Worried robots are taking your jobs? According to data recently published by Mark Muro of the Brookings Institute, there has not yet been much of that in Pittsburgh. Among America's 100 biggest metropolitan areas, Pittsburgh ranks 69th in industrial robots per worker, with just one robot to every thousand workers.

Job automation probabilities compiled by Oxford professors Martin Osborne and Carl Benedikt Frey, however, show that there may be more automation coming in the future. Their predictions, combined with Bureau of Labor Statistics data, suggest that more than half of Pittsburgh area jobs are at risk of being computerized.

Using data from the International Federation of Robots, which surveys robot manufacturers, Mr. Muro found that industrial robots are concentrated mostly in the South and the Midwest. Nearly half of North American industrial robots are used in the auto industry.

Two local industries, basic metals and chemicals, also are among the top 10 industries, each taking 2 percent of the North American robot market share, but, said Mr. Muro, "Pittsburgh manufacturing disappeared too soon to be automated. That's why Pittsburgh, this great industrial city, isn't really on the list."

Advertise with us

Among regional metropolitan areas, Youngstown-Warren-Boardman, which is mostly in Ohio, leads the way in robots per worker, followed by Reading. Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, and Harrisburg are all near the bottom of the list.

Pittsburgh isn't exactly overflowing with robots

Pennsylvania metropolitan statistical areas by number of industrial robots, and industrial robots per thousand workers.

Frank Giarratani, an emeritus professor of economics at the University of Pittsburgh, said that while the steel industry “has been forced by competition to figure out how to get more work done with fewer workers,” it was largely not through robots. Other efficiency increases, like skipping the ingot stage of refining, reduced costs.

Mr. Giarratani also pointed to cases like scrap metal sorting and handling, where work that used to be done by steel workers is now done by contractors. “Steel employment goes down and service employment goes up,” he said.

Indeed, service employment has overtaken manufacturing as the primary profession across most of the country, due to both reclassification like that and due to real industry shifts. Even as American manufacturing rebounded following the recession, manufacturing employment did not.

Advertise with us

Unfortunately, according to Mr. Frey and Mr. Osborne's predictions, many of those service jobs are among the most computerizable. Pittsburgh's five biggest job categories includes only one, registered nurses, to which they did not assign a higher than nine in 10 chance of being computerized. The top job, retail sales, they gave a 92 percent probability.

Mr. Frey and Mr. Osborne base the prediction on potential of being standardized to a sufficient extent for a computer to perform the task, but they do not give a precise time frame, other than, “perhaps a decade or two.” Their predictions are no guarantees, and even if a task could potentially be automated, it does not mean it can be automated for cheaper than paying a person to do it, or that the personal touch will not make up the difference.

There are two service industry jobs that have been computerized that peple encounter on a regular basis, though: bank tellers and grocery store cashiers, who now share space with ATMs and self-checkout machines.

The introduction of automated technologies like these does not necessarily spell job losses. A 2015 analysis by the International Monetary Fund found that as US ATM installations accelerated, teller job growth continued. As ATMs took over basic teller duties, the number of tellers per branch declined, so banks could afford to open more branches, in the end employing more tellers.

Richard Roberts, a spokesperson for Giant Eagle, said per-store employment was largely steady before and after the introduction of self-checkout machines. “This technology also serves as an effective solution during peak business hours when many lanes are simultaneously occupied, as well as off-peak times that can be more challenging to staff.”

Advertise with us

Elsewhere in the country, fast-food chains including McDonald's are rolling out self-order kiosks.

Another visible area of automation is transportation, with Uber's pilot self-driving cars program in the city. Currently, there are twice as many jobs per self-driving car as per regular car, with a back-up driver plus an engineer in the driver's seat, but that is not the permanent plan.

Uber could not be reached for comment, but Travis Kalanick, the former CEO of Uber, said in a 2016 interview in Business Insider that the company’s long-term plan was to have such big fleets that even if a small portion have drivers, they would have more drivers than they do now.

Other than ambulance drivers, Mr. Frey and Mr. Osborne rate driving professions at 69 percent or higher probability of computerization.

Frank Menchaca, chief product officer for SAE International, which sets product standards in transportation industries, said, “The infrastructure is the limiting factor” on commercial autonomous car rollout. “The technology is there.” Building and designing that infrastructure will require new jobs, Mr. Menchaca pointed out.

Advertise with us

“Pittsburgh knows the effects of technological disruption,” said Timothy McNulty, spokesperson for Mayor Bill Peduto. "Mayor Peduto is pushing for the city to not only be a research hub on automation but a manufacturing center, too, which would create a new jobs sector."

Software development joins the medical professions among major Pittsburgh job classes that have low probabilities of automation.

Christopher Huffaker: chuffaker@post-gazette.com.

Editor’s note: This story has been updated to correct the spelling of the last name of Frank Menchaca.