A mistake by city officials allowed a contractor to demolish the one-story addition to a brick home in Homewood where three people died in December despite instructions from prosecutors that the entire house be preserved for further investigation.
The Dec. 20 fire at 7634 Bennett St. killed Sandra Carter Douglas, 58; Chy’enne Manning, 4; and her mother, Shamira Staten, 21.
Pittsburgh police charged Martell Smith, 41, with three counts of criminal homicide and related charges. They are seeking the death penalty if he is convicted of first-degree murder.
Because of the seriousness of the case, prosecutors wanted to ensure that the crime scene was preserved long enough to allow Mr. Smith’s attorney — and any potential investigator — to review it. Detectives believe the fire started in the front living room of the main portion of the house, which remains intact — even after the demolition work that was halted.
On Jan. 16, Allegheny County’s first assistant district attorney, Rebecca Spangler, sent an email to Pittsburgh city solicitor Lourdes Sanchez Ridge requesting that the property be kept intact until a court order is issued saying it could be razed.
The Pittsburgh law department relayed that information to the city’s Department of Permits, Licensing and Inspection, and a hold was supposed to be put in place, preventing any permits from issuing for demolition.
Read More
But on Feb. 9, a private contractor hired by the homeowner obtained a permit from the city and began work the next day. The homeowner contacted Pittsburgh Detective Martin Kail on Feb. 12 and told him that demolition had started.
The detective alerted city officials, and a stop work order was issued, but not before the addition had been torn down.
On Friday, city spokesman Timothy McNulty acknowledged it was a mistake.
“According to PLI, the parcel should have been locked down so that no actions could have been taken on it. Typically that means putting a freeze on the parcel in their database,” he said. “That was not done due to human error.”
Richard Narvin, the attorney representing Mr. Smith, said he does not believe there was any malicious intent on the part of the city workers who issued the permit.
“I think there just happened to be a bureaucratic mix-up in the building inspection department,” Mr. Navin said. “These things do happen.”
Mr. McNulty agreed.
“PLI has audit procedures in place that are supposed to block errors such as this and indeed follow those procedures correctly hundreds of times per year on other demolitions,” he said.
Pittsburgh police detectives said Mr. Smith set the fire in retaliation for a fight outside a Penn Hills club earlier that night with Ms. Carter Douglas’ son, Ricco Carter.
Investigators said Mr. Smith stopped at a gasoline station in Point Breeze about 2:10 a.m., bought a gas can, filled it up and drove to the Homewood house. They said he then doused the three-story house in gasoline and set it on fire.
After learning about the demolition work, Assistant District Attorney Brian Catanzarite filed a motion in Common Pleas Court asking that the property be secured and preserved in its present condition until a judge issues an order releasing the scene.
Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski granted the motion on Thursday.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.