A Pittsburgh police commander Wednesday called the death of University of Pittsburgh junior Alina Sheykhet "a tragic, senseless act of violence" but provided no insight into what might have driven the killer, who apparently attacked her with a claw hammer and two knives.

Many questions remained unanswered about Ms. Sheykhet's death in the second-floor bedroom of an Oakland apartment she shared with four roommates.

Although in court paperwork detectives described in detail the investigation that led them to arrest the 20-year-old's ex-boyfriend, Matthew Darby of Greensburg, on homicide and other charges, they provided scant information about a possible motive. They did not reveal -- and Cmdr. Vic Joseph would not discuss at a news conference -- how the killer got into the apartment on Cable Place. And it was left unclear how such an intimate and horrific crime was carried out with no one in the house hearing a scuffle.

Police in Myrtle Beach, S.C., arrested Mr. Darby, 21, after a report came in at 12:48 a.m. Wednesday about a man "tampering" at a private residence. Officers apprehended Mr. Darby and soon learned he was wanted on the homicide charge in Pittsburgh. He was charged by authorities there with loitering and resisting arrest.

Advertise with us

A judge in South Carolina denied Mr. Darby bond on his fugitive warrant from Pennsylvania. He is being held until he can be extradited to Pittsburgh to face charges of homicide, burglary, possessing instruments of crime, theft and flight to avoid apprehension..

"We have waived extradition," Mr. Darby's attorney, David J. Shrager, said, adding that bond of $2,000 was set in connection with the Myrtle Beach charges, which have been scheduled for a hearing Oct. 24. "Now that we've waived extradition, I can allow that case to hopefully quickly be resolved so I can address these matters here."

In a criminal complaint laying out the evidence used to arrest Mr. Darby, Pittsburgh police said that after Ms. Sheykhet's body was found by her parents, they "immediately" learned of a "tumultuous" relationship she had with Mr. Darby.

Pittsburgh police had charged Mr. Darby with felony criminal trespass in connection with a Sept. 20 incident. Ms. Sheykhet told police that she was asleep when just after 1 a.m. she heard a "commotion" outside her door and then watched the door swing open. Mr. Darby stood in the doorway and said he "just wanted to talk," according to a criminal complaint.

A roommate called police, and Mr. Darby left by car. Officers found a second-story window that had been pushed in.

Advertise with us

Ms. Sheykhet got a temporary restraining order -- which Pittsburgh police said was served Oct. 5 on Mr. Darby by the Westmoreland County Sheriff's Office -- and described in her petition an abusive relationship involving “grabbing," “pushing” and emotionally abusive behavior. She claimed that he had climbed up a gutter and broke through the window.

Mr. Darby was arrested Sept. 26. He was released on $10,000 bond. At that time, he was already out on a separate $10,000 bond in connection with rape, sexual assault and other charges stemming from a Feb. 19 incident involving an ex-girlfriend in Indiana, Pa.

Allegheny County President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning said a defendant still facing charges is presumed to be innocent and is entitled to bail unless he is a flight risk or is a proven danger to the community.

In Allegheny County, employees with pre-trial services make a recommendation as to whether a defendant should be released or held based on information such as criminal history, prior instances of failing to appear on charges, employment and living arrangements.

"We're now using new tools -- risk assessments -- to guard against these things reoccurring," Judge Manning said. "It's always a gamble."

Advertise with us

In the rape case, the woman told police that Mr. Darby called around 2 a.m. Feb. 19 and said he wanted to talk and apologize for things in the past. She agreed to see him, according to a police affidavit,

By 4:27 a.m. Mr. Darby had called her 33 times, police said. When they finally met at her apartment, according to the affidavit, Mr. Darby raped her. He was arrested and released on bond.

Indiana County District Attorney Patrick Dougherty said Mr. Darby was in his county's pretrial services program, meaning he had to report regularly to a probation officer. He was also barred from having any contact with the victim in that case.

The prosecutor did not take issue with the $10,000 bond. "Bond is considered to ensure attendance" at court hearings, he said. "That's the main reason to consider bond. It's not flashy, but defendants are still innocent until proven guilty in this country."

Mr. Dougherty said that his office, and his county's probation department, received a prompt, computer-generated notice following the filing of the trespassing charge, through the Pennsylvania Justice Network, or JNET, system. He said the technology worked as intended, and is adequate to let one Pennsylvania county know of new charges filed against a defendant in another county.

Advertise with us

"I know we were aware that he had some pending stuff in Allegheny County, but he had not been through a preliminary hearing yet, and generally speaking that's when our probation officers tend to act," Mr. Dougherty said. "Usually, they wait to see if the charges are held at a preliminary hearing," because that's when probable cause is confirmed by a judge, he said.

