President Donald Trump on Wednesday nominated two lower court judges to fill longstanding vacancies on the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania -- almost two and a half years after the same two judges were nominated to the same posts by former President Barack Obama.
Judges Marilyn Jean Horan and Susan Paradise Baxter both were supported by Pennsylvania’s two senators and cleared bipartisan approval from the Senate Judiciary Committee in 2015 only to have their appointments to the federal bench derailed by partisan politics in the full Senate.
The result has been a Western Pennsylvania court that hasn’t operated with a full complement of judges for five years. If approved, Judge Horan would sit in Pittsburgh and Judge Baxter in Erie. The third division of the Western District sits in Johnstown.
By tradition, home-state senators form vetting committees to recommend potential candidates. The two senators then review the recommendation and present it to the president for nomination.
Judges Horan and Baxter were hailed at the time by Democratic Sen. Bob Casey Jr. as “highly skilled legal professionals who will bring fairness and integrity to their work on the federal bench.”
But Mr. Casey's effort was blocked by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., who opposed Mr. Obama’s judicial nominations.
Republican Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey, who was running for re-election in 2016, argued that it was important to move ahead on the confirmations, only to see his Democratic opponent’s campaign accuse him of “blatant hypocrisy" for Mr. Toomey’s refusal to move on Mr. Obama’s nomination of Judge Merrick Garland to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Mr. Toomey's proposal was blocked by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., who wanted a vote on all federal judges who had cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee, not just Pennsylvania's.
Judge Horan has been a Butler County Common Pleas Court judge since 1996. The first female judge in Butler County history, she serves in the court's civil division. From 1979 to 1996, Judge Horan worked at the law firm of Murrin, Taylor, Flach and Horan, where she rose to partner in 1982. She received her J.D. from the University of Pittsburgh School of Law in 1979 and her B.A. from Penn State University in 1976.
Judge Baxter has been a United States magistrate judge in the Western District since 1995. She served as chief magistrate judge from 2005 to 2009. Prior to her appointment to federal court, she worked briefly as the court solicitor for Erie County Common Pleas Court. From 1983 to 1992, she worked at the Washington, D.C., law firm of Cole, Raywid & Braverman (now Davis Wright Tremaine LLP), where she was a partner. She is a graduate of Temple University School of Law and also holds a M.Ed. from Temple and a B.S. from Penn State University.
There had been some concern among Democrats that the nominees might be too moderate for Mr. Trump, who had promised to appoint anti-abortion judges who would support conservative ideals. The White House announcement did not comment on the nominations.
The two judges are among 10 judicial nominees announced Wednesday by the White House and the ninth group put forward by the president this year. Judge Chad F. Kenney, who has served on Delaware County Common Pleas Court since 2003, was tapped for the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
The White House also announced the nomination of two U.S. attorneys, including William M. McSwain for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.