County Children and Youth Services caseworkers are not adequately trained, are burdened by overwhelming caseloads and paperwork, and earn “a remarkably low salary given the educational requirements, daily work complexity and potentially dangerous components of the job,” according to a report Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale released Thursday examining county child welfare systems.
Those factors cause high caseworker turnover, and further impact the ability of caseworkers to adequately protect kids, Mr. DePasquale said Thursday.
The 80-page report looked at Allegheny, Bucks, Cambria, Centre, Crawford, Dauphin, Delaware, Erie, Fayette, Luzerne, Monroe, Philadelphia, and York counties, a range of urban, suburban and rural locations. Each of the state's 67 counties administer their own children and youth services agency, with state oversight.
The report recommends the Department of Human Services and update all job descriptions, which in the instance of some caseworker positions have not been updated in more than 20 years; reduce certain paperwork requirements; appoint an independent child protection ombudsman, who could recommend systemic improvements; encourage counties to hire more clerical aides to assist with paperwork and increase salaries where possible.
Here is the auditor general’s State of the Child report:
STATE of the CHILD RPT CYS 091417 FINAL (PDF)
Read More
STATE of the CHILD RPT CYS 091417 FINAL (Text)
The average starting salary for a new caseworker in the 13 counties was $30,018.
The turnover rate for Allegheny County caseworkers is 15 percent and the current average salary for an Allegheny County children, youth and families caseworker is $37,211, according to a spokeswoman.
The report also recommends DHS examine the predictive risk modeling used in Allegheny County to determine its usefulness in other counties. The Allegheny Family Screening tool is a computer tool that aims to help child protection staff make better decisions and focus on the most at-risk kids.
Many of the recommendations of the report were already being discussed or considered in some way, said Cathy Utz, deputy secretary for Children, Youth and Families at the state Department of Human Services, such as the creation of an ombudsman and updating job descriptions for caseworker positions. Other changes would need to come from counties, such as salary increases for caseworkers.
"We are a system that is constantly looking to see how we can do things differently," she said.
In 2015, numerous child protective services laws were updated, expanding the definition of what was considered child abuse and increasing the number of people considered "mandated reporters" -- professions who have frequent contact with children and are mandated to report abuse. Child abuse reports subsequently surged, overwhelming staff in some counties.
Cathleen Palm, a child protection advocate, said she applauded the recommendation of the creation of an independent ombudsman.
“Pennsylvania’s child welfare structure too rarely lends itself to transparency or accountability undercutting the identification of systemic issues that impact, not just one child, but also the collective community of children,” she said in prepared statement.
A statement from advocacy group the Pennsylvania Family Support Alliance endorsed some recommendations, such as streamlining the volume of paperwork required of caseworkers, decreasing their caseloads and strengthening their training to include real-life family scenarios.
Rather than create a children’s ombudsman at DHS, the organization suggested reviewing staffing patterns and job functions in state and regional offices.
In 2016, 46 children died and 79 nearly died statewide from abuse and neglect, the report notes.
The full report is available online at http://www.paauditor.gov/.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.