Many Americans no longer expect the truth from their elected leaders or the media. But even the courts — where participants swear to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth — have become increasingly unable to assert that it actually exists.

So argues Duquesne University law professor Bruce Ledewitz, who has co-convened a symposium titled “Resurrecting Truth in American Law and Public Discourse” being held Thursday and Friday. Mr. Ledewitz, a constitutional scholar and frequent commentator on legal issues, will join six other academics to address “law’s complicity in the death of truth,” and whether the legal system itself can be rehabilitated.

How did the idea for this conference arise?

It clearly arose out of the election and what a lot of people were thinking, which was, “Isn’t Donald Trump saying things that are plainly untrue, and people are accepting them anyway?”

Advertise with us

... [But] the people involved in the conference all agreed that there will be no bashing of particular politicians or parties. Neither side is exempt in the great chasm of American politics, and the problem has been building for a long time.

But aren't courts, at least, supposed to be the one place where contesting sides can determine the truth?

It’s not true. I wrote an article about two Supreme Court cases in June 1992 in which every justice on the court joined in an opinion that held values were subjective — either the dissent in Planned Parenthood v. Casey abortion decision or the majority in [Lee vs. Weisman], a case about prayer in high school. [Justice Antonin] Scalia, in his dissent in Planned Parenthood, said that nothing can be said about whether a fetus was a life because some cultures have said they are and others have said they aren't.

OK, but in a criminal trial, jurors still try to determine whether X shot Y, right? They don't just shrug and say "yeah, but what is truth, really?"

At the level of a criminal case in the court of Common Pleas, you still have a sense of truth, of right and wrong. But the higher up you go, the more sophisticated and expensive the law, the less that's the case. There's a reason nobody went to jail back after [the collapse of financial markets] in 2008....

Advertise with us

What can be done about that in a legal arena?

You have to start a tradition of honest inquiry. I think law school has to become the community in which people of very different views come together, and engage in common reasoning. Duquesne is not dogmatic, but in many places people now choose up sides, just like they do everywhere else. … If one faculty member is on the [conservative] Federalist Society, the other is a leftist.

And what impact does all this have outside the legal system?

Now every answer you get to everything is, "That's just a matter of your opinion," or "it’s not one side that does it. We've all done it." Just a few years ago, the country could decide Nixon was a crook. We can no longer agree on that. We can’t decide whether humans are warming the environment, or whether the Russians are meddling in our elections.

Every time somebody says there is no truth, and it's just a matter of opinion, an angel dies.