A nearly $555 million budget that would keep Pittsburgh tax rates flat in 2018 has cleared its first hurdle, positioning the plan for hearings before city council next month.
The city Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority board last week approved Mayor Bill Peduto’s fiscal blueprint, which lists $554.8 million for operating costs and $105 million for capital projects next year. His administration said the proposal would strengthen financial management while reinforcing core priorities, including police, fire protection and street repaving.
Operating expenses would climb close to 5 percent, but revenue from taxes, permits and some other sources is forecast to grow, too — up more than $13 million, or some 2.4 percent, over 2017, the proposal shows. Under the operating budget, that would place 2018 revenue at roughly $6 million more than expenses.
But two fiscal monitors questioned overall spending levels. Michael Danovitz, an ICA board member who abstained from last week’s budget vote, said the total expenses would be overkill.
And “I think it doesn’t do enough for the pension [obligations], but I’ve been saying that all along,” he said.
He also cited uncertainty over a prospective tax increase that could emerge as city council takes up budget discussions in November and December. Some council members have eyed an increase in realty transfer taxes in the city — bumping them from 4 percent to 5 percent — to pay for a $10 million trust fund for affordable housing.
Read More
Were that tax increase to materialize for 2018, Mr. Danovitz said, he doubts the budget would return to the full ICA board for approval.
“My concern is, I didn’t know what I was voting for, plain and simple,” he said.
The ICA is charged with overseeing city finances under state Act 47, the oversight mechanism that has guided the city’s financial recovery for more than a decade.
City Controller Michael Lamb said he’s concerned with long-term spending trends. Plans for 2018 would bring city spending some $100 million higher than it was five years ago, he said.
City council has until year’s end to finalize the budget.
“My concern with this budget is that, over the last five years, we’ve seen a pretty significant increase in spending and that the city needs to get control of that,” Mr. Lamb said.
He called the latest spike “a big chunk of money, some of it necessary,” including for pension obligations.
Mr. Peduto said he would address the criticism during his annual budget address to council on Nov. 13. City revenue is on track to outpace expenses by about $18 million under the 2017 operating budget, according to his proposal for next year.
“It’s important to note where we have increased spending,” the mayor said. “It’s hypocritical to complain that we’re not funding pensions fully when we spend more to fund pensions, then criticize that we’re spending too much. It’s hypocritical to say there aren’t enough police — and then, when we fund the additional police, firefighters, medics and building inspectors, complain that we’re spending too much. You’ve got to pick one side.”
Mr. Peduo acknowledged a tax increase — to pay for the affordable housing fund — could take shape but said his office is “willing to work with council to find alternative ways” to generate that revenue. He said he’s confident that an amendment to cover the fund will emerge before council in December.
Under the current budget proposal, spending increases would span several areas. Allocations under line items for pension obligations and retiree benefits would go up about $16 million to $91.6 million; for employee health benefits, up about $5 million to $69 million; for the fire bureau, up nearly $3 million to $75.3 million; and for the police bureau, up $1.5 million to $100.1 million. Plans include three police recruit classes and one firefighter recruit class.
One increase would support the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure, which formed this year and is absorbing some planning and public works functions. Its allocation would jump from about $400,000 to nearly $6 million.
The overall Peduto budget would pay for 3,147 full-time city jobs, a net uptick of about 10 positions from 2017, said Sam Ashbaugh, the chief financial officer under the mayor. Mr. Ashbaugh estimated that six or seven full-time jobs currently filled under the 2017 budget would not be included under the 2018 proposal.
City officials are working with affected employees, hoping to match them with vacancies elsewhere in city government, Mr. Ashbaugh said. He said those affected are scattered among the departments of finance, personnel, public works and innovation and performance.
“We’ve done a lot to transform city government. We’ve automated functions. We’ve changed the way business processes operate,” Mr. Ashbaugh said. “When we do those things and modernize city government, there is a people impact. People’s jobs, as they currently exist, change, and that requires training and change management so people are equipped to do those jobs. Sometimes jobs will be eliminated.”
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.