Thick, choking blackness smothered Shawn Butchko as soon as she stepped into the hallway of Midtown Towers, an 18-story apartment building Downtown, early Monday morning.

She held tight to a firefighter’s hand.

“I tried to breathe but I couldn’t at all,” she said. “I started to scream but then I realized I better save my air. It was pitch black, just pitch black.”

With the firefighters’ help, she made it to the stairwell and survived the 7-alarm fire, which left one woman dead, displaced about 100 other residents and renewed questions about the city’s sprinkler requirements. It wasn’t clear when the tenants may return home.

Advertise with us

“Sprinklers have been around for about 100 years now — a little more. And in that 100-year time, there has never been a fatality as a result of fire in a building with a working sprinkler system,” Pittsburgh fire Chief Darryl E. Jones said. He advocated tougher sprinkler requirements but said he doesn’t “have any control over that.”

The 18-story high-rise at 643 Liberty Ave. was not equipped with a sprinkler system because it was not required to be, said Ray Czachowski, executive vice president at NDC Real Estate Management, which has managed the building since the 1970s. Built in 1907, it is one of the oldest high-rises in Pittsburgh, and now houses a mix of low-income and market-rate tenants.

City inspectors last examined the building in March 2016, at which time no violations were found, said Katie O’Malley, communications coordinator for Mayor Bill Peduto.

Yet fire officials have called for sprinklers to be installed in the building before — once nearly two decades ago after a fire on the 13th floor forced a similar evacuation in 1999. At that time, acting fire chief Peter Micheli called it a “classic example” of why sprinklers are needed in high rises.

7-alarm fire in Downtown Pittsburgh: 1 dead, 3 firefighters injured

Monday’s blaze began around 3 a.m. on the sixth floor — the same floor where 75-year-old Mary Robinson died, although investigators could not say Monday whether the fire began in her apartment.

Advertise with us

Ms. Robinson died from heat and inhalation injuries, according to the Allegheny County medical examiner’s office. Three firefighters and two residents suffered minor injuries.

Two men who were talking outside the building spotted flames shooting out of a window and rushed inside to warn residents.

Ricco J.L. Martello, 41, and Ryan Brown, 27, ran through the first six floors, banging on doors, but had to turn back when the smoke became too thick.

Before leaving the sixth floor, Mr. Martello knocked on the apartment door where the smoke and flames seemed to be coming from.

“Nobody answered,” he said. “No one said anything, no one answered the door.”

Advertise with us

As Mr. Martello and Mr. Brown retreated, they passed firefighters headed up, Mr. Brown said.

Pittsburgh fire Chief Darryl E. Jones said the fire was difficult to fight and that several firefighters were trapped at one point while fighting the blaze.

“They were trapped for some time,” he said. “There were a couple of ‘mayday’ calls ... for firefighters in trouble.”

After initially getting the fire under control, firefighters discovered that the blaze was still burning within the building’s walls, jumping between the seventh and 10th floors in a pipe chase, a space often used to run utilities, Chief Jones said.

The sixth and seventh floors suffered the most damage, he said. The cause of the fire is under investigation.

Advertise with us

***

City officials addressed the issue of sprinklers at a press conference Monday afternoon. Maura Kennedy, director of the city Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections, said such mandatory safety upgrades to a structure would be prompted by a change of use in the building — or a building rehabilitation of greater than 50 percent of the structure. Neither of those had happened at the high-rise, she said. "Code changes are not applied retroactively."

Ms. Kennedy said that it would take a code change to toughen sprinkler and other fire suppression requirements — and it would have to be approved by the state.

Asked how many other buildings like this one are in the city — large, residential or office buildings that don't have sprinklers, Ms. Kennedy said: "We are working to do pro-active inspections of all these structures." She said a pro-active fire safety inspection program lapsed in 2004 and was restarted in 2015.  She said all structures with violations identified in this program are noted on a city website: pittsburghpa.gov/pli/buildingeye.   These pro-active inspections are done Downtown, in high rises, schools, special assembly spaces, night clubs and other places with greater likelihood of fire to make sure all fire safety systems are operating correctly. Ms. Kennedy said those systems can include sprinklers, fire exits, emergency lights, elevator recalls and fire escapes.

"Pittsburgh is an old city, and this code requirement for sprinklers in high-rise structures did not become universal until 1990."

Advertise with us

Asked if the lapse in inspections set the city back, she said:  "I think it's an important function the city was right to revive. We need to make sure we are inspecting these places before an emergency strikes to make sure all the response systems are happening correctly. In this case, the fire alarm did function, and it called the emergency response systems, and people were able to respond in a timely manner. It obviously would have been much worse if it had failed to do so."

Mr. Czachowski could not say Monday how long repairs will take or when residents might be able to return home.

“We don’t have clue at this point,” he said. “We’ve got to see exactly what the extent of the damage is before we can do anything.”

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow on Twitter @ShellyBradbury. Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow on Twitter @ShellyBradbury. Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com.