read More
The settlement agreement between the facility and the state does not provide details describing the decision to reduce the fine. It states the two parties “have constructively resolved the issues, Order, and challenges to the Order ... in a way that reflects their views and both parties’ interests in the well-being of the Facility’s residents.” The agreement noted that a provisional license that had been imposed on the facility was also lifted effective Feb. 26.
Debbie Winn-Horvitz, CEO of the Jewish Association on Aging, said Friday that the original fine was “certainly surprising. For a nonprofit, that would have been difficult. ... Based on a thorough explanation of the facts, we’re now pleased we’ve come to an agreement with a reasonable outcome.”
In the past, state penalties for nursing home problems have rarely exceeded $100,000, and in most instances they are below $10,000. The state auditor general’s office and other critics of the department’s enforcement in recent years have called for the fines to be increased as a means of discouraging substandard care at the facilities.
Although Ms. Hutcheson declined to address whether the department erred in imposing a high penalty that it subsequently agreed to reduce by some $220,000, she said the state remains committed to using the process to make sure facilities correct problems.
“The goal in all of this is to make sure the deficiencies are corrected and that the conditions are safe for residents,” she said. “Sometimes financial incentives help in that.”
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.