Town halls are supposed to be a place for healthy political discourse, where constituents can directly engage with their representatives.
Oh, how idealistic.
In reality, they’re often venues for shouting matches, political gaffes, awkward moments and controversy -— like last week’s incident at Sen. Pat Toomey’s town hall in Bethlehem, where an attendee was promptly removed by police after asking the senator a cringeworthy question that suggested Mr. Toomey’s daughter had been kidnapped.
The audio is cut from this clip, but you can hear the ensuing awkwardness:
The full context of the question can be found here, but where does this moment stack up against some of Pennsylvania’s oddest and most memorable town hall moments? Let’s recap them.
1) Former Democratic Sen. Arlen Specter was forced to listen to quite the monologue from an angry constituent at a town hall in 2009. Pointing a finger in the senator’s face, the man repeatedly called him a “crony,” and appeared to call down the power of God. “One day, God’s going to stand before you and he’s going to judge you and the rest of your damn cronies up on the Hill!” To which Mr. Specter responded, calmly, “We’ve just had a demonstration of democracy.”
Read More
2) With the full 685-page Obamacare bill in hand, current Democratic Sen. Bob Casey looked a bit flustered in 2009 as critics at a town hall questioned the bill’s constitutionality. Instead of answering specifics, he encouraged people to bring up a lawsuit if they had criticisms. “We don’t have the money,” shouted some in the crowd.
3) In a nationally televised town hall in December, former Republican Sen. Rick Santorum listened intently as Elizabeth Vilchis -—a mechanical engineer who said she immigrated to the U.S. from Mexico when she was a child -— expressed her fears over Donald Trump’s immigration plans. “I will lose my career and will potentially be labeled for deportation,” Ms. Vilchis said. The former senator said the woman had “been given a tremendous benefit by being here in this country,” and pointed out that she has the ability to go to another country now and reapply to come back to America. Mr. Santorum was then blasted by CNN contributor Ana Navarro.
4) Current Republican Rep. Scott Perry could barely get a word in at a town hall in March. He was shouted down and booed by constituents who yelled, “Tax the Rich!” and blasted his support of cuts to the Environmental Protection Agency. Lucky for him, he had about 10 awkward feet separating him from the crowd.
5) Current Republican Rep. Glenn Thompson was berated by a constituent last month in the form of a long question. The man, who identified himself as Max from State College, brought up the Republican effort to repeal Obamacare. Calling Mr. Thompson’s vote for the replacement bill “despicable” and “reprehensible,” he pleaded with the Congressman to let him finish his question. Mr. Thompson’s response was long-winded, but he ended it with a tongue-in-cheek, “I think you’ll find we share the same concerns, I just find solutions for them.”
6) Current Republican Rep. Lou Barletta couldn’t help but smile and chuckle at a constituent’s angry tirade at a town hall in 2011, but that wasn’t helping ease tensions. “You’re our Congressman, don’t laugh at us!” one woman yelled. Without saying a word, Mr. Barletta walked around, smiled some more and sat casually on a folding table. “Sit down, you’ve said enough,” the representative said eventually, and didn’t address the questions.
7) In front of a radio station’s backdrop, former Democratic Rep. Joe Sestak was shouted down by protesters in 2009 as he tried to say he doesn’t look at government from a political perspective, but from a factual perspective. As soon as he was met by a thunderous uproar, the moderator playfully tapped him on the back, as if saying, “Joe, you shouldn’t have went there, pal.”
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.