Saying his conduct "undermines public confidence" in the “good men and women” of the Pittsburgh police force, a federal judge on Wednesday sentenced a former city sergeant to more than two years in prison for beating up a drunk teenager outside Heinz Field.
U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon imposed a term of 27 months on Stephen Matakovich.
Prosecutors had asked for 27 to 33 months, saying Matakovich assaulted Gabriel Despres and then lied about it.
Matakovich and his lawyer, Tina Miller, argued for probation, saying he felt that Mr. Despres was going to attack him and that he had an exemplary career as an officer.
"There's more to me than 11 seconds of potential misinterpretation," Matakovich said.
But the judge said prison was necessary because Matakovich instigated the incident and then concocted a story to cover up what he'd done.
Read More
She said Matakovich's long career of service as an officer as outlined by character witnesses and many letters doesn't outweigh what he did to Mr. Despres, then 19, in 2015.
A jury in May convicted him of using excessive force against Mr. Despres during high school football playoffs. The jury found him not guilty of falsifying reports.
Surveillance footage from Heinz Field
Despite the jury's verdict on those reports, the judge agreed with the U.S. attorney's office that Matakovich should receive an enhanced sentence for obstructing justice because of those lies and his testimony at trial supporting them.
She said his story that Despres took actions, such as turning sideways and balling his fist as if to attack, was "plainly contradicted" by a video and witness statements.
Mr. Despres didn't testify. But his mother, Sherry Despres, said her son, while drunk, didn't deserve to be beaten by the much larger Matakovich. She said seeing her son attacked on the video made her sick.
"No mother should have to see that," she said.
Ms. Miller urged a sense of context. She said her client had spent many years going out of his way to help people and was well-regarded as an officer and leader in the department. She presented co-workers who testified about his work ethic and willingness to respond to any call.
Bill Mathias, a University of Pittsburgh police officer who worked with Matakovich on the city force, recalled an incident in which Matakovich handcuffed himself to a man on the Birmingham Bridge to keep him from jumping to his death.
"I can't say enough good things about him," he said.
Collier police Chief Craig Campbell, who also worked with Matakovich with the city, said he never had to worry if Matakovich had his back at a scene.
"Steve was there for me in countless life-threatening situations," he said.
In arguing against prison, Ms. Miller cited several other federal prosecutions of police in this district for civil-rights violations.
She said the Matakovich case was similar to that of Nicole Murphy, a Millvale officer convicted of using her Taser on a handcuffed prisoner. U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab gave her probation and community service, and Ms. Miller wanted the same for her client.
She had also cited former Springdale Officer Mark Thom Jr., who got a year in prison for punching and using a Taser on a handcuffed man. Ms. Miller argued that his case was different because he had been the subject of many complaints.
But that tactic, said Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung, opened the door for prosecutors to introduce Matakovich's disciplinary history, which included 34 complaints with the city's Office of Municipal Investigations, including 11 brought by citizens alleging too much force. Three of those were sustained, prosecutors said.
Ms. Chung said her office wouldn't have brought up the OMI complaints had Ms. Miller not referenced complaints in the Thom case.
Ms. Miller said citizen complaints are not evidence of wrongdoing.
"Complaints can be filed by anyone about anything," she said.
Matakovich made a similar point, saying he dealt mostly with drunks on the South Side who are unpredictable and sometimes violent.
"I'm going to have complaints filed against me," he said.
The judge took note of the complaints but said she recognized that they are not necessarily valid.
In addition to the prison term, she ordered Matakovich to pay $900 in restitution to Mr. Despres and serve three years of probation when he gets out. She said he'll be allowed to self-report to prison.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.