A hippopotamus is missing from Brookline. He’s concrete, a few feet tall and can squirt water out of his nose through copper pipes. He was a fixture at the neighborhood kiddie pool for more than two decades. Have you seen him?

For those who grew up in Brookline in the ’80s and ’90s, their worst fear is that their darling hippo is languishing in captivity — its concrete skin coated in dust at a dark warehouse near Butler Street.

But to find the truth is to follow a fine line between rumor and reality, and the only fact that neighborhood residents have to go by is that they haven’t seen their beloved hippo since it was removed during construction four years ago from its spot in the pool.

So they let their imaginations run wild.

Advertise with us

“It’s like in that Indiana Jones movie — the ‘Ark of the Covenant,’” said Doug Brendel, born and raised in Brookline. “It’s in this big warehouse somewhere with a number on it.”

There has been much chatter lately among Brookline residents about searching for the hippo, which resided in the pool as a playful fountain feature for children for more than two decades. It was taken away in 2013 by the city’s Department of Public Works during an overhaul of the Brookline Memorial Park, which replaced the pool with a dek hockey rink.

But the hippo is a reminder of simpler times, back in the 1980s and 1990s when children splashed in the hippo spray on warm summer days. It’s an endearing icon that residents say they’d like to see installed in front of their recreation center, or at least back in the neighborhood as the city intended. Time is of the essence, though, as the hippo’s situation could be “desperate,” as one resident put it. “What is the life expectancy of a hippo in captivity?” a post in a private neighborhood Facebook group read.

The hippo’s roots in the community date to the early 1980s, when the city added a swimming pool, two baseball fields and tennis courts to the park area. The pool opened in 1982, and the hippo took its place in the children’s wading area. A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette article from July 4, 1984, touted the spraying hippo fountain as one of the area’s must-see swimming pool attractions.

The Brookline pool closed in 2003, and a few years later the Penguins Foundation funded the construction of a public-use dek hockey rink on the site. It opened in December 2013, but the hippo statue was nowhere to be seen. Residents reported they saw it hauled away, strapped to a public works truck.

Advertise with us

That was the last time they saw the hippo, and everyone seems to have a theory about its current whereabouts. Some say Henry Cafardi has the answers, but the city’s longtime facilities maintenance supervisor said he has not been able to locate it. Others point to Mike Radley, who was director of parks from 2010 to 2013, but he said he doesn’t know, either.

The most compelling intel comes from Michelle Trapolsi-Underwood, who was director of the recreation center from 2005 to 2015. She said she knows for a fact where the hippo is: in a warehouse off Butler Street. Public works officials told her that’s where it was headed a few years ago.

They also said they would return it, she recalled.

“They told us it would go in the yard for kids to play on by the playground equipment,” Ms. Trapolsi-Underwood said. “They kept saying, ‘Oh, it’s there. It’s there.’ I’ve asked them to put it back. That was one of the last things I asked them to do.”

Mr. Brendel, 55, said he heard the hippo was supposed to be installed in one of the city’s spray parks, but doubts it ever made it there. On the neighborhood Facebook page, one resident volunteered to help with the “recon and capture” of the hippo, while another wished aloud that she would have chained herself to the hippo in protest back in 2013.

Advertise with us

Officials from the city’s public works department could not be reached for comment.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.