The Allegheny County District Attorney's office will seek the death penalty against a man accused of setting a fire in Homewood that killed two women and a 4-year-old girl.

Martell Smith, 41, is charged with killing Sandra Carter Douglas, 58, Chy'enne Manning, 4, and her mother, Shamira Staten, 21, in the blaze at 7634 Bennett Street on Dec. 20.

Pittsburgh police said Smith set the fire in retaliation for a fistfight outside a Penn Hills club earlier that night.

To pursue capital punishment, the prosecution must obtain a conviction for first-degree murder and then prove to a jury, unanimously, the presence of at least one aggravating factor.

Advertise with us

The jurors must then find that the aggravators outweigh any mitigating evidence presented by the defense.

In the Smith case, the prosecution listed six potential aggravating factors it will attempt to prove. They include: the defendant committed the killing while in the perpetration of a felony; that he knowingly created a grave risk of death to another person in addition to the victims of the offense; that he has a significant history of felony convictions involving the use or threat of violence; that he has been convicted of another federal or state offense, committed either before or at the time of the offense at issue, for which a sentence of life imprisonment or death was possible; that he has been convicted of another murder before or at the time of the offense in question; and that the victim was a child less than 12 years old.

Police said Mr. Smith had a fight with Ricco Carter, Ms. Carter Douglas' son, at Spot Etc, a nightclub in Penn Hills, around 1:50 a.m.

Then, Mr. Smith is seen in surveillance photos driving to a gas station in Point Breeze, buying a gas can and filling it, and then driving away. That was at 2:10 a.m.

Investigators said Mr. Smith then doused the three-story brick house where Mr. Carter lived -- although he was not home at the time -- and set it on fire.

Advertise with us

The blaze was first reported at 2:21 a.m.

There are several people for whom the death penalty is currently being sought in Allegheny County. They include James Karr, accused of setting a fire that killed his wife in Duquesne in 2014; Roman Jones and Jonathan Coles, accused of killing a man in Crawford Village to prevent him from testifying in 2015;

Cesar Mazza, charged with killing his ex-girlfriend and her grandmother in East Hills in 2015; Cheron Shelton and Robert Thomas, accused of killing five people and an unborn child in Wilkinsburg in 2016; and Christian Clark, accused of killing her 17-month old son and recording it to send the video to the father in 2016.

As of Feb. 1, there were 154 men on Pennsylvania's Death Row, which is split between the state correctional institutions at Greene and Graterford. Nine of those inmates are from Allegheny County. No one has been executed in Pennsylvania since 1999.

In 2015, Gov. Tom Wolf issued a moratorium on the death penalty in the state as he awaited a long-anticipated report by the Pennsylvania Task Force and Advisory Committee on Capital Punishment.

In December 2016, the state Supreme Court upheld the moratorium while the report is finalized.