A former city of Pittsburgh payroll clerk who sued the city after she was placed on leave during a federal investigation of a former police chief has lost her case in which she claimed she was forced into retirement because she's black.

U.S. District Judge David Cercone on Friday granted summary judgment for the city in its legal battle with Kim Montgomery, a former clerk in the city police bureau’s personnel and finance office.

Ms. Montgomery, who retired in 2014, was placed on administrative leave in February 2013 by then-acting police Chief Regina McDonald and Mike Huss, then the public safety director.

In her 2016 suit, she said she wasn’t given a reason at the time but was later told by a city lawyer that she was under federal investigation as part of the FBI's case against former Chief Nate Harper.

Advertise with us

Other employees had also been suspended or fired at the time because they were being investigated.

Ms. Montgomery claimed the reason given for her suspension was a pretext because she was not a target of the investigation, and she compared herself to a white employee in the same situation who was not put on leave.

A magistrate judge, Robert Mitchell, in October had recommended that summary judgment be granted for the city in part because Ms. Montgomery could not support her claims that she was “continually” implicated in the criminal investigation.

She said she was subjected to a “hostile work environment” because of media reports that named her, but Judge Mitchell said the city was not responsible for those reports or for the investigation, which the FBI conducted.

The judge also said Ms. Montgomery’s complaint and her later claims didn't match. She initially said her discharge on Jan. 24, 2014, was the “adverse employment action” for which she was suing. But she later said the adverse action was being placed on leave on Feb. 21, 2013.

Advertise with us

The city said her initial discrimination claim, filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission on Nov. 14, 2014, was untimely because it wasn’t filed within 300 days of her being placed on leave, as required by law. Judge Mitchell agreed.

Judge Cercone adopted Judge Mitchell’s opinion and ruled in favor of the city.

Ms. Montgomery’s lawyer did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.