Point Breeze landlord Golan Barak tried Thursday to say he didn't mean it when he pleaded guilty in the spring to stealing millions from Israeli investors in a real-estate Ponzi scheme.
U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose didn't buy it.
After a lengthy hearing that saw heated sparring between Barak and a federal prosecutor, she denied his motion to withdraw his plea and said she'll sentence him in December on the plea he already entered in May.
Plea withdrawals are rarely granted in U.S. courts. The burden on defendants is high. They have to provide evidence of innocence and show that their lawyer was ineffective, among other steps.
Judge Ambrose said Barak couldn't do that.
Barak claimed his previous public defender, Skip Livingston, didn't understand his case, didn't listen to him, didn't return his calls or emails and pressured him to plead guilty.
"He did not have patience with me. I was very frustrated," Barak told the judge.
Mr. Livingston didn't testify and didn't return a message for comment; the federal public defender's office has a policy of not speaking to the media.
But Assistant U.S. Attorney Greg Melucci said Mr. Livingston did everything required during the case and the plea, and even if he didn't, Barak could have hired another lawyer before agreeing to enter the plea.
"Lawyers are a dime a dozen in this city," Mr. Melucci said.
He said Barak is a sophisticated businessman who knows his way around lawyers, having hired them in the past and having been sued repeatedly.
He also said his plea before Judge Ambrose was knowing and voluntary. Federal plea hearings are exercises in tedium in that prosecutors recite exactly what defendants are accused of, after which the judge asks them over and over if they did it and if they understand their rights.
"When you're in front of a federal judge, you're not in Kansas anymore," Mr. Melucci said.
Komron Maknoon, Barak's new lawyer, argued that his client's relationship with Mr. Livingston was strained and that it affected his plea. In addition to feeling "pressure," Barak said he also pleaded because he wanted to spare his family harm and because he is a "soldier" — he served in the Israeli Army — who lives by "principles."
"What were your principles in lying under oath?" the judge asked him.
She said she'll sentence him Dec. 7.
Barak, 50, a plumber by trade who owns seven businesses and controlled hundreds of properties in the region, was indicted last year on nine counts of wire fraud following a federal investigation into his real estate dealings.
He pleaded guilty to one of those counts involving more than $1 million given him by one investor.
The FBI and the IRS said he persuaded sophisticated investors from Israel and other countries to fly to Pittsburgh to become partners with him in buying and flipping houses in the city and suburbs.
He told them they would be able to enter into 50-50 partnerships with him in buying houses and then either selling them or managing them for rental income through companies he created.
Investors, many of whom have prepared victim impact statements for the U.S. attorney, said he used their money to buy properties other than the ones specified in agreements or used it to pay off earlier investors.
Mr. Melucci said some of their funds also went to run his property company, Ergo Management.
In all, according to the FBI, Barak ripped off investors of more than $2 million.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.