The accusations against Matthew Darby, charged this week with the murder of Alina Sheykhet, highlight the need for bail reform, state Victim Advocate Jennifer R. Storm said Friday, in reaction to a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette story highlighting a communication breakdown between counties.

"I think that this is a horrific tragedy that could have been prevented," said Ms. Storm, who has led the state Office of the Victim Advocate since 2013. "If that knowledge doesn't catapult people to be willing to make systematic changes in their counties, I don't know what will."

Mr. Darby, 21, of Greensburg, was charged with the February rape in Indiana County of a former girlfriend. In September, he was charged with criminal trespass at the home of another former girlfriend, Ms. Sheykhet, 20, of Oakland. In both cases, he was released on $10,000 bond, and there has as yet been no indication that officials in the two counties communicated or recognized the similarities between the allegations.

Ms. Sheykhet was found dead Sunday. Mr. Darby awaits transport from South Carolina to Pittsburgh, where he would await court appearances in the murder charge against him.

Advertise with us

Indiana County officials have said that an electronic notification promptly alerted them to the trespassing charge, but did not include details. They opted not to consider pretrial inceration until after the new case's preliminary hearing, which has not yet occurred.

"I don't know about you, but [a trespassing charge is] going to prompt me to investigate further," said Ms. Storm. "If they'd inquired, they would have found that he was at the bedroom door of a young female. That should send anyone's skin crawling."

"He has trespassed and come to the door of another female," said Ms. Storm. "He should have been incarcerated."

Ms. Storm outlined measures that could make it less likely that someone free while awaiting trial would commit multiple new crimes.

First, she said, "We need to be doing better in terms of information sharing."

Advertise with us

Second, all counties should have, and use, risk assessment software that suggests bail conditions, based in part on prior and pending criminal cases. The ultimate decision would remain with the magisterial district judge.

Third, counties should have policies that suggest appropriate ranges of responses when new charges are leveled against defendants who are free pending trial, especially in domestic violence cases.

Fourth, police should be able to arrest, on site, people reasonably suspected of violating the conditions of bail. "Law enforcement should be able to act and apprehend immediately," she said.

"You can't completely and totally prevent and predict extreme violent tendencies," she said. But you can "flag cases earlier to potentially prevent these acts."

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542. Twitter @richelord