Prior to this weekend, Mr. Darby was complying with his conditions of bond and appearing in court when required to do so, said Mr. Dougherty. "He was actually in our courthouse on Friday," when his case was postponed until Nov. 3, said the prosecutor. "His rape charge was progressing through the system at [its] normal course.

"In this case, until this weekend, we had no reason to treat him any differently than any other defendant," Mr. Dougherty said.

Following the filing of the trespassing case, his office had the option to seek a revocation of bond and ask a judge for a detainer under which Mr. Darby could have been held in the Allegheny County Jail. "Could that conceivably have happened? Yes," Mr. Dougherty said. "In the normal course of business, I don't think it would've. We can play Monday morning quarterback all day. We have to establish probable cause before we revoke bond."

He said his office did not know about the restraining order filed against Mr. Darby by Ms. Sheykhet on Sept. 27, but added that accusation, made in civil court, would not likely have prompted a bond revocation.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dougherty said the subsequent events certainly bothered him.

"It's disturbing knowing that here's an individual that was in court on Friday, and going through the system. We don't have crystal balls in this system. I don't think anybody could have comprehended that this individual would have done what he did on Friday or over the weekend," if the murder accusations are accurate, he said. "It's terribly shocking, it's terribly sad, and sure, you wish that something could have been done differently."

Upon review, though, he does not think any mistakes were made, based on the available facts, he said.

On Tuesday, his office started the process to revoke bond, which will likely continue even though "it's moot" at this point, said Mr. Dougherty.

After Ms. Sheykhet's parents found her body about 8:30 a.m. Sunday, police used video surveillance footage, cell phone records and interviews to document Mr. Darby’s movements, according to a criminal complaint.

Advertise with us

They learned that Ms. Sheykhet was last seen alive by roommates at 12:30 a.m. Sunday in her apartment's common area. About 30 minutes later, she sent one of her roommates a picture by phone.

The trail next picked up at 3:19 a.m., when police said surveillance video showed Mr. Darby at Duquesne University. At 4:15 a.m. two calls -- apparently unanswered -- were placed from Mr. Darby's cell phone, with a Michigan area code, to Ms. Sheykhet's, according to records reviewed by investigators. Six minutes later, a car service picked up Mr. Darby to take him to Oakland. He got out at Semple and Ward streets, near Cable Place.

Police did not record in the complaint the exact time Mr. Darby arrived in Oakland. But investigators said he asked the car service driver to wait 10 minutes; then asked him in person to wait another 10 minutes; and finally, five minutes later, called to request another 10 minutes. The driver said he couldn't and left.

At 4:54 a.m. and 4:55 a.m., police said, three unanswered calls were made from Mr. Darby's phone to Ms. Sheykhet's.

Police said Mr. Darby was caught on surveillance video walking on Urie Way toward Semple Street with what appeared to be some type of light in his hand. At Urie and Semple, Mr. Darby knelt and dropped a shiny object into a sewer grate, the complaint said. A little farther along Urie he dropped another object into a trash bin, according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

In the sewer, police found a claw hammer and two stainless steel knives they believe were used to kill Ms. Sheykhet.

Just as Ms. Sheykhet's friends and family have expressed shock at her death, those who know Mr. Darby were also surprised. The 5-foot-10 Mr. Darby had lived in Cranberry, went to Seneca Valley High School and played basketball as a guard for Pitt-Greensburg.

He was dismissed from the team around Feb. 11 by then-head coach Sean Strickland, who declined to explain the decision. That was eight days before the incident that led to rape charges against Mr. Darby.

Nick Anderson, 24, a former Pitt-Greensburg basketball player who played during the 2013-2016 seasons, said Mr. Strickland had described the freshman recruiting class as particularly strong the year Mr. Darby arrived. "He was supposed to be one of our stars coming in," Mr. Anderson said.

Mr. Anderson described all his interactions with Darby as normal or positive. The summer before Mr. Darby's freshman year, he had stayed at Mr. Anderson's house before a Fourth of July tournament. He recalled Mr. Darby as nothing but polite and respectful to Mr. Anderson's parents.

Advertise with us

"There was absolutely no inclination of him being a criminal," Mr. Anderson said.

At Pitt-Greensburg, Mr. Anderson said, Mr. Darby was "very undisciplined" in that he would need to be reminded to take an itinerary for away games at the end of practices or would sometimes show up late. Mr. Anderson remembered Mr. Darby's parents as supportive, showing up to games as often as they could.

The last time Mr. Anderson saw Mr. Darby was last fall, when he came back to Greensburg to receive a championship ring.

Alaina Lisovich, 20, of Penn Township, said she worked with Mr. Darby last summer at an American Eagle.

"He seemed like such a nice guy. We would go on lunch breaks together," Ms. Lisovich said.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth. Amanda Zhou: 412 263 1130 or azhou@post-gazette.com. Twitter @amondozhou. Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1542 or on Twitter @richelord. Paula Reed Ward contributed